Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Double Murder Mystery Pack presents two classic point-and-click adventures that lean heavily on logical deduction and environmental exploration. Both titles invite players to carefully examine crime scenes, collect and combine items, and interrogate suspects. The interface remains true to the genre’s roots: an easy-to-use inventory bar, a contextual cursor for actions like “look,” “use,” and “talk,” and a hint system that can be toggled on for less experienced sleuths.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

In Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None, gameplay revolves around an ever-shrinking cast trapped on a remote island. Puzzle design here is often intertwined with the narrative—discover a hidden compartment in a bedroom, deduce the owner of a mysterious letter, or align clues from multiple rooms to piece together a timeline of events. The difficulty ramps up smoothly, encouraging methodical note-taking and careful questioning of each suspect.

Murder on the Orient Express, by contrast, unfolds aboard a moving train, with each compartment offering new puzzles and alibis to unravel. Players switch between Hercule Poirot and an assistant, balancing the detective’s legendary observation skills with a secondary character’s resourcefulness. Some sequences even require real-time decisions, such as choosing which carriage to inspect first before the train arrives at its next stop. Both games reward patience and attention to detail, making every clue feel impactful.

Graphics

Visually, this pack relies on richly rendered pre-rendered backgrounds that capture the period details of the 1930s. In And Then There Were None, the isolated mansion and its surrounding beaches are depicted with muted color palettes and subtle weather effects, reinforcing the game’s ominous atmosphere. Character models are expressive, though largely static, with facial animations reserved for key dialogue moments.

Murder on the Orient Express takes advantage of narrower corridors and ornate train carriages, creating a more claustrophobic feel. The vibrant upholstery and polished wood come alive under the game’s dynamic lighting system, which simulates the train’s movement through tunnels and sunlit plains. While textures occasionally show their age at higher resolutions, the overall art direction remains faithful to Christie’s era and adds depth to each environment.

Both games include animated cutscenes that enhance pivotal plot developments. Though not blockbuster-level CGI, these sequences effectively convey tension—an intense storm on the island, or Poirot’s dramatic reveal in the drawing-room of the Orient Express. Minor graphical quirks persist, such as occasional clipping in character animations, but they rarely detract from the immersive period setting.

Story

At the heart of this mystery pack are two of Agatha Christie’s most celebrated plots, adapted with care for the interactive medium. And Then There Were None faithfully recreates the novel’s sense of mounting dread as ten strangers arrive on an uncharted island, only to discover they are being targeted one by one. The game preserves Christie’s signature twists, ensuring that even seasoned readers will be kept guessing.

Murder on the Orient Express centers on the brilliant detective Hercule Poirot, who must unravel a murder in the middle of a snowbound train. The narrative excels at pacing: early scenes introduce the eclectic passenger list, while subsequent chapters shift seamlessly between tense interrogations and surprising revelations in private compartments. Voice acting brings the characters to life, with nuanced performances that capture accents and social mannerisms of the 1930s.

Both storylines are enriched by well-written dialogue, detailed journals, and collectible “evidence cards” that players can review in an optional case file system. These narrative devices not only aid in solving puzzles but also allow for deeper engagement with each character’s backstory. Players who take time to read every letter and diary entry will find themselves more invested in the ultimate resolution of each mystery.

Overall Experience

The Agatha Christie: Double Murder Mystery Pack offers tremendous value by combining two full-length adventure games in one package. Fans of classic detective stories will appreciate the depth and fidelity of each adaptation, while newcomers to the genre can enjoy guided hints and a clear interface. The dual-title format also means you’re getting hours of gameplay—between puzzle-solving, cutscenes, and thorough examinations, each game can last anywhere from 8 to 12 hours.

Technically, the pack runs smoothly on modern PCs, with compatibility patches that address older engine issues. Load times are minimal, and the user interface scales well for high-resolution displays. A built-in hint system lets players opt for gradual nudges or full solutions, catering to both casual gamers and hardcore mystery enthusiasts. Achievement enthusiasts will also find a set of in-game milestones, such as solving a chapter without hints or uncovering every hidden object.

Overall, this bundle is a must-have for those who love narrative-driven adventures and the golden age of detective fiction. While the gameplay mechanics may feel dated to fans of newer point-and-click hybrids, the strength of the writing, the fidelity to Christie’s original works, and the atmospheric graphics combine to deliver a truly immersive experience. Whether you’re exploring a storm-tossed island or probing the secrets of a lavish Orient Express carriage, the Double Murder Mystery Pack stands out as a compelling tribute to Agatha Christie’s enduring legacy.

Retro Replay Score

null/10