Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

NHL Open Ice: 2 On 2 Challenge delivers an electrifying arcade-style hockey experience that feels instantly familiar to fans of NBA Jam. Players select from all 26 NHL teams of the 1995–96 season, each featuring two-on-two action that emphasizes fast-paced puck battles, big hits, and high-flying goals. The simple control scheme—pass, shoot, body-check—makes it easy for newcomers to pick up, while the deep roster of 120 real NHLPA players, complete with reflective stats, rewards those who learn each skater’s strengths and weaknesses.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The defining feature of the gameplay is the “Hot Meter.” Every successful pass, goal, or bone-crushing hit fills this meter, and once it maxes out, your skater literally bursts into flames. In this heated state, attributes like shot power, checking, and skating speed are temporarily boosted, turning a standard shift into a game-changing power play. Strategically building and unleashing the Hot Meter adds a satisfying risk–reward dynamic, as you may sacrifice short-term possession for the opportunity to dominate with supercharged talent.

Variety is baked into every match thanks to five adjustable difficulty settings, customizable period lengths, and a slew of cheat modes like “Big Head.” These options let casual gamers crank up the chaos while purists can settle in for a more balanced challenge. Multiplayer modes shine brightest here: whether you’re cooperating two-on-two against the CPU or going head-to-head with friends, the pick-up-and-play design fosters endless matches, clutch comebacks, and the occasional hilarious fluke goal.

Commentary by Chicago Blackhawks announcer Pat Foley further breathes life into each contest. His color commentary cues up after highlight-reel plays, delivering enthusiastic calls that amplify the arcade feel without overstaying its welcome. In sum, NHL Open Ice nails the sweet spot between accessible fun and strategic depth, making every shift an opportunity for jaw-dropping plays and memorable rivalries.

Graphics

The visual presentation of NHL Open Ice captures the mid-’90s arcade spirit with vibrant colors, exaggerated animations, and detailed team branding. Player sprites are bold and cartoonish, allowing you to distinguish skaters easily even amidst the blur of on-ice action. Hockey jerseys and rink boards flaunt authentic team logos and color schemes, reinforcing the NHL license and deepening immersion for die-hard fans.

Animations are fluid and impactful. Body checks send opponents flying into the boards with comical spins, slap shots erupt in pixelated eruptions of ice and spark, and fiery “on fire” skaters light up the ice with dynamic flame effects. While the game doesn’t aim for realism, these over-the-top animations deliver constant visual feedback, making each big hit or momentum swing feel triumphant.

The user interface remains clean and intuitive, displaying player names and Hot Meter gauges without cluttering the rink. Menus sport crisp logos and straightforward layouts, allowing players to dive into exhibition or tournament modes in seconds. Even on hardware of the era, load times are minimal, and the frame rate holds steady through the most chaotic sequences, ensuring the action never feels choppy or delayed.

Special modes like “Big Head” add an extra layer of visual humor, transforming star players’ helmets into oversized caricatures that bob wildly with each stride. These playful graphical flourishes underscore the game’s lighthearted ethos, reminding users that the fun factor takes priority over simulation fidelity.

Story

As an arcade sports title, NHL Open Ice forgoes a traditional narrative in favor of pure, pick-up-and-play competition. There’s no season mode storyline or dramatic career progression—your journey unfolds shift by shift, goal by goal, fueled by the thrill of arcade spectacle rather than an unfolding plot. That said, the game’s structure subtly weaves a sense of progression through its tournament ladder and unlockable cheat options.

The authentic NHL license acts as the closest thing to a narrative, allowing you to rally real-world teams like the Detroit Red Wings or New York Rangers under their official banners. Competing with star players—complete with real 1995–96 season stats—gives each match an organic context: you can rally underdogs to shocking upsets or forge your own dynasty against the league’s best.

Commentary from Pat Foley adds a loose thread of ongoing drama, with his enthusiastic calls framing each goal as a highlight-reel moment. While there’s no voice-acted cutscene or player backstory, Foley’s energetic narration injects a playful storyline into every match, making even casual exhibition games feel like must-see broadcasts.

Ultimately, the narrative thrust of NHL Open Ice resides in the stories you create with friends—epic comebacks, buzzer-beating goals, and underdog victories. The lack of a traditional story mode keeps the focus squarely on immediate gratification and replayability, inviting players to write their own legends shift after shift.

Overall Experience

NHL Open Ice: 2 On 2 Challenge stands out as a quintessential arcade hockey game that balances accessibility with arcade-style thrills. From the moment you fire up the title screen, the game’s infectious energy—bolstered by bold graphics, roaring commentary, and over-the-top power-ups—signals that you’re in for a wild ride rather than a down-to-the-wire simulation.

The combination of authentic NHL license, roster depth, and simple yet strategic mechanics creates a perfect environment for both casual play and competitive matchups. Friends can jump in for fast-paced co-op sessions or intense head-to-head rivalries, and the adjustable difficulty settings ensure every skill level finds an appropriate challenge. The Hot Meter mechanic provides exhilarating momentum swings, rewarding both timing and teamwork as you strive for that blazing-hot performance.

While there’s no traditional storyline or deep career mode, the game’s emphasis on quick, action-packed sessions enhances its longevity. The joy of discovering a new star pairing, experimenting with Big Head mode, or pulling off a last-second overtime winner ensures that each playthrough feels fresh. Even decades after its original release, NHL Open Ice retains that arcade magic, serving as a nostalgic time capsule and a remarkably fun party game.

For fans of arcade-style sports games and hockey enthusiasts alike, NHL Open Ice: 2 On 2 Challenge offers a compelling blend of speed, spectacle, and licensed authenticity. Whether you’re chasing high scores solo or engaging in heated multiplayer showdowns, this title delivers a puck-pounding good time that’s hard to resist.

Retro Replay Score

6.1/10