Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Tales of the Sword Coast integrates seamlessly with the base Baldur’s Gate experience, providing a quartet of sprawling new quests that can each occupy several hours of playtime. From the moment you step off the map’s eastern edge into the bustling docks of Ulgoth’s Beard, it’s clear that the developers have prioritized depth of exploration. Party management remains critical, as tougher foes and environmental hazards push you to optimize your roster’s abilities and equipment.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The four quests themselves range from traditional dungeon crawls to intrigue-laden investigations. Durlag Tower stands out as a labyrinthine gauntlet filled with deadly traps and clever puzzles that evoke classic AD&D dungeon lore. Elsewhere, the seaside town of Ulgoth’s Beard becomes a hub for side-stories involving smugglers, missing persons, and malevolent sea spirits. Combat encounters are balanced to test both melee brawlers and spellcasters, encouraging a versatile approach to tactics.

Complementing the new areas are dozens of unique items, spells, and voice-over lines that help the expansion feel like a natural extension of the original game. High-level magical gear and powerful new abilities—such as enhanced fighter specializations and potent cleric prayers—encourage veteran parties to rethink their load-out. The increased difficulty curve also rewards careful planning, making every trek into Durlag Tower or the hidden coves near the Sword Coast feel consequential.

Graphics

Visually, Tales of the Sword Coast adheres to the classic 2D isometric style of the Infinity Engine, preserving the familiar look and feel that fans cherish. While there are no sweeping graphical overhauls, the new areas receive fresh artwork with distinctive color palettes and atmospheric detail. Ulgoth’s Beard boasts sun-baked docks, sundrenched taverns, and salty sea breezes captured through subtle environmental animations.

Durlag Tower offers a darker contrast, drenched in shadowy stonework and flickering torchlight. The dungeon’s visual design ups the ante with elaborate trap mechanisms, animated statues, and sinister gargoyles that feel appropriately menacing. Texture work remains consistent with the original, ensuring a seamless visual transition when you fast-travel between the Sword Coast and Baldur’s Gate city proper.

Character portraits and monster sprites maintain their high level of detail, and the new NPCs introduced in this expansion have fully voiced lines that match the original game’s quality. From grizzled pirates to crypt-dwelling trolls, each new model is lovingly rendered, making exploration and combat feel both nostalgic and fresh. In short, while the engine’s age shows in polygon counts, the art direction and new assets carry the torch admirably.

Story

Although Tales of the Sword Coast doesn’t advance the main Baldur’s Gate storyline, it shines by offering four standalone narratives that enrich the Forgotten Realms setting. Each quest is woven into the broader tapestry of Sword Coast lore, featuring memorable characters, moral dilemmas, and lore-heavy dialogue. The writing team has clearly invested in creating scenarios that feel weighty despite their add-on status.

One quest sends you investigating a series of strange disappearances in Ulgoth’s Beard, uncovering a smuggling ring far more dangerous than it first appears. Another has you confronting a vengeful spirit haunting a coastal cove, blending horror elements with classic role-playing choices. The true highlight, however, is the saga of Durlag Tower: a multi-level descent into the ancestral stronghold of a long-dead dwarven clan, filled with journal entries, ghostly apparitions, and echoes of past betrayals.

Dialogue remains top-notch, with plenty of branching options that let you charm, intimidate, or deceive your way through social encounters. The new voice work fits in seamlessly with the original cast, keeping immersion intact. While purists hoping for a direct sequel may find the absence of main plot developments disappointing, the expansion’s side adventures more than compensate by delivering high-quality role-playing experiences.

Overall Experience

Tales of the Sword Coast stands as a robust expansion that delivers hours of additional gameplay for fans of Baldur’s Gate. By introducing four large-scale quests, rich new locales, and a wealth of items and abilities, it provides both variety and depth. Its integration with the base game is smooth, so newcomers to the add-on won’t feel shoehorned into contrived content.

For players who have thoroughly explored Candlekeep and the winding streets of Baldur’s Gate, this expansion offers fresh challenges and compelling stories to tackle. The difficulty spike in Durlag Tower alone justifies multiple playthroughs with different party builds, while the narrative quests reward careful dialogue and exploration. Ultimately, it’s an ideal package for those craving more high-fantasy adventure without straying from the core AD&D mechanics they love.

Whether you’re returning to revisit the Sword Coast or diving in for the first time via a bundle purchase, Tales of the Sword Coast is a valuable addition that complements the original Baldur’s Gate beautifully. It may not revolutionize the genre, but it refines and expands upon a classic formula, ensuring that your next journey through Faerûn remains unforgettable.

Retro Replay Score

8/10