Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Scary Monsters places you in the cleats of former football star–turned–adventurer Harry Johns, with a clear mission: track down six fearsome beasts and send them back to their graves. Each of the island’s buildings hides both a slumbering monster and the unique weapon needed to destroy it, but locating the right tool is only half the challenge. You must explore rooms filled with Dr. Graves’ twisted victims—ghosts, witches, mummies, and more—wielding a limited supply of bullets and precious “Peek-a-Boos” to clear your path.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The combat feels satisfyingly old-school, pitting you against wave after wave of lesser ghouls before you face the main monsters at the far right of each building. Standard shots dispatch most enemies, but when the halls become flooded with spooks, your limited Peek-a-Boos—which instantly banish foes—become invaluable. Just beware: every ghostly limb you vaporize leaves behind severed hands that become deadly tripwires. Precision jumps and split-second timing are critical to avoid being brought down by your own handiwork.

Puzzle elements weave naturally into the action, as you never know which of the six structures holds the weapon for the monster that dwells elsewhere. Back-tracking and memorizing layouts quickly turn into a satisfying meta-puzzle: should you clear Building A first in hopes of finding the silver stake for Dracula, or head to B for burst shells that might slay the werewolf? This trial-and-error loop encourages multiple runs, and mastering each building’s enemy patterns feels rewarding.

Controls are tight and responsive, with Harry’s leaps and shots landing exactly where you want them—essential when you’re bounding over gory obstacles or lining up a headshot on a stalking mummy. While the challenge can spike suddenly, especially in the later levels, the learning curve never feels unfair. Scary Monsters nails that classic arcade bounce where repeated deaths aren’t frustration points but invitations to refine your strategy.

Graphics

For its era, Scary Monsters delivers a delightfully spooky aesthetic. Dr. Graves’ island is rendered in richly detailed pixel art, from the creaking boards of abandoned mansions to the moonlit courtyards where skeletons patrol. Each building’s interior is unique, giving you visual cues about what to expect—dusty crypts for the mummy, cobweb-strewn laboratories for Frankenstein’s creature.

The monster sprites themselves are memorable, combining enough detail to be instantly recognizable with smooth animations that bring them to life. Dracula’s wings flutter menacingly before he swoops, the witch’s cackle is conveyed through a brief but expressive head turn, and the hunchback lumbers toward you in exaggerated frames. These animations heighten the tension as you approach the boss zones at the rightmost screens.

Color palettes swing from icy blues in ghost chambers to blood-red accents in the witch’s lair, creating an unsettling atmosphere without straining the hardware. Lighting effects—such as flickering torches or glowing eyes—add depth, while the parallax background layers convey a sense of scale on Graves’ twisted island. Even the status bar receives care: six monster portraits line the top of the screen, each swapping to a gravestone icon the moment you succeed.

Story

Scary Monsters casts you as Harry Johns, an ex-football hero turned reluctant action star, trapped with his girlfriend Conny on an island ruled by the deranged Dr. Graves. The premise unfolds in brief opening text and mid-level cut-ins, establishing Graves as a psychotic surgeon who can’t resist experimenting on islanders. His victims now roam as undead minions, setting the stage for your slasher-style adventure.

While the narrative stops short of deep character development, it provides enough motivation to keep you pushing through each building. Harry’s determination to save Conny fuels the urgency, and each monster you vanquish feels like a step closer to confronting Graves himself. The text snippets reveal moments of gallows humor, with Harry quipping about flying hounds or severed limbs, adding light relief to the tension.

The simple but effective story beats work in tandem with the level design. As you progress, bits of lore surface—a discarded journal page here, a blood-spattered surgical tool there—hinting at Graves’ twisted psyche. Although the game never plunges into lengthy cutscenes, it balances gameplay and narrative so that each victory over a legendary monster feels like a genuine plot advancement.

Overall Experience

Scary Monsters is a tight blend of action, platforming, and light puzzle-solving that stands the test of time. Its old-school difficulty will appeal to players seeking a genuine arcade challenge, while its varied monster roster and cleverly hidden weapons inject freshness into each building. The game moves at a brisk pace, rarely overstaying its welcome, and the moment a monster’s gravestone replaces its portrait is always satisfying.

While some modern gamers might chafe at limited continues or the absence of in-game checkpoints, die-hard platformer fans will relish the trial-and-error loop. Each failed run becomes a lesson in enemy behavior and level layout, making subsequent attempts feel progressively smoother. The combination of tight controls, atmospheric graphics, and spooky sound design elevates what could have been a standard “monster-hunt” premise into a memorable experience.

In the end, Scary Monsters delivers a nostalgic yet polished adventure that still packs surprises. Whether you’re a retro enthusiast or a newcomer curious about classic action titles, Harry Johns’ quest on Dr. Graves’ island offers enough thrills and chills to justify a playthrough. Grab your gun, conserve those Peek-a-Boos, and prepare to face some truly scary monsters.

Retro Replay Score

5.9/10