Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Submarine Commander puts you squarely in the captain’s chair, armed with only a periscope, a handful of torpedoes, and your wits. From the moment you dive beneath the waves, you’ll juggle fuel consumption, torpedo stockpiles, and the ever-scanning radar as enemy destroyers and cargo ships bustle overhead. The tension ramps up quickly, especially as depth charges start raining down when you’re detected. Every decision—whether to surface for a quick scan or stay submerged and silent—carries weight.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The game features eight distinct difficulty settings, each adding new layers of complexity. Beginners can focus on basic tracking and firing two torpedoes at a time, while hardcore captains must contend with limited fuel, tighter torpedo reserves, and more aggressive enemy AI. On higher settings, enemy ships move faster, depth-charge volleys become more precise, and even your radar has a shorter effective range. This gradual ramp ensures there’s always something new to master.

One of the standout mechanics is the dual tracking system. You can line up a visual shot through the 360-degree periscope or switch to radar mode to intercept high-speed targets that simply zoom past your viewfinder. Coordinating between visual targeting and radar pings creates a thrilling cat-and-mouse dynamic. Balancing risk and reward—should you run on low fuel to chase a fast freighter?—keeps every mission fresh and addictive.

Graphics

While Submarine Commander isn’t aiming for hyper-realism, its stylized visuals deliver clarity and atmosphere in equal measure. The water effects shimmer convincingly under various light conditions, and subtle wave motion around your periscope lends authenticity to the experience. Enemy vessels are easily distinguishable by silhouette and color-coding, making split-second targeting decisions straightforward even in low-visibility conditions.

The periscope view is impressively rendered, with a circular viewport that smoothly rotates a full 360 degrees. Horizons fade into mist, rain streaks across the glass during storms, and distant ship silhouettes slowly sharpen as you close the gap. Underwater views are suitably murky, reminding you that lurking danger may be just beyond sonar range. All these touches reinforce the solitude and tension of submarine warfare.

HUD elements like fuel gauges, torpedo counters, and radar blips stay unobtrusive yet informative. The designers struck a fine balance between immersion and usability: you never have to struggle to read your instruments, but you still feel like you’re peering through real submarine optics. Overall, the graphical presentation enhances gameplay without showing off, putting function and mood above flashy effects.

Story

Though Submarine Commander is primarily a gameplay-driven experience, it weaves a taut narrative of naval cat-and-mouse across its missions. You play a lone sub captain deep in enemy waters, cut off from reinforcements and supply lines. Each patrol becomes a test of endurance and tactical foresight as you hunt convoys and evade destroyer escorts. Briefing texts before each mission hint at strategic objectives—interdict supply lines, cripple heavy warships, or rescue allied assets under fire.

There’s no sprawling cast of characters or cinematic cutscenes, but the game’s minimalist story approach works in its favor. The sparse radio chatter from your commanding officer, urgent mission updates, and intermittent distress signals build a sense of world and duty without slowing down the action. You feel the weight of every torpedo fired and every drop of fuel burned, giving each successful engagement a satisfying narrative payoff.

The escalating difficulty settings double as a narrative arc, too. Early missions feel like reconnaissance sorties, while later assignments turn into desperate gambits to cripple a well-armed enemy fleet. By the time you face those lightning-fast supply ships that require pure radar tracking, you’ve already lived through enough narrow escapes and depth-charge barrages to appreciate the sub’s every creak and groan.

Overall Experience

Submarine Commander delivers a compelling blend of strategy, tension, and resource management that keeps you hunched over the controls. Every dive feels like a puzzle—monitoring your fuel, lining up torpedo shots, scanning the horizon, and listening for depth-charge explosions all at once. The learning curve is satisfying, with new mechanics and higher stakes introduced progressively across the eight difficulty tiers.

Replayability is high. You can experiment with aggressive hit-and-run tactics or adopt a stealthier playstyle, stalking targets from miles away on radar before closing in for the kill. The balanced risk-reward loop and unpredictable ship patterns mean no two patrols play out the same. For players who relish mastering systems and outsmarting adaptive AI, Submarine Commander offers hundreds of hours of undersea warfare.

While the game’s focus on mechanics over cinematic storytelling may not appeal to everyone, it will enthrall fans of classic naval sims and tactical suspense. If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like to command a submarine in hostile waters—or simply crave a deep, engaging challenge—Submarine Commander is a voyage worth taking.

Retro Replay Score

6.3/10