Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

SuperStar Soccer builds on the tight, fast-paced framework of its predecessor, Superstar Ice Hockey, to deliver an exhilarating six-a-side football experience on the Commodore 64. You step into the boots of the centre-forward for most of the match, but you’re never truly alone—your teammates dart into position around you, ready to receive your passes or pounce on loose balls. The intuitive controls let you dribble, pass, shoot, head, and even pull off bicycle kicks, and the ball clings to your avatar in a way that feels both responsive and realistic.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

One of the finest touches is the ability to track back when your side is under pressure. While the centre-forward role is your default, the game allows you to switch to goalkeeper or manager mode on the C64 version, giving you a broader tactical perspective. Goalkeepers are penalised if they hang on to the ball too long, forcing you to rediscover the rush of launching swift counterattacks rather than stalling in your own box. Every turnover counts, and fouls are faithfully implemented, meaning you’ll need to weigh a risky slide tackle against the chance of gifting a free kick.

Match length is entirely in your hands. By toggling the in-game speed, a full contest can last anywhere from a quick 6 minutes to a marathon 90-minute fixture. This flexibility caters to casual pick-up-and-play sessions and committed weekend manager marathons alike. Speaking of management, the disk version unfolds a full-season structure: 64 English teams divided into four tiers can be guided across either a concise seven-match campaign or a grueling 15-game slog, each victory and defeat shaping promotion and relegation drama.

Graphics

Visually, SuperStar Soccer strikes a perfect balance between functionality and flair. The pitch is rendered in crisp green tones, with clear boundary lines and a well-defined center circle. Players are represented by simple but distinctive sprites, each sporting contrasting kits to help you instantly recognize teammates and opponents. Animations are smooth for the hardware, ensuring that tackles, headers, and celebrations look fluid without noticeable slowdowns.

The game’s overhead view offers an excellent vantage point on the action, letting you map out runs and passes effectively. While the pitch detail may seem sparse by modern standards, the running crowd in the stands and the occasional referee sprite add a dash of atmosphere. The transition between offense and defense feels seamless, and bounce trajectories of the ball—whether on a powerful shot or a looping header—are easy to follow against the green backdrop.

During replays of goals or near misses, the camera zooms in slightly to emphasize key moments. These brief cutaways underscore the excitement of a bicycle kick or the drama of a goal-line scramble. In short, while SuperStar Soccer isn’t pushing contemporary graphical boundaries, it maximizes the C64’s capabilities to deliver a clean, engaging visual presentation that keeps your focus on strategic play and in-the-moment thrills.

Story

While SuperStar Soccer doesn’t offer a narrative campaign in the traditional sense, it weaves its own brand of storytelling through player progression and league drama. Each match you play contributes to an unfolding saga of triumphs, near misses, and managerial gambles. The season mode, in particular, feels like your own personal football novel, with promotion-chasing underdogs and relegation-battling giants swapping places in dynamic fashion.

You become invested in your centre-forward’s golden boot race, your backline’s clean sheet record, and your manager avatar’s tactical decisions. Every cup upset and division-clinching victory creates emotional highs, while a last-minute equalizer conceded through a foul can break your heart. The absence of a predetermined storyline is a strength here—your decisions write the plot, and the pixelated pitch is your stage.

Moreover, the game’s rule-enforced realism—particularly the goalkeeper possession penalty—adds narrative tension to even the simplest of matches. You’re not just chasing goals; you’re navigating the unwritten tales of leadership, split-second decisions, and the relentless pressure of the final whistle. In a sense, SuperStar Soccer crafts its drama through gameplay mechanics rather than cutscenes, making every fixture feel uniquely yours.

Overall Experience

SuperStar Soccer offers an arresting blend of accessible controls and strategic depth that holds up remarkably well today. Whether you’re diving into a quick single match or committing to a full-season marathon, the gameplay loop is consistently rewarding. The six-a-side format keeps the action tight and frenetic, while league management adds a layer of long-term satisfaction that casual players and die-hard fans alike will appreciate.

The presentation is clean, the controls are responsive, and the rules enforcement—especially around fouls and goalkeeper restrictions—adds a welcome layer of authenticity. Newcomers to retro sports sims will find it easy to pick up but challenging to master, thanks to its well-calibrated difficulty curve. Season mode’s multiple divisions, varied fixture counts, and promotion/relegation stakes infuse significant replay value, ensuring that each campaign brings fresh excitement.

For anyone seeking a streamlined yet compelling soccer sim on the Commodore 64, SuperStar Soccer stands out as a classic worth revisiting—or discovering for the first time. Its straightforward approach highlights the essence of the beautiful game, focusing on skillful play, tactical choices, and the joy of netting that perfect goal. In combining the best of arcade immediacy with league-manager depth, it earns its place among the era’s most memorable sports titles.

Retro Replay Score

6.3/10