Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Age of Pirates 2: City of Abandoned Ships offers a vast sandbox experience in the Caribbean of 1665, giving you the freedom to carve your destiny as an adventurer, corsair, or merchant. Right from the start, you choose one of three characters—Diego Espinoza, Peter Blood, or Jan Stance—each with minor narrative tweaks, starter ships, and crew bonuses. But beyond that, the game places no hard restrictions: you can switch professions, change allegiances, and pursue your own path toward fame and fortune.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The core gameplay loop balances ship-to-ship combat, land skirmishes, and trading. Naval engagements are real-time affairs, requiring careful navigation and tactical use of your cannons, grappling hooks, and repairs under fire. On land, you’ll test your Light, Medium, or Heavy Weapons skills against bandits or rival captains, and occasionally sneak or negotiate your way through towns using Stealth or Leadership.

Character progression is entirely skill-based: every action—from firing a cannon to haggling for a better price—grants experience toward that skill. As you unlock levels, new Abilities like “Smooth Sailing” for ship combat or “Basic Defensive Arts” for personal duels become available. Ranks rise as a composite of your personal and ship skills, opening access to tougher opponents and richer treasures.

Trade assignments add another layer of strategy: buy sugar in Havana, sell rum in Port Royal, or chase exotic furs in St. Lucia. Markets fluctuate, so keeping an eye on supply and demand can turn your vessel into a floating gold mine. All the while, random events—hidden caches on uncharted isles or letters of marque—keep the experience fresh and unpredictable.

Graphics

Graphically, Age of Pirates 2 is a product of its era, yet it manages to conjure a believable Caribbean atmosphere. The tropical seas shimmer under dynamic lighting, and each port town features distinctive architecture—Spanish fortresses, English docks, and Dutch warehouses. Weather effects, such as sudden squalls or calm sunsets, add to the immersion, even if some textures feel dated by modern standards.

Ship models are detailed, with rigging, sails, and hulls that show battle damage over time, reinforcing the sense that your vessel is a living asset. When boarding, the camera shifts smoothly to ground level, and character animations—while not flawless—capture the rhythm of swordplay and pistol shots.

The UI leans toward utilitarian, with multiple panels for skills, inventory, and maps. It can feel cluttered initially, but most menus are logically organized once you learn where to find trade prices or crew morale statistics. Tooltips help clarify each capability and its impact, making skill management approachable for those willing to dig into the numbers.

Sound design complements the visuals with rolling waves, creaking timbers, and crewmates cheering or cursing during engagements. The musical score blends jaunty shanties and tense orchestral cues, subtly shifting to underscore a chase at sea or a duel onshore. While the audio may loop in longer sessions, it successfully reinforces the swashbuckling mood.

Story

Rather than a fixed narrative, City of Abandoned Ships offers an open-ended story that you write yourself. Each profession—adventurer, corsair, merchant—comes with its own set of quest lines and hooks. Adventurers might unearth lost temples or mythical wrecks; corsairs receive letters of marque to prey on enemy shipping; merchants chase lucrative contracts from colonial governors.

Selectable characters bring slight variations: Diego Espinoza hints at hidden Inca treasures, Peter Blood’s reputation precedes him among rival captains, and Jan Stance has contacts in Dutch trading guilds. These personal touches enrich role-playing without locking you into a single storyline, allowing you to pivot from treasure hunting to piracy or trade whenever you choose.

Side quests and random events fill the world with color—whether rescuing castaways, intercepting smuggling rings, or bargaining for rare spices. Conversations with governors and local factions can sway your standing, enabling new missions or triggering naval blockades if relations sour. This dynamic faction system ensures that your actions carry weight and consequences.

Although there’s no cinematic, scripted finale, reaching the rank of Admiral or amassing legendary wealth provides a satisfying sense of accomplishment. The absence of a rigid storyline might feel lacking to players seeking a linear plot, but for those who relish emergent narratives, every voyage becomes its own epic tale.

Overall Experience

Age of Pirates 2: City of Abandoned Ships shines as a deep, open-world pirate RPG with a steep learning curve and rewarding complexity. Its fusion of naval tactics, character-driven quests, and skill-based progression caters to players who love micromanagement and emergent storytelling. If you relish plotting trade routes by day and boarding enemy frigates by night, there’s no shortage of activities to keep you engaged.

The game’s age shows in some rough edges—periodic bugs, occasional pathfinding glitches on land, and a UI that feels cramped—but frequent mod support and fan patches have ironed out many issues. The community remains active, offering quality-of-life improvements and enhanced textures for those looking to modernize the experience.

Customization is a highlight: adjust your captain’s nationality, swap professions at will, and tailor your crew’s composition for optimal performance. This flexibility, combined with a living Caribbean world populated by traders, privateers, and rival nations, offers excellent replay value. Each new run reveals undiscovered treasures, alliances, and story twists.

Whether you’re a history buff chasing colonial intrigue or an RPG enthusiast who loves leveling up every arrow of capability, City of Abandoned Ships delivers a memorable voyage. Its ambitious scope occasionally outpaces its polish, but for fans of nautical adventures and open sandbox designs, it’s a treasure worth claiming.

Retro Replay Score

6.6/10