Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Gunfighter II: Revenge of Jesse James picks up right where its predecessor left off, offering two distinct play modes—Story and Arcade—that cater to both narrative-driven players and those seeking a pure score-chasing challenge. In Story mode, you follow the legendary outlaw Jesse James on a vengeance-fueled journey through a variety of Western settings, from dusty frontier towns to dimly lit mines. Each stage tasks you with blasting away wave after wave of outlaws before time runs out, creating a relentless pace that keeps you leaning into the trigger.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The game’s core shooting mechanics are satisfyingly tight, with quick target acquisition and a reticle that feels responsive even in the heat of a multi-gun drawdown. As you dispatch standard grunts, pocket watches occasionally drift onto the screen—hitting one rewards precious extra seconds on the clock and injects an addictive risk-reward element. Do you spend an extra second picking off a watch, or press on to mow down the next bandit before time expires?

Boss encounters punctuate each area, offering memorable set-pieces and unique weapons you unlock upon victory. These boss fights are more than mere bullet sponges: they employ movement patterns and attack cues that force you to stay alert and adapt on the fly. Whether you’re in the methodical hunt of Story mode or the high-score frenzy of Arcade, Gunfighter II’s gameplay loop remains a taut, arcade-flavored shooter that rewards both accuracy and split-second decision-making.

Graphics

For a sequel to a 2001 PlayStation classic, Gunfighter II pushes the hardware with surprisingly crisp visuals and a bold color palette that evokes the arid beauty of the Old West. Backgrounds are rich with detail—from the flickering lanterns in a miner’s tunnel to the sun-bleached textures of a desert canyon—creating an immersive frontier atmosphere. Character sprites are well-animated, with smooth gun-drawing motions and splintering wood effects when your bullets find their mark.

While polygon counts and texture resolutions reflect the game’s roots on earlier hardware, the art direction leans into stylization to mask technical limitations. Enemies are distinct silhouettes, making it easy to prioritize threats on-screen, and environmental props—wagons, barrels, campfires—are placed with a painterly eye for composition. This approach not only preserves performance but also maintains clarity during the most hectic firefights.

The user interface strikes a practical balance between rustic charm and readability. Ammo counters, time meters, and life gauges resemble old-timey dials and gauges, reinforcing the period setting without obscuring your view of the action. Even in split-second moments, you’ll always know when it’s time to Duck & Cover—or let loose with a hail of lead.

Story

Revenge of Jesse James thrusts you into the hardened boots of America’s most infamous outlaw, driven by a singular goal: to hunt down the bandits who betrayed him. The narrative unfolds in bite-sized vignettes between levels, using brief cutscenes and terse on-screen captions that echo the terse, stoic dialogue of classic Westerns. While the storytelling isn’t Shakespeare, it delivers just enough grit and swagger to keep you invested in Jesse’s vendetta.

Each locale you traverse contributes a new chapter to the tale—whether tracking clues in an abandoned mine or ambushing a gang’s hideout at dusk. Boss characters are introduced with flair, sporting distinctive backstories and signature weapons you’ll claim as your own trophy upon their defeat. This cyclical reveal of foes and firepower gives the campaign a satisfying progression that complements the shooting gameplay.

Though the plot leans on familiar Western tropes—double-crossing deputies, hidden treasure, a final showdown at high noon—the brisk pacing and punchy presentation ensure you never feel bogged down. Missions flow quickly, and the promise of newly unlocked armaments maintains momentum, making the narrative feel less like a lecture and more like a desert-soaked shootout you can’t turn away from.

Overall Experience

Gunfighter II: Revenge of Jesse James delivers a lean, mean Western shooting experience that strikes a strong balance between arcade thrills and story-driven ambition. The dual-mode structure ensures both newcomers and series veterans can find their groove—whether they want to savor Jesse’s path of vengeance or simply chase high scores in a shoot-‘em-up gauntlet. The pocket watch mechanic, boss unlocks and time-pressured stages give each run a palpable sense of urgency.

Although it doesn’t reinvent the wheel, the game’s confident art direction, responsive controls, and varied level design combine into a cohesive package that will appeal to fans of rail shooters and Western aficionados alike. Minor drawbacks—such as occasional pop-in and the absence of deep narrative branches—are easily forgiven by the steady drumbeat of adrenaline-fueled duels and the satisfaction of picking off outlaws with pinpoint accuracy.

For anyone seeking a taste of Old West justice served up in bite-sized, bullet-riddled segments, Gunfighter II: Revenge of Jesse James is a rewarding ride. Strap in, cock your iron, and prepare to stake your claim as the fastest gun north of the Rio Grande—just don’t blink, or you might miss your chance at redemption.

Retro Replay Score

6.2/10