Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Smelly Mystery delivers a charming blend of interactive storybook reading and light puzzle-solving that’s tailor-made for younger players. From the moment you select the “Play” option, you’re guided through beautifully illustrated pages where you click to uncover hidden clues—footprints, handprints, and favorite items—that deepen the mystery. Each clue you find is automatically logged, and you can refer back at any time to piece together which of the six suspects might be responsible for the great smell switcheroo in Monsterville.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Navigation is intuitive, with clear prompts and friendly cursor changes when you hover over an interactive element. The “Page” feature allows children (and impatient adults) to jump to any part of the story, which is particularly useful if you want to revisit a favorite scene or replay a tricky puzzle. Meanwhile, the “Read” mode removes all interactivity, turning the game into a straightforward digital book—ideal for bedtime reading without the distractions of gameplay mechanics.

Adding to its replay value is the “New” option, which shuffles the clues and assigns the odor-altering culprit at random. This ensures every playthrough feels fresh: one minute you’re tracking down Ickky’s distinctive green slime imprint, the next you’re matching Jerr y Bombanat’s sparkling red footprints. For bonus fun, the “Mugs” minigame lets players assemble goofy monster faces under three difficulty levels, complete with a timer for a bit of friendly competition.

Graphics

The visual style of The Smelly Mystery is unmistakably Mercer Mayer, whose “Little Monster Private Eye” art brings warmth and whimsical detail to every page. Characters pop against soft pastel backgrounds, and the playful linework captures the quirky personalities of Little Monster, Detective Kerploppus, and the rest of the Monsterville gang. Children will delight in spotting subtle animations—like a fridge door that creaks open or a sneaky tail flicking behind a shadowy suspect.

The user interface is clean and accessible: buttons are clearly labeled, icons are large enough for little hands to click, and menu screens are bright without feeling overwhelming. The transition effects between pages are smooth, giving the impression of turning real paper pages. Even the clue-highlighting glow is gentle, ensuring that it draws attention without breaking the immersion of the storybook environment.

While the game doesn’t push the limits of modern GPU horsepower, its art direction is perfectly suited to its young audience. Backgrounds are intricately detailed—shelves of bubbling potion bottles in Yally’s kitchen, towering bookcases in the detective’s study—while character portraits remain bold and expressive. This balance of detail and clarity makes each screen inviting and easy to read.

Story

The narrative hook of The Smelly Mystery is both silly and engaging: someone has tampered with Yally Yallapaphous’s refrigerator, scrambling all of Monsterville’s finest aromas—and the foulest. What starts as a sleepover prank soon escalates into a town-wide stink, and it’s up to Little Monster and his trusty sidekick, Detective Kerploppus, to sniff out the truth. The premise is simple enough for preschoolers to follow, yet introduces logical deduction in a playful context.

Each page of the storybook is peppered with humorous illustrations and kid-friendly dialogue that capture the camaraderie of the Little Monster Private Eye crew. From Little Laff’s giggle-inducing puns to Errg’s dramatic gasps, the characters feel alive and distinct. Parents reading aloud will appreciate the clear, concise writing that balances narrative progression with interactive moments, encouraging children to stay alert for the next clue.

Pacing is handled expertly: the early chapters lay the groundwork with world-building and character introductions, while middle chapters ramp up the mystery by scattering more subtle evidence. The final reveal is satisfying without feeling rushed, and the epilogue ties up loose ends with a lesson on fairness and the importance of teamwork. It’s a gentle mystery that teaches observational skills and fosters cooperative play between child and caregiver.

Overall Experience

The Smelly Mystery is a delightful foray into interactive storytelling that strikes the right balance between reading and light puzzle-solving. It’s an excellent title for families seeking an engaging afternoon activity or for educators looking to introduce basic deductive reasoning in a playful digital format. The multiple menu options cater to varied playstyles—pure story mode for quiet time, full mystery mode for eager detectives, and mini-games for quick bursts of creative fun.

Replayability is a standout feature thanks to the randomized culprit mechanic, making each new game feel like a fresh challenge. The “Mugs” face-building game also provides a whimsical diversion when players need a break from clue hunting. Although the graphical fidelity is modest by today’s standards, the charming Mercer Mayer art style and smooth interface more than compensate, especially for the game’s target demographic.

Overall, The Smelly Mystery offers an engaging, age-appropriate blend of story, puzzle-solving, and creative play. Its endearing characters, user-friendly design, and replay value ensure that both children and parents will return time and again to solve Monsterville’s aromatic conundrum. For anyone in search of a lighthearted, interactive mystery that encourages observation and critical thinking, this game is a clear winner.

Retro Replay Score

null/10