Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Alternate Reality: The Dungeon builds upon its predecessor’s exploration-focused mechanics by introducing a more structured, level-based progression. Rather than roaming a sprawling cityscape, players traverse four distinct dungeon levels in a strictly linear sequence. This shift in design streamlines the experience, placing emphasis on steady progression and survival rather than open-ended discovery.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The core of the gameplay remains a classic turn-based combat system. Each skirmish requires careful planning, as the party’s positioning and stat management can mean the difference between victory and a quick death. Enemies grow tougher on deeper levels, and though the variety of monsters can feel repetitive at times, the escalating difficulty curve keeps encounters tense and engaging.

Shops and services from the city return inside the dungeon walls. Inns, smithies, and magical item dealers provide essential respite, allowing players to rest, repair, or upgrade equipment. Additionally, six core guilds (plus two hidden ones) appear throughout the depths, offering membership benefits such as specialized gear or unique abilities. Gaining entrance to these factions rewards exploration and clever use of resources.

One of the most significant new mechanics is item weight. Every sword, potion, or piece of armor carries a tangible burden that directly impacts your party’s speed and endurance. This forces players to make meaningful choices about inventory, balancing the desire for treasure with the need for mobility. Hoarding every shiny trinket is no longer viable, and managing resources becomes as critical as vanquishing foes.

Graphics

For its time, Alternate Reality: The Dungeon delivered impressive visuals that struck a balance between functionality and atmosphere. The dungeon corridors are rendered in a moody, low-resolution palette that evokes claustrophobic tension. While sprites are simple and blocky by modern standards, their stark silhouettes fit the dark, oppressive environment perfectly.

Lighting effects, though rudimentary, play a significant role in immersion. Flickering torches cast dancing shadows on stone walls, giving each corridor a sense of depth that belies the hardware limitations of the era. Color choices—predominantly grays, deep browns, and muted reds—reinforce the drab, dangerous feel of the underground labyrinth.

Character and monster sprites are distinct enough to tell friend from foe at a glance, but there’s room for improvement in animation variety. Attacks and death animations are brief and functional; they convey action adequately but rarely surprise. Still, the overall visual package accomplishes its goal of keeping players focused on exploration and survival.

The minimalistic interface complements the graphics without overcrowding the screen. Status bars, inventory windows, and dialogue boxes are laid out cleanly, ensuring that vital information—hit points, stamina, carry weight—is always visible. This clarity speeds decision-making in the heat of battle and reduces frustration when managing your party’s gear.

Story

Alternate Reality: The Dungeon picks up immediately following the events of The City. You remain a prisoner of hostile aliens, cast into another facet of a twisted reality. The narrative motivation is straightforward: delve deeper, fight for survival, and uncover any hope of escape. This urgency drives you forward through each level of the dungeon’s perilous depths.

While the story doesn’t rely on lengthy cut-scenes or multi-branching dialogue, environmental storytelling fills in the gaps. Faded wall carvings hint at ancient civilizations, and cryptic messages scrawled by previous captives add layers of mystery. These touches invite players to piece together the lore as they progress.

Guild involvement also contributes to the narrative. Joining one of the factions isn’t merely a gameplay choice; it ties into the world’s power dynamics. Each guild has its own backstory and motivations, revealed through item descriptions and sporadic NPC chatter. Aligning with a guild can feel like choosing a side in a political struggle played out in the shadows.

Although the plot remains focused on survival rather than epic heroism, the sense of isolation and desperation feels palpable. There are no allies waiting on the surface—only more darkness. This relentless atmosphere heightens every combat encounter and exploration decision, making even the smallest victory feel hard-won.

Overall Experience

Alternate Reality: The Dungeon offers a tightly designed, dungeon-crawl experience that rewards careful planning and resource management. Its linear structure contrasts with the predecessor’s freeform city exploration, delivering a clear sense of progression. Players who enjoy methodical advancement and deliberate risk-taking will find much to appreciate.

The balance between combat, inventory constraints, and mercantile opportunities keeps the gameplay loop engaging. Every descent to a new level brings fresh challenges—from increasingly powerful monsters to the looming threat of over-encumbrance. The inclusion of guilds and shops maintains strategic depth without overwhelming first-time dungeon crawlers.

Visually and aurally, the game remains a product of its era. If you approach it expecting modern polish, you may be disappointed. However, when judged on its own terms, the graphics and interface successfully immerse you in their gritty, claustrophobic world. The streamlined UI ensures that you spend your time immersed in the adventure rather than wrestling with menus.

Ultimately, Alternate Reality: The Dungeon is an atmospheric, challenging sequel that carves out its own identity within the series. Its focus on survival, combined with manageable RPG systems, creates an experience that can be both punishing and rewarding. For fans of classic dungeon crawlers and those who enjoyed the first game’s world, this installment is a must-explore underworld filled with danger and intrigue.

Retro Replay Score

7.1/10