Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Broken Sword Trilogy brings together three of the most iconic point-and-click adventures ever made, plus the bonus title Beneath a Steel Sky (Talkie version 1.2). Each game retains its classic inventory-and-dialogue mechanics, challenging players to combine items, interrogate NPCs and solve devious puzzles. You’ll spend hours clicking hotspots, dragging items and deciphering clues, just as the series intended.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The first two entries, Broken Sword: The Shadow of the Templars and The Smoking Mirror, stick to 2D backgrounds and sprite-based characters, offering intuitive controls and clever puzzle design. The third entry, Broken Sword: The Sleeping Dragon, ventures into 3D environments—sometimes clunky, yet ambitious—while still preserving the series’ signature logic puzzles. Beneath a Steel Sky provides a welcome change of pace with its dystopian cyberpunk setting, injecting a fresh challenge into the collection.

Across all four titles, the difficulty curve remains balanced. Early puzzles ease you into the interface, whereas later challenges demand careful observation and lateral thinking. The unified menu system in this Trilogy edition streamlines navigation; you won’t have to relearn controls between titles. Veteran adventurers will appreciate the faithful emulation of original mechanics, while newcomers benefit from optional hints to avoid getting stuck.

Graphics

Visually, Broken Sword Trilogy celebrates its heritage. The first two Broken Sword games feature richly painted 2D backdrops, from Parisian cafés to ancient catacombs. These hand-drawn scenes still look beautiful in higher resolutions, with cleaner lines and more vibrant colors than their 1990s counterparts. Character portraits shine during conversations, enhancing the comedic timing of witty banter.

The Sleeping Dragon’s 3D leap is more divisive. Some environments feel dated—blocky character models and awkward animations can break immersion—yet particular locales (like the underground Temple of Dragon) showcase striking lighting and atmospheric effects. Meanwhile, Beneath a Steel Sky’s Talkie version marries digitized backgrounds with smooth voice acting, creating a compelling neo-Gothic aesthetic that complements Cyberia City’s oppressive vibe.

Overall, the Trilogy’s graphical polish strikes a pleasing balance between nostalgia and modern presentation. Backgrounds are crisp, user interfaces are scaled for today’s high-DPI displays, and character animations retain enough nuance to convey emotion. Whether you prefer 2D artistry or 3D exploration, the collection retains its charm while looking better than ever.

Story

At the heart of Broken Sword Trilogy is the unfolding mystery of the Knights Templar. In The Shadow of the Templars, American tourist George Stobbart and French journalist Nico Collard uncover a globe-spanning conspiracy, racing from Paris to a hidden Parisian catacomb. The Smoking Mirror takes them to Central America, where ancient Mayan mythology collides with modern greed. Each narrative twist deepens the bond between the unlikely duo and keeps you guessing until the final cutscene.

The Sleeping Dragon introduces a more personal stake: a friend’s kidnapping and a shadowy military organization with world-ending ambitions. Although the shift to 3D sometimes dilutes the intimate dialogue of its predecessors, it still delivers compelling set pieces and memorable locations. Meanwhile, Beneath a Steel Sky offers standalone relief with its satirical cyberpunk plot—Robert Foster’s quest to escape a floating city governed by a tyrannical AI feels distinct yet resonates with the Trilogy’s theme of uncovering hidden truths.

Throughout the collection, writing shines with sharp dialogue and well-paced exposition. Characters feel real, with Nico’s wit and George’s steady determination forming a satisfying partnership. Side characters, from shady informants to enigmatic villains, add color and keep each chapter fresh. If you crave smart storytelling woven into your puzzles, this Trilogy delivers on every front.

Overall Experience

Broken Sword Trilogy stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of classic adventure gaming. With approximately 30–40 hours of content across four titles, it offers exceptional value for players seeking a deep, narrative-driven journey. The balanced puzzle design ensures steady progression, while optional hint systems guard against frustration—ideal for both series veterans and newcomers.

Performance is rock solid on modern hardware and platforms. Load times are minimal, and button remapping ensures comfortable play with gamepads or mouse-and-keyboard setups. The seamless menu unifies all four games under a single launcher, letting you switch between medieval crypts and dystopian cityscapes in seconds.

For anyone who treasures storytelling, clever puzzles and atmospheric design, Broken Sword Trilogy is a must-have. It preserves the soul of these adventure legends while polishing them for today’s audiences. Whether you’re reliving a childhood favorite or discovering George and Nico for the first time, this collection will leave you grinning at every plot twist and crowing “aha!” with every solved mystery.

Retro Replay Score

null/10