Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Company of Heroes: Anthology delivers a robust real-time strategy experience that emphasizes tactical decision-making, unit positioning, and resource management. The base game introduces the innovative cover system and directional suppression mechanics that set the series apart, rewarding players who think carefully about terrain and flanking. Whether advancing infantry squads or coordinating armored assaults, every engagement feels dynamic and earned.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The standalone expansions—Opposing Fronts and Tales of Valor—add depth and variety to the core gameplay loop. Opposing Fronts introduces two new factions, the British 2nd Army and the German Panzer Elite, each with its own doctrine trees, unique units, and strategic playstyles. Tales of Valor builds on this by offering focused skirmish campaigns and the heroic “Regimental” missions, encouraging players to master small-scale tactics and rapid unit micro-management.

On Mac, Anthology marks the first official release of the franchise, although it comes with the caveat of no multiplayer support. This limits competitive play and cooperative missions, so Mac users will need to rely on the single-player campaigns and skirmish AI for replayability. Meanwhile, the Nintendo Switch edition translates the controls to a handheld format, letting players experience the series on the go, though menu navigation can feel clunky and precise unit selection sometimes challenges the Joy-Con’s analog sticks.

Despite platform differences, the core strategic framework remains solid across all versions. Each mission in the Allied or Axis campaigns offers varied objectives—seizing fuel depots, holding defensive lines, or launching full-scale assaults. The introduction of doctrines and veterancy systems in the expansions invites multiple playthroughs and diverse tactics, ensuring that both newcomers and series veterans find plenty of engaging content.

Graphics

Though originally released in 2006, Company of Heroes still impresses with its detailed unit models, dynamic lighting, and destructible environments. Buildings crumble realistically under artillery fire, smoke plumes rise from burning vehicles, and the shifting daylight in several missions lends a cinematic quality to the battlefield. These visual effects not only look great but also serve as tactical cues—seeing a wall collapse can open new avenues of attack or force a hasty retreat.

The expansions maintain the base game’s visual fidelity and add fresh skins, textures, and map environments to the mix. Opposing Fronts introduces lush Normandy hedgerows and the ruined streets of Caen, while Tales of Valor offers smaller but visually distinct locales for its focused skirmishes. On high-end PCs, players can push draw distances and shadow details to appreciate the full scope of the war-torn European countryside.

Rendering on the Nintendo Switch is commendable given hardware constraints. Textures are slightly downsampled, and the resolution dips during intense firefights, but the core visual identity remains intact. Unit animations and particle effects hold up surprisingly well on the handheld screen, providing a portable taste of Company of Heroes’ signature destructibility and ambiance.

The Mac release mirrors the original PC graphics with near-identical fidelity, aside from lacking multiplayer overlays. Performance varies with hardware—modern MacBook Pros handle the visuals smoothly on medium to high settings, but older machines may struggle with frame rates during large scale engagements. Careful tuning of graphical options ensures a stable experience without sacrificing too much visual flair.

Story

Company of Heroes: Anthology does not rely on a single linear narrative but weaves its story through a series of stand-alone campaigns and vignettes. The base game’s Allied campaigns focus on the brutal fight for Caen and the hard-won liberation of France, immersing players in historical battles with period-authentic dialogue and mission briefings. Cutscenes and in-game narration bring the human side of war to life without overshadowing the strategic gameplay.

Opposing Fronts flips the coin with dual campaigns—first showing the German perspective as they attempt to stymie the Allied advance, and then placing players in command of the British forces pushing into occupied territory. This narrative shift provides fresh context for familiar battlefields and highlights the challenges faced by both sides of the conflict. Each mission feels like a chapter in a larger war diary, punctuated by moments of triumph and tactical setbacks.

Tales of Valor’s three mini-campaigns—“Falaise Pocket,” “Operation Market Garden,” and “Tiger Ace”—hone in on heroic skirmishes and individual acts of valor. While shorter in length, these missions foreground personal stories and introduce unique gameplay twists, such as controlling a single elite tank or leading a commando squad behind enemy lines. The narrative framing here is leaner but still evokes the tension and unpredictability of frontline combat.

Across all three titles, the Anthology package does an admirable job of balancing historical authenticity with engaging mission design. Voice acting and period visuals reinforce the setting, while mission objectives encourage players to experience the tactical ebb and flow that defined the Western Front of WWII. The combined effect is a tapestry of war stories that feel both personal and strategically meaningful.

Overall Experience

Company of Heroes: Anthology offers outstanding value for RTS enthusiasts and history buffs alike. Bundling the base game with both expansion packs delivers dozens of hours of single-player campaigns, skirmish maps, and doctrinal experiments. For newcomers, Anthology provides a one-stop introduction to the series’ best entries, while veterans can revisit familiar battles armed with new units and tactics.

The lack of multiplayer on the Mac version is a notable downside, especially for those hoping to engage in competitive matches or community-hosted cooperative missions. However, the comprehensive AI skirmish modes and robust campaign offerings still make for satisfying solo play. On Switch, portability and the ability to save anywhere add convenience, though complex menu navigation can sometimes hamper quick tactical commands in the heat of battle.

Technical performance across platforms is generally stable: PCs deliver the full visual and control experience, Macs run well if matched with capable hardware, and the Switch holds its own despite minor compromises. Installation is straightforward, and the unified launcher in Anthology makes it easy to jump between base and expansion content without juggling separate shortcuts or installers.

In summation, Company of Heroes: Anthology remains one of the finest real-time strategy collections available. Its blend of deep tactical gameplay, atmospheric graphics, and compelling historical scenarios sets a high bar for the genre. Whether you’re reliving classic World War II battles on your desktop or commanding Allied forces on the go, this anthology stands as a must-have for any RTS library.

Retro Replay Score

null/10