Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Great Baseball delivers an authentic major-league experience right from the first pitch. You step onto the diamond with full control over pitching mechanics—choosing between fastballs, curveballs, or the sneakiest sliders—and timing your swings to connect for powerful hits. The game’s responsive controls make it easy to feel like a pro, whether you’re aiming for a home run or executing a hit-and-run play.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Beyond solo play, Great Baseball shines in its multiplayer mode. You can challenge friends locally or hone your skills against the CPU, adjusting difficulty settings to match your expertise. With teams ranging from New York and Toronto to Milwaukee, Chicago, Seattle, Boston, and more, you’ll find endless replay value as you test your talents against different lineups and ballparks.

A key highlight is the pitcher-selection system. Before each game, you pick your hurler based on specialty—power pitcher, finesse thrower, or balanced starter—and stamina ratings. Managing pitcher fatigue becomes crucial in longer matches and tournament settings, making every decision on the mound feel strategic. Combine that with responsive fielding controls and base-stealing mechanics, and you have a deep, engaging baseball sim that rewards practice and strategy.

Graphics

From the lush green outfield to the detailed dirt on the base paths, Great Baseball’s visuals capture the texture and atmosphere of big-league ballparks. Stadium backdrops feature realistic lighting that shifts seamlessly from day to night games, while dynamic shadows add depth to every play. The diamond feels alive, with grass patterns and infield chalk lines that bring authenticity to each matchup.

Player models are crisp and well-animated, showcasing smooth pitching wind-ups, dynamic batting swings, and fluid fielding motions. Even the crowd has been given attention: digital fans wave banners and perform synchronized cheers, adding to the immersive stadium environment. Subtle touches—like umpires signaling safe or out and on-deck batters warming up—enhance the realism throughout.

The selection of ballparks offers a nice variety, from cozy urban fields to expansive modern coliseums. Each stadium has its own color palette, scoreboard aesthetics, and ambient crowd noise, making each matchup visually distinct. Weather effects—light rain, overcast skies, or bright sunshine—further vary the look and feel, ensuring that no two games ever look exactly the same.

Story

Great Baseball doesn’t lean on a traditional narrative but crafts its own story through season and tournament modes. You’re not just playing isolated games—you’re building a legacy. Guide your chosen team through a full schedule, handling trades, lineup adjustments, and all the off-field decisions that make baseball more than just nine innings of action.

The sense of progression comes from seeing your team’s record improve, watching rookies develop into all-stars, and experiencing the highs and lows of pennant races. Rivalries intensify as you face the same opponents week after week, and you’ll find yourself invested in rematches to settle unfinished business. This emergent storyline, shaped by your victories and defeats, offers more narrative heft than any scripted cutscene.

Even in exhibition mode, the game sprinkles small narrative touches: announcer comments about slumps and hot streaks, post-game interviews that recap turning points, and in-game prompts highlighting player milestones. While there’s no overarching tale, the cumulative effect is a living baseball world where your actions craft the story.

Overall Experience

Great Baseball strikes an excellent balance between arcade accessibility and deep simulation. Beginners will appreciate the straightforward controls and helpful tutorials, while seasoned players can dive into strategic depth with pitcher management, situational hitting, and defensive shifts. The variety of teams, ballparks, and game modes keeps the experience fresh for hours on end.

Multiplayer sessions feel particularly rewarding: whether you’re trading friendly jabs with a buddy in local play or climbing leaderboards online, Great Baseball fosters a competitive atmosphere that mirrors the camaraderie of a real clubhouse. And with the CPU AI adapting to your style, every match can feel like a new challenge.

Overall, Great Baseball offers engaging gameplay, polished visuals, and a living “story” crafted by your triumphs and setbacks. For anyone seeking a faithful baseball simulation that captures the thrill of America’s pastime, this game is a home run.

Retro Replay Score

5.8/10