Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Pretender: Part One places you in the shoes of Laurence, a 19th-century stage magician unexpectedly thrust into a mystical realm. Your primary objective is straightforward yet compelling: locate your scattered audience members and guide them back to the exit portal one at a time. Each rescued spectator reappears in the real world, and retrieving them all feels like reclaiming fragments of Laurence’s lost legacy.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Puzzles are the heart of this adventure. You’ll traverse four distinct level sets, each offering a mix of five essential puzzle stages and at least one optional story challenge. The game grants unlimited lives and quick resets, eliminating any sense of frustration and encouraging experimentation. Bottomless pits, water traps, and massive boulders stand in your way, creating a delicate balance between trial-and-error play and thoughtful planning.

Laurence’s innate magic is limited at first: a simple flash that barely illuminates his path. Thankfully, mystical glyphs scattered across each stage imbue him with powerful elemental abilities. Step on a rock glyph to become a rock-man, able to shove boulders aside or break brittle rock floors. Activate an air glyph and you transform into a wispy form, drifting on gentle breezes and generating gusts strong enough to blow sailboats or lift you high. A neutral glyph returns Laurence to his normal self, preserving puzzle balance.

As you progress, puzzles grow in complexity, cleverly combining elemental powers and environmental hazards. Timing, positioning, and choosing the right form are all critical. The ability to reset the map at any time means you can methodically test new strategies without penalty, making each success feel earned and rewarding. The optional story levels add a welcome narrative twist to what might otherwise be a strictly cerebral experience.

Graphics

The Pretender: Part One boasts a beautifully hand-painted art style that blends Victorian-era aesthetics with dreamlike fantasy landscapes. Backgrounds evoke ornate theater curtains, rusted machinery, and overgrown ruins, creating an atmosphere that feels at once familiar and otherworldly. Each level set has its own visual motif, ensuring environments never grow stale.

Animations are smooth and purposeful. Laurence’s transformations between normal, rock-man, and air forms are accompanied by subtle visual flourishes—stone textures crackle around him, or wisps of wind swirl into his silhouette. Environmental hazards such as water surfaces ripple realistically, while boulders and breakable floors respond convincingly to player inputs.

Lighting and color palettes shift to support the narrative tone. Early levels feature warm, golden hues reminiscent of a theater stage, while deeper stages transition to cooler blues and shadowy grays, reinforcing the sense of exploration into unknown territory. Glyphs glow softly but distinctly, guiding player attention without feeling intrusive.

Although some textures can appear slightly low-resolution when viewed up close, these moments are rare and do little to detract from the overall presentation. The cohesive art direction and consistent frame rate ensure that immersion remains uninterrupted, allowing you to focus entirely on solving puzzles and uncovering the story.

Story

At its core, The Pretender chronicles Laurence’s desperate bid to rescue his audience after a magical trick goes awry. This narrative setup provides a strong emotional hook: each rescued ghostly spectator serves as a reminder of the stakes and of Laurence’s guilt. The game doesn’t rush its storytelling, letting you absorb subtle details at your own pace through environmental cues and brief interludes.

Optional story levels delve deeper into the relationship between Eliza, Laurence’s assistant, and a mysterious aged magician. These chapters hint at a hidden bond and arcane secrets that lie at the heart of the dreamland’s power. While these levels are not mandatory for unlocking the next difficulty, they offer rich lore for players eager to piece together the underlying mythos.

Dialogue is sparse but effective, appearing as short captions or silhouette cutscenes that maintain the sense of wonder and enigma. The absence of lengthy exposition leaves much to player interpretation, fostering engagement through curiosity rather than spoon-feeding every detail. This design choice ensures the story feels both intimate and expansive.

As Part One concludes, you’ll be left with intriguing questions about the aged magician’s motives and Eliza’s true role. The narrative payoff is solid—enough closure to satisfy your immediate curiosity, yet plenty of mystery remains, building anticipation for the sequel.

Overall Experience

The Pretender: Part One delivers a well-rounded puzzle-platforming adventure that caters to both casual players and puzzle enthusiasts. The unlimited lives and quick-reset feature remove frustration, allowing you to focus on discovery and strategy. Each level feels hand-crafted, offering just the right mix of challenge and satisfaction.

While the elemental mechanics are straightforward, their combinations unlock a surprising depth of puzzle variety. You’ll find yourself replaying stages to discover new pathways or faster solutions, especially in search of optional story levels. The balanced difficulty curve ensures early levels ease you in, while later stages provide a genuine test of your problem-solving prowess.

Visually and aurally, the game stands out with its lush art style and minimal but evocative sound design. Ambient effects and subtle musical cues enhance the dreamlike ambiance without overshadowing gameplay. Loading times are minimal, and performance remains stable even on modest hardware.

In sum, The Pretender: Part One is an engaging introduction to Laurence’s magical misadventure. It expertly weaves puzzles, atmosphere, and story into a cohesive experience that leaves you eager for more. If you enjoy thoughtful puzzle-platformers with a touch of narrative mystery, this title is well worth your time.

Retro Replay Score

null/10