Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Mail Order Monsters centers on a deeply engaging monster-building sandbox that gives you remarkable freedom in creating your ultimate combatant. You start by choosing from 12 distinct monster types—ranging from the hulking Tyro and agile Hominid to the insectoid Arachnid and subterranean Worm—each with its own movement style and base attributes. The real magic happens when you layer on 11 different enhancements such as fiery breath, tentacles, or a poisonous sting, carefully balancing offense, defense, and utility. Finally, you equip your creation with a choice of ranged weapons, whether you prefer the classic rifle, a cutting-edge laser gun, or the raw power of a flamethrower.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Every upgrade and weapon carry a monetary cost, making victory in the arena crucial. Battles are fought across varied terrains like desert dunes, dense jungle, and murky swamp, each with its own tactical considerations. While reminiscent of Archon’s tactical grid, Mail Order Monsters spices things up with three unique victory conditions: Total Destruction (eliminate the opposing beast), Flag Collection (capture and return the flag), or The Horde (outscore your rival by vanquishing swarms of computer-controlled Hordlings). This variety keeps matches feeling fresh as you adapt your strategy to both your monster’s build and the battlefield objective.

The game’s three difficulty tiers further refine the experience. The Beginner level strips away the customization and hands you a prebuilt monster, ideal for getting your feet wet in the arena’s fundamentals. Intermediate mode offers a modest starting fund, letting you explore enhancements and weapons before stepping into combat. But it’s in the Tournament (career) level where the game truly shines: you manage a stable of monsters, maintain their upgrades in corrals, and chart a career path that rewards long-term planning and resource investment. This tiered approach makes the game accessible for newcomers while providing a robust, long-term challenge for veterans.

Strategic depth emerges from the interplay of monster design, resource management, and battlefield tactics. Do you funnel your money into high-damage enhancements at the expense of mobility? Will you arm your worm with a flamethrower to deliver devastating close-range bursts, or opt for a laser gun to keep foes at bay? Each decision ripples through every encounter, ensuring that victories feel earned and defeats spur you to rethink your build. Though the core combat loop can grow repetitive over extended sessions, the breadth of options and the high stakes of each match maintain a compelling loop of trial, error, and refinement.

Graphics

For a game released in the mid-1980s, Mail Order Monsters offers surprisingly detailed pixel art that still holds a certain nostalgic charm. Each monster type is rendered with clear, recognizable silhouettes so you can instantly identify your opponent’s strengths and weaknesses. The choice of enhancements translates into visible appendages—wispy tendrils of flame for fiery breath, sharp barbs for stingers—making each creature feel truly custom-crafted.

The battlefields themselves demonstrate a commendable variety of tile sets. Desert arenas sport cracked earth and shifting dunes, while swamp levels use darker hues and murky water to evoke a sense of danger. Jungle stages come alive with thick foliage that can sometimes obscure vision, adding an extra layer of tactical consideration. Though the color palette is limited by the hardware of the era, clever use of shading and tile variation keeps environments distinct and visually engaging.

Animations are concise but effective. Monsters lunge, recoil, and discharge their weapons with enough fluidity to convey impact. When enhancements like tentacles strike or a flamethrower roars to life, small but satisfying visual flourishes reinforce the connection between your customization choices and on-screen action. While modern gamers might find the frame rates basic by today’s standards, there’s an undeniable charm to the pixel-perfect hits and the crisp feedback upon scoring a kill or capturing a flag.

Menus and interfaces are straightforward, if a bit spartan. The monster editor uses simple icon-based selections that load quickly, though it can feel slow when you’re scrolling through multiple enhancement options. Once in combat, the HUD provides clear information—health bars, remaining ammo, and the current objective—without cluttering the screen. All told, the graphics may feel dated, but they deliver clarity and style in equal measure, serving the gameplay rather than overshadowing it.

Story

Mail Order Monsters doesn’t rely on an elaborate narrative or characters with deep backstories. Instead, it offers a loose premise: a futuristic competition circuit where trainers design and dispatch custom creatures to battle in hazardous arenas. This minimal story framework functions as an open invitation to unleash your creativity, letting you craft your own monster saga without being tethered to a rigid plot.

What unfolds in each match creates its own emergent storytelling. You might remember the ragged Hominid that outran a high-powered laser by leaping over a swamp pit, or the Worm that ambushed a rival from below. Over time, as you collect victories and refine your roster in Tournament mode, you build a personal legend for each monster—extraordinary feats you alone have witnessed. In this way, the game’s sparse narrative scaffolding gives way to player-driven stories that feel surprisingly memorable.

The lack of a formal storyline can be a double-edged sword. Players seeking rich character development or dramatic cutscenes may find the experience underwhelming. But for those who relish open-ended design challenges and sandbox-style progression, the minimal plot is a strength: there’s nothing between you and your next monster match. The corral system in Tournament mode even lets you rewatch battle results, further fueling the sense of a personal monster league with rivalries, upsets, and dramatic comebacks—all with zero handholding.

Ultimately, narrative emerges from your own ambitions. Are you building a gladiatorial champion to dominate the Destruction mode? Or crafting a nimble, flag-capturing specialist? Each build spawns its own backstory in your mind, making the story less an authored script and more a gallery of player-created legends. If you embrace this modular approach to storytelling, Mail Order Monsters offers a fertile ground for your imagination.

Overall Experience

Mail Order Monsters stands out as an early pioneer of player-driven customization fused with strategy-based combat. Its core strength lies in the robust monster editor and the variety of battle objectives that demand flexible tactics. Whether you’re savagely eliminating your opponent in Destruction mode, deftly snatching the flag and sprinting home, or clawing your way through hordes of Hordlings, every victory feels earned through careful planning and nimble execution.

Replayability is sky-high thanks to the combination of twelve monster archetypes, eleven enhancements, and multiple weapons. The three-tiered difficulty structure further extends longevity: new players can cut their teeth in Beginner mode, while seasoned tacticians can sink dozens of hours into a Tournament career. Throughout, the game’s accessible interface and straightforward rules make it easy to jump back in and tinker with new builds.

No title this vintage is perfect by modern standards. The audiovisuals, though charming, can feel primitive, and the pacing sometimes slows during menu navigation. Multiplayer is limited to hot-seat play, which—while fun in its day—may not satisfy today’s online-centric audiences. Additionally, the lack of a formal narrative may disappoint those looking for a more cinematic or character-driven journey.

Yet these quibbles pale in comparison to the sheer joy of constructing a killer monster army and unleashing it on unsuspecting foes. Mail Order Monsters rewards creativity, strategic thought, and a willingness to experiment. For retro enthusiasts and fans of tactical customization alike, it remains a uniquely satisfying experience—one that invites you to tinker, battle, and build your own legends in the monster arena. If you’re seeking a game where imagination is your greatest weapon, this is a match made in monster heaven.

Retro Replay Score

6.8/10