Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

City of Heroes: Good Versus Evil Combined Edition delivers an expansive MMO experience that lets you step into the shoes of both champions and criminals. From the moment you create your first character, the robust archetype and power-set options shine through, whether you’re soaring above Paragon City as a hero or commanding villainous forces across the Rogue Isles. The combined edition seamlessly merges the base game and its sequel, giving you access to a monumental roster of missions, side quests, and instanced challenges on day one.

Thanks to the inclusion of Issue 7: Destiny Manifest, you’ll encounter dynamic player-versus-player zones that offer organic PvP skirmishes alongside your PvE adventures. Villain Mayhem Missions add a layer of unpredictability as crime lords vie for control, forcing players to coordinate on the fly or ambush one another to achieve objectives. This blend of hero-vs.-villain conflicts keeps the action fresh and ensures that no two sessions feel quite the same.

The Combined Edition doesn’t just stop at story and PvP content—it boosts your toolkit with powerful extras. You’ll gain the Jump Jet Prestige Power for heroes, a sleek “Pocket D” VIP Card Teleport Power that allows instant travel back to home bases, and an array of unique costume pieces tailor-made for both sides of the moral spectrum. Four additional character slots further encourage experimentation, making it easy to try out new power combinations and roles without ever deleting an old favorite.

Graphics

Although City of Heroes debuted in the mid-2000s, the game’s stylized visuals have aged gracefully. Characters pop with vibrant color schemes, and costume customization ensures that your avatar stands out whether patrolling the gleaming spires of Paragon City or lurking in the shadowy alleyways of the Rogue Isles. The art direction favors a bold, comic-book aesthetic, which suits the super-powered theme and remains appealing even by today’s standards.

The environment design in both cities is impressively varied. Paragon City features modern skyscrapers, serene parks, and neon-lit nightclubs, while the Rogue Isles present dilapidated docks, gothic cathedrals, and storm-battered industrial zones. Dynamic lighting effects—such as lightning strikes in the Isles or the glow from villainous lairs—add atmospheric depth. Including a two-sided paper map of both regions is a thoughtful touch for collectors and newcomers who appreciate a tangible reference.

Performance-wise, the Combined Edition runs smoothly on modest hardware. Load times are reasonable, and frame rates stay consistent even during large group encounters or chaotic Mayhem Missions. Costume pieces that come bundled with this pack integrate seamlessly, ensuring that your hero or villain looks crisp without any graphical hiccups. For players focused on presentation, the game’s comic-book panel UI and cutscenes retain their charm and clarity throughout your entire playthrough.

Story

At its core, City of Heroes presents a classic tale of good versus evil with branching narratives that evolve based on your alignment. Hero players delve into the machinations of the notorious Juggernaut and unravel conspiracies threatening to engulf Paragon City. Villain players, meanwhile, rise through the ranks of the villainous cabal, orchestrating heists and unleashing chaos on unsuspecting citizens.

Issue 7: Destiny Manifest expands this narrative by introducing the enigmatic forces behind both heroes’ and villains’ greatest foes. The dynamic PvP zones aren’t just for show—they tie directly into the larger storyline, as rival powers clash over control of valuable resources that could turn the tide of the war. Mayhem Missions for villains reveal inner power struggles while pushing hero players to respond in force, creating a living storyline that reacts to player achievement.

Supplementing the in-game narrative, the digital copy of issues 1–6 of the City of Heroes comic is included, offering backstory and world-building that deepen your immersion. These comics dive into origin stories, highlight epic battles, and flesh out supporting characters whose fates you’ll influence in-game. This cross-media storytelling makes every mission feel more meaningful and connects you emotionally to the fate of Paragon City and the Rogue Isles.

Overall Experience

City of Heroes: Good Versus Evil Combined Edition represents exceptional value for both returning veterans and newcomers. By bundling the original game, its sequel, and the pivotal Destiny Manifest expansion, it provides hundreds of hours of content out of the box. The added goodies—exclusive powers, costume pieces, extra character slots, and physical collectibles like the two-sided map—make this an irresistible package for any super-enthusiast.

The learning curve is gentle, whether you’re familiar with MMOs or brand new to the genre. Community servers and fan-driven guides remain active, helping players form super-groups for larger raids and coordinating large-scale PvP events. The game’s sense of camaraderie is as strong now as it was at launch, thanks in part to built-in social tools and a welcoming player base eager to team up against global threats or rival factions.

Overall, City of Heroes: Good Versus Evil Combined Edition stands as a testament to enduring MMO design. Its blend of compelling gameplay, distinct visual style, rich storytelling, and extensive bonus content makes it a top pick for anyone seeking heroic—or villainous—adventures. Whether you’re drawn by nostalgia or exploring Paragon City and the Rogue Isles for the first time, this edition delivers a super-powered experience that’s hard to resist.

Retro Replay Score

null/10