Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The core appeal of the Gunslinger Collection lies in its straightforward, fast-paced light-gun action. Each of the three titles—Mad Dog McCree, Mad Dog II: The Lost Gold, and Crime Patrol—leans heavily on on-rails shooting sequences where quick reflexes and accurate aim make all the difference. Whether you’re facing down outlaw bands in dusty frontier towns or fending off a masked bandit crew in the search for lost treasure, the feeling of pulling off a perfect shot never grows stale.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Mad Dog McCree sets the stage with its simple “draw your weapon and fire” mechanics, pitting you against a host of gung-ho desperados in real-time FMV sequences. Its follow-up, Mad Dog II: The Lost Gold, adds a modest layer of exploration by offering branching paths when you uncover maps and clues, giving the gameplay a sense of discovery beyond point-and-shoot showdowns. Crime Patrol diverges slightly by transporting you to more modern settings—train robberies, bank heists, and even a daring cat burglar scenario—while preserving that same arcade-style immediacy.

While light-gun veterans will appreciate the razor-sharp timing windows and precision targeting, newcomers might find the trial-and-error process a bit jarring. Each misfire or missed shot can lead to an abrupt “you’re dead” screen, forcing you back to the last checkpoint. However, the collection’s built-in rewind or checkpoint skips in non-gun controller modes soften the learning curve. Overall, the gameplay loop is relentless but rewarding, providing short bursts of high-tension action that feel tailor-made for weekend sessions.

Graphics

The Gunslinger Collection’s graphics are a loving time capsule of early ’90s FMV technology. You’ll immediately notice the live-action video sequences, complete with worn edges, grainy textures, and the occasional overexposed set piece that hints at the modest production budgets of the era. This retro aesthetic is more charming than it is cutting-edge, offering a genuine throwback vibe that enthusiasts of vintage gaming will adore.

Each game’s environments are distinct yet consistent in their campy, B-movie flair. Mad Dog McCree and its sequel lean heavily into dusty saloons, moonlit canyons, and saloon brawls, all shot on soundstages that feel authentically “Western.” Crime Patrol sharpens the lens with more modern locales—railroad stations, city streets, and armored car ambush sites—delivering slightly cleaner visuals but retaining that signature FMV softness.

While you won’t find advanced shaders or dynamic lighting here, the grainy, washed-out palette lends a nostalgic charm that more polished graphics often lack. The occasional frame hitch or mismatched audio cue only enhances the kitschy appeal. For players seeking sleek, modern visuals, this collection may feel rough around the edges—but for fans of period-correct FMV, it’s pure gold.

Story

The narrative threads in the Gunslinger Collection are delightfully thin but serve their purpose—setting up each shootout with a dash of spaghetti-Western melodrama. In Mad Dog McCree, you’re thrust into a town terrorized by the eponymous outlaw, armed with nothing but your wits and a trusty six-shooter. Each confrontation builds toward a final face-off that feels tense precisely because the stakes—your life—hang in the balance.

Mad Dog II: The Lost Gold cranks up the adventure by promising hidden riches buried deep in uncharted canyons. As you track down maps stolen by clever bandits, the story gains a light Indiana Jones flavor, complete with treacherous ambushes and double-crossing treasures hunters. It’s a simple setup, but the branching paths fuel curiosity: which trail leads to fortune, and which to your demise?

Crime Patrol breaks the mold by transporting you to a series of modern heist scenarios orchestrated by a faceless crime syndicate. Whether you’re protecting train passengers from masked robbers or foiling a jewel theft at a gated mansion, the episodic structure keeps the pace brisk. Dialogue is minimal and often campy, but it sets the scene quickly so you can dive straight into the action. All told, the stories are more framing devices than deep narratives, but they’re delivered with enough flair to keep players engaged between cinematic shoot-outs.

Overall Experience

As a single purchase, the Gunslinger Collection offers a compelling retro package for fans of FMV shooters and nostalgic oddities. The three included titles run the gamut from classic frontier showdowns to modern crime standoffs, ensuring that every session delivers fresh set pieces and a variety of challenges. Even after decades, those quick-draw moments still pack a jolt of excitement.

Modern conveniences such as adjustable difficulty settings, checkpoint skips, and mouse/dual-stick compatibility make these otherwise vintage titles surprisingly accessible. While die-hard purists might lament the loss of original light-gun support, the alternative controls are responsive enough to preserve the core thrill. The collection’s interface is straightforward, with a unified launcher allowing you to hop between games seamlessly.

Ultimately, Gunslinger Collection is best suited for players with a taste for retro kitsch and arcade-style gunplay. Its stories won’t rewrite the Western canon, and its graphics won’t rival today’s blockbusters. But for anyone seeking a bite-sized feast of point-and-shoot nostalgia, this multi-pack is a wildly entertaining trip through the dusty backroads of FMV history. It’s a must-have for collectors and a fun curiosity for casual gamers looking to experience a bygone era.

Retro Replay Score

null/10