Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The American McGee’s Alice and Clive Barker’s Undying budget two-pack offers two distinct gameplay experiences, each leveraging its unique mechanics to draw players into a twisted world. In Alice, you navigate macabre re-imaginings of Wonderland through third-person combat and platforming segments that blend environmental puzzles with frenetic swordplay. The level designs surprise you with hidden pathways and cleverly placed collectibles, encouraging thorough exploration to unlock the game’s darker secrets.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Clive Barker’s Undying, on the other hand, delivers a first-person survival-horror adventure where tension is built through limited ammunition, powerful supernatural enemies, and a reliance on arcane spells. The game’s dynamics center on resource management and quick thinking; a well-timed casting of a protective shield can mean the difference between survival and a grisly demise. The pacing alternates between moments of dread-filled suspense and frantic combat, creating a roller-coaster of adrenaline that horror fans will appreciate.

Both titles in this package emphasize atmosphere as much as mechanics. Alice’s combat is rhythmic and stylized, encouraging players to chain combos while avoiding grotesque enemies. In Undying, the arsenal of both firearms and magical abilities provides multiple approaches to each encounter. Whether you prefer gunning down cultists or turning the undead into charred remains with fire spells, the gameplay remains balanced and satisfying.

Finally, the learning curve in each game is well-paced. Alice gradually introduces new weapons—such as the Vorpal Blade and Pepper Grinder—while stacking environmental hazards that test your reflexes. Undying eases you into its spellcasting system, letting you experiment with various runic combinations against lesser foes before unleashing daunting bosses. Together, they form a duo of memorable gameplay experiences that cater to fans of action, horror, and exploration alike.

Graphics

Released in the early 2000s, both American McGee’s Alice and Clive Barker’s Undying sport visuals that still stand out for their creativity and ambition. Alice touts a gothic art style, with warped geometry and twisted character designs that breathe fresh malice into the once-innocent Wonderland. Sharp textures and dramatic lighting transform mushrooms and tea cups into eerie obstacles that both delight and unsettle.

Undying’s graphics emphasize moody environments, from decrepit manor halls to moonlit graveyards. The muted color palette and strategic use of shadows amplify the horror, making you second-guess every corridor. Enemies are rendered with gruesome detail—rotting flesh, glowing eyes, and spectral effects that flicker as you circle your foes. Despite the age of the engine, the careful art direction keeps Undying feeling immersive rather than dated.

Performance-wise, both games run smoothly on modest hardware, especially in their original PC iterations. The two-pack’s jewel cases preserve the original disc art and manuals, adding a tactile appreciation for the era’s aesthetic. Whether viewed on a CRT back in the day or modern displays via upscaling fixes, the distinct styles hold up thanks to strong silhouette work and imaginative level design.

Minor issues such as occasional texture pop-ins or low-resolution sprites surface, but they never detract from the overall mood. In fact, these quirks can feel nostalgic, evoking memories of PC gaming’s golden age. For those who prize artistry over photorealism, the graphics of both titles deliver a hauntingly beautiful experience worthy of revisiting.

Story

American McGee’s Alice reimagines Lewis Carroll’s classic tale as a psychological thriller. Alice Liddel returns to a Wonderland shattered by trauma, and the narrative unfolds through scraps of memory and cryptic boss encounters. Each level represents a fragment of Alice’s broken psyche, driving home themes of grief, revenge, and coming to terms with loss. The minimal dialogue is offset by environmental storytelling, making every hallway and boss fight feel laden with personal significance.

Clive Barker’s Undying weaves a gothic horror tale steeped in family curses, occult rituals, and the protagonist’s personal vendetta. You play Patrick Galloway, an occult investigator summoned to the eerie Irish estate of Jeremiah Covenant. As you uncover dark secrets about betrayal, immortality, and unholy pacts, the story thickens with each journal entry and cryptic tombstone. Conversations with ghosts punctuate the exploration segments, revealing layers of tragedy and vengeance.

Both narratives are bolstered by strong voice acting and atmospheric audio cues. Alice’s solitary musings and the haunting piano motifs underscore her existential plight, while Undying’s whispered incantations and distant screams amplify the tension. The two stories, though differing in scope—one psychological, one supernatural—share a commitment to immersive, emotionally driven storytelling.

Despite being budget reissues, the two-pack does not skimp on narrative presentation. The original manuals and artwork provide context for the lore, and the box itself feels like a collector’s item. For fans drawn to dark narratives and layered mythos, these titles deliver compelling worlds that stick with you long after the credits roll.

Overall Experience

The Electronic Arts budget two-pack of American McGee’s Alice and Clive Barker’s Undying represents outstanding value for players seeking distinctive, memorable adventures. You get two full-length titles that excel in their respective genres—action-platformer and survival horror—each offering 8–12 hours of playtime with additional depth unlocked via collectibles and multiple endings.

Whether you’re new to these classics or revisiting them for nostalgia’s sake, the physical presentation elevates the experience. The specially designed cardboard box houses each jewel case securely, and the included manuals feel authentic to the era. Unwrapping the package evokes the anticipation of yesteryear’s PC game releases, making it a treat for collectors and fans of tangible media.

Even today, the combined package holds up thanks to strong design, compelling atmosphere, and gameplay that remains engaging. Patches and community mods address compatibility on modern systems, ensuring that new players can enjoy both games without technical headaches. For those who relish dark fantasy and horror, this two-pack is an affordable way to dive into two of the early 2000s’ most imaginative titles.

In conclusion, this budget release is more than just a bargain; it’s a celebration of creative risk-taking in game design. From the shattered Wonderland of Alice to the haunted halls of Undying, you’re treated to two wholly unique experiences that deserve a place in any enthusiast’s collection. If you’re seeking eerie atmospheres, robust mechanics, and lasting replay value, this double feature is a must-have.

Retro Replay Score

null/10