Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Submarine offers a deceptively simple yet engaging two-player experience. One player assumes command of a fleet of surface ships, navigating them along predetermined paths marked on the screen overlay. The second player takes on the role of a silent hunter beneath the waves, maneuvering a submarine in an attempt to intercept and sink these vessels. This dynamic of hunter versus hunted creates a tense back-and-forth that keeps both players fully invested.

The core mechanic revolves around hidden movement and prediction. The ship controller must follow a specific overlay track, limiting unpredictability but demanding careful timing to avoid torpedoes. Meanwhile, the submarine player must anticipate the fleet’s route, aim carefully, and fire before the ships escape. Each successful hit feels rewarding, while near-misses heighten the suspense for the next turn.

Switching roles after each round ensures fairness and variety. Players quickly learn the subtleties of each side: captaining a ship requires precision in timing, while piloting the submarine rewards strategic positioning and risk-taking. The competitive element—tallying who sinks more ships over multiple rounds—provides clear goals and incentives, making Submarine an excellent choice for head-to-head matchups.

Although rooted in straightforward rules, Submarine’s gameplay thrives on adaptation and psychological play. Bluffing about your next move, feinting a change in direction, or feigning aggression as the submarine can all tip the balance. As you and your opponent explore these tactics, the experience deepens, transforming a simple overlay-based game into a memorable tactical challenge.

Graphics

Given its origin on the Odyssey platform, Submarine relies on minimalist visuals supplemented by a detachable overlay. The on-screen elements consist of basic blobs and lines, representing ships and torpedoes in motion. While this basic display may seem dated by modern standards, it carries a certain nostalgic charm that appeals to fans of vintage gaming.

The real visual magic happens with the included plastic film overlay, which maps out the fleet’s pathways. This tactile component bridges the gap between raw graphics and player imagination, turning abstract pixels into a coherent battlefield. The overlay’s crisp, simple artwork clearly distinguishes the routes and adds an immersive layer that feels surprisingly interactive.

Colors are limited, but contrast is sufficient for easy readability. Ships are displayed as bright blocks, while the submarine’s torpedoes appear as small dashes or dots. Movement is smooth within the Odyssey’s hardware limits, and there’s minimal flicker, ensuring that players can focus on strategy rather than visual distractions.

Though modern gamers may find the visual presentation rudimentary, it’s important to appreciate Submarine in context. The design choices reflect the ingenuity of early video game development, where imagination filled in the gaps. For those intrigued by gaming history or seeking a retro party piece, Submarine’s graphics are part of its enduring appeal.

Story

Submarine doesn’t come with a sprawling narrative or detailed lore; instead, it offers an open-ended context that players can flesh out themselves. You’re placed squarely in the midst of a naval engagement, with one side defending a convoy and the other hunting from the deep. This bare-bones setup empowers players to imagine their own high-seas drama.

The minimalist storyline serves as a canvas for emergent tales of daring escapes and near-miss torpedoes. Each round generates its own micro-story: perhaps the submarine captain executes a daring ambush, or the fleet commander narrowly evades destruction through clever timing. These personal anecdotes become the game’s true narrative heartbeat.

For younger players or newcomers, this lack of rigid story structure may feel liberating. Without predefined character backstories or forced dialogue, participants are free to role-play, giving voices to their captains or inventing mission briefs. This fosters creativity and can be a delightful way to involve spectators, turning the play area into a makeshift war room.

While fans of story-driven titles might miss a structured campaign, Submarine’s strength lies in the stories you create around the action. Every session spawns memorable moments, from triumphant victories to heartbreaking losses, ensuring that the game’s legacy is carried forward through player anecdotes rather than canned cutscenes.

Overall Experience

Submarine is a standout example of how early video games balanced simplicity with strategic depth. Its two-player focus makes it a social experience, perfect for casual gatherings or competitive one-on-one showdowns. The quick setup and straightforward rules mean that even those unfamiliar with classic systems can jump in and enjoy themselves almost immediately.

The requirement of Odyssey’s game card #5 gives Submarine a collectible edge for enthusiasts of vintage hardware. Owning and playing this title connects you to gaming’s formative years, and the tactile overlay adds a physical dimension missing from many modern downloads and emulations. This tangible aspect enhances both the nostalgia and authenticity of the experience.

Replayability is high thanks to the alternating roles and the psychological mind games that underpin each round. No two sessions play out the same way, as each commander brings a unique style to navigating or hunting. Skill will improve over time, but the element of surprise remains, keeping the game fresh even after multiple plays.

For potential buyers, Submarine is more than a historical curiosity. It’s a compelling, interactive duel that emphasizes strategy, timing, and player interaction. Whether you’re a retro collector, a tabletop gamer looking for a digital twist, or someone seeking a fun competitive pastime, Submarine delivers an experience that’s both charmingly old-school and surprisingly deep.

Retro Replay Score

null/10