Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Backyard Wrestling: Don’t Try This at Home takes the core of traditional grappling mechanics and transports them into a gritty, fluid environment where nearly every object within arm’s reach becomes a potential weapon. Wrestling need not be limited to a ring and bare arms—in this title, bricks, tables, chairs and even garden tools are fully destructible and integrated into your moveset. Every slam through a wooden table or tumble onto a pile of rubble feels dynamic, thanks to a physics engine that reacts in real time.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The damage modeling is unapologetically brutal, complete with full blood and gore that splatter across the screen during high-impact maneuvers. This graphic presentation, combined with an intense rock-rap soundtrack blasting between matches, creates an adrenaline-fueled atmosphere that pushes players to attempt increasingly risky stunts. While the visceral feedback of ripping through a stack of crates or crucifix-bombing an opponent through a car hood can be immensely satisfying, it also means this is not a game for younger audiences.

With 30 pre-configured wrestlers to choose from—each with unique stats, special moves and ring personalities—you’ll find yourself experimenting with different fighting styles, from the high-flying daredevil to the powerhouse brawler. For those who want a personal touch, the creation suite lets you design your own backyard bruiser: customize appearance, movesets and finishing maneuvers, then pit your creation against the established roster in solo or multiplayer modes. The result is a robust package that keeps matches fresh, whether you’re online or passing the controller to a friend.

Graphics

The visual presentation of Backyard Wrestling leans heavily into its underground aesthetic. Environments are richly detailed, featuring chipped paint on fences, scattered household debris and patchwork lighting that casts dramatic shadows across backyard arenas. Each location—from suburban lawns to makeshift junkyard rings—feels lived-in and personalized, enhancing the sense of raw, unregulated combat.

Character models deliver solid variety: ripped clothing textures, glistening sweat effects and dynamic blood splatter all contribute to the visceral feel of each encounter. While faces can occasionally look a bit stiff in close-up dialogue scenes, the in-match animations—especially when you body-slam an opponent onto a barbecue grill—more than make up for small imperfections. Camera angles dynamically adjust during high-flying moves, giving you a front-row seat to the action without sacrificing clarity.

Lighting and particle effects shine brightest when the action peaks. Sparks fly as metal chairs clash, embers glow when a wrestler crashes onto a flaming barrel, and blood droplets scatter naturally across surfaces. The combination of gritty textures and thoughtful post-processing filters gives the game an almost documentary-style vibe, reinforcing that this is underground wrestling in its rawest form.

Story

Unlike traditional wrestling titles that build a sprawling narrative around championship belts and stadium tours, Backyard Wrestling opts for a minimalistic story framework. You’re cast as an up-and-coming brawler eager to prove your mettle in a series of underground tournaments. Between matches, brief cutscenes and monologues introduce rivalries and stakes, but the emphasis remains firmly on the violence and spectacle rather than an elaborate plot.

Each character’s background is hinted at through their entrance videos and taunts, offering snippets of personality—be it the former high school quarterback turned backyard rebel or the masked luchador seeking redemption outside the ring. While these vignettes lack the depth of a full-blown narrative campaign, they do provide enough context to make matchups feel personal. Rivalries simmer with tension, and seeing your custom wrestler square off against a nemesis you’ve come to hate adds fuel to the fire.

Multiplayer bouts forgo storyline entirely, but players can create their own narratives through match stipulations and community-hosted events. Whether you’re reenacting a grudge match in your friend’s backyard or streaming heated 1-on-1 showdowns online, the emergent stories often outshine the game’s modest official tale. In Backyard Wrestling, your most memorable moments will likely stem from unexpected stunts and improvised rivalries rather than scripted story beats.

Overall Experience

Backyard Wrestling: Don’t Try This at Home delivers an unapologetically violent and visceral wrestling experience that stands out in a crowded genre. Its destructible environments and graphic damage modeling offer a level of interactivity rarely seen outside niche fighting titles. Coupled with a hard-hitting rock-rap soundtrack, every match feels like a hardcore show in your own backyard—complete with all the thrills, spills and messy aftermaths.

While the lack of a deep narrative might deter players seeking a cinematic wrestling saga, the game more than compensates with its robust roster and extensive customization options. The simple control scheme lets newcomers jump right in, while advanced grappling and environmental stunts reward those willing to master timing and positioning. Casual players will appreciate the pick-up-and-play appeal, and hardcore fans will find replay value in discovering new combos and stage hazards.

In summary, Backyard Wrestling isn’t for the faint of heart or the underage crowd, but for adult gamers craving over-the-top action and creative use of surroundings, it delivers in spades. Whether you’re a solo competitor looking to build your legend or a group of friends eager for chaotic multiplayer brawls, this title offers a one-of-a-kind wrestling playground that’s as unpredictable as it is brutal. Just remember: don’t try these moves at home—unless you’re playing the game.

Retro Replay Score

5.9/10