Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Young Sherlock: The Legacy of Doyle delivers a classic point‐and‐click adventure experience that will appeal to puzzle aficionados and mystery lovers alike. You control both Holmes and Watson, switching seamlessly between the two detectives to combine their unique skills. The command list—“walk,” “examine,” “talk,” “listen,” “show,” “take,” “inventory,” and “use”—feels intuitive, yet each verb opens up new ways to interact with suspects and crime‐scene clues.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Exploration is divided into two modes: a close‐up view for dialogue and investigation, and an overhead map of Victorian London for fast travel. As you move the red square across different districts, you uncover new landmarks and hidden locations. This dual‐screen approach helps you keep track of your journey and prevents needless backtracking, though some players may find the map’s grid feels a bit restrictive at first.

Puzzle design strikes a satisfying balance between logic and detective work. Early cases focus on basic inventory uses—combining footprints with Watson’s magnifying glass, for instance—while later challenges demand cross‐referencing witness statements and decoding secret messages. Occasionally, you might find yourself stuck without clear direction, but thorough note‐taking and careful examination generally lead you back on track.

Graphics

Graphically, Young Sherlock embraces a hand‐drawn aesthetic that captures the foggy streets and gaslit alleyways of 1875 London. The illustrative pictures displayed during investigations possess a charming, almost storybook quality, with detailed backgrounds that reward close inspection. Although the resolution feels dated by modern standards, these visuals evoke the nostalgia of 8‐bit adventure titles without sacrificing atmosphere.

The overhead map is crisp and functional, using bold lines and simple icons to represent key areas. A small red square denotes Holmes and Watson’s position, making navigation straightforward even on the limited palette. While there’s little animation beyond character icons blinking or moving, the static scenes are richly colored and imbued with period‐appropriate details, such as gas lanterns and cobblestone streets.

Character portraits that appear during conversations add personality to suspects and witnesses. These portrait sketches are expressive enough to hint at motive or mood—Cindy’s tear‐streaked face, for instance, contrasts sharply with the stoic glower of a possible murderer. Though the art style is minimalistic, it effectively conveys emotion and enhances immersion in the unfolding drama.

Story

At its heart, The Legacy of Doyle spins a riveting narrative of intrigue and redemption. December 1875: millionaire Doyle is found brutally murdered, and his daughter Cindy stands accused. Her fiancé, Roger, desperate to save her reputation and the family name, hires a young Sherlock Holmes to scour early‐Victorian London for the real killer.

Unlike its inspiration from the 1985 film, this adventure carves its own path. You won’t see elemental glass knights or fantasy creatures here; instead, the plot unfolds through meticulous detective work. Questioning witnesses in dimly lit taverns, finding footprints in misty alley corners, and piecing together cryptic journal entries creates a grounded, almost documentary‐style investigation.

The writing deftly balances period dialogue with clear clues. Holmes’s dry wit blends seamlessly with Watson’s more empathetic observations, and the rapport between them grows as you progress. Side characters—from an anxious butler to a streetwise urchin—each add color to the world and potential leads, ensuring that every conversation feels vital to solving the central mystery.

Overall Experience

Young Sherlock: The Legacy of Doyle offers a captivating old‐school adventure that rewards patience and inquisitive minds. Its methodical pacing encourages you to think like a detective, poring over every line of text and every pixel of background art. Though modern sensibilities may bristle at the lack of voice acting or dynamic animations, the game’s strengths lie in its cerebral puzzles and richly drawn narrative setting.

The learning curve is gentle but persistent. Beginners to the genre may need time to master verb‐based commands, while veterans will appreciate the intricate clue network. The interface feels dated by today’s standards, but its simplicity actually enhances immersion—there are no distracting HUD elements or quest markers to lead you by the hand.

For fans of classic adventure gaming and Sherlock Holmes lore, this title is a hidden gem. It stands as a testament to how strong writing, thoughtful art direction, and clever puzzle mechanics can deliver an unforgettable detective experience, even on limited hardware. Young Sherlock: The Legacy of Doyle may not revolutionize the genre, but it sets a high bar for storytelling ambition in a retro package.

Retro Replay Score

null/10