Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Sherlock offers a classic blend of text and graphics adventure mechanics, placing you directly in the deerstalker of the world’s greatest sleuth. You navigate the game world by typing commands, and the descriptive text remains neatly separated from your inputs, which are displayed at the bottom of the screen. This clean interface ensures that you can focus on the mystery without losing track of your previous actions or running into confusing text overlap.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The core gameplay revolves around gathering clues at crime scenes and interrogating a variety of NPCs. Doctor Watson provides helpful insights when you encounter a dead end, while Inspector Lestrade’s bumbling interference adds both humor and challenge. NPCs will change their demeanor and the information they share depending on previous discoveries, making each dialogue feel dynamic and rewarding careful note-taking.

Time is a critical resource in Sherlock. You must catch trains at specific times to travel between key locations, adding strategic pressure to your investigation. Failing to plan your travel correctly can close off vital evidence or suspects, raising the stakes and encouraging you to map out each move thoughtfully. This race against the clock injects urgency into what might otherwise be a leisurely puzzle experience.

Graphics

Visually, Sherlock balances simple but evocative static images with richly detailed text descriptions. Background illustrations of Victorian streets, dimly lit parlors, and the grim crime scene in Leatherhead set the mood perfectly. Although the graphics won’t rival modern 3D environments, they complement the narrative by sparking your imagination rather than distracting from it.

The user interface design is refreshingly uncluttered. The command line sits at the bottom of the screen, separate from the descriptive text, so you always know exactly where to type and how the game has responded. This separation also makes it easy to review your previous inputs and plot out your next move—an important feature in a puzzle-heavy adventure.

Character portraits during interrogations are simple but effective, capturing expressions that hint at honesty, fear, or deceit. These visual cues become invaluable when you decide whom to trust or when to press for more information. The restrained color palette and period-appropriate fonts further immerse you in Sherlock Holmes’s 19th-century world.

Story

The narrative centers on a chilling double murder in the quiet town of Leatherhead. As Holmes, you arrive with Watson to unravel the tangled motives behind the crime. The game steadily unfolds its plot through crime scene investigation, suspect interviews, and sudden twists that keep you guessing until the very end.

Doctor Watson serves as a reliable sounding board, often suggesting lines of inquiry you might have overlooked. Inspector Lestrade, in contrast, provides comic relief—and occasional frustration—by bungling simple leads or dismissing evidence. Their banter enhances the storyline, making every discovery feel like a triumph shared with close allies rather than a solitary puzzle solved in isolation.

Clue management is at the heart of the story progression. Every item you pick up, every witness statement you record, and every subtle nod in a character’s portrait could be the key to unlocking the next chapter. This tight integration of story and gameplay ensures that narrative momentum never stalls, and you’re always motivated to push forward.

Overall Experience

Sherlock delivers a refreshingly pure adventure experience that honors the detective genre. Its combination of time-based challenges, thoughtful interrogation mechanics, and atmospheric graphics creates a compelling package that feels both nostalgic and fresh. Puzzle enthusiasts will appreciate the game’s respect for logical deduction and meaningful consequences.

The learning curve is gentle for newcomers yet deep enough to satisfy veteran sleuths. Early cases introduce the interface and basic mechanics, while later stages demand meticulous attention to detail and clever time management. This pacing ensures that you never feel overwhelmed, even as the complexity ramps up.

Despite its age, Sherlock remains an engaging mystery that stands the test of time. Whether you’re a fan of Victorian-era detective stories or simply love unraveling intricate puzzles, this game offers hours of thoughtful entertainment. It is a testament to elegant design that the thrill of solving a baffling case still resonates today.

Retro Replay Score

7/10