Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

City of Villains (Collector’s Edition) expands upon the core City of Heroes engine by placing you firmly on the darker side of Paragon City. From the moment you create your first nefarious villain, you’ll notice the thoughtful balance between turncoat powers and the original archetypes. The supervillain archetypes—ranged attackers, summoners, and shadow-powered assassins—feel distinct and satisfying, offering considerable depth to both solo and group play.

Combat encounters are fast-paced, with an emphasis on crowd control and area-of-effect attacks that make you feel truly formidable. Each mission in Rogue Isles carries unique objectives—ranging from sabotage and kidnapping to large-scale assaults on rival mobs—ensuring there’s always a fresh twist. The game’s progression system rewards creativity: experimenting with power combos often yields surprises, and the skill trees encourage multiple playstyles.

The Collector’s Edition sweetens the deal with thirty days of free gameplay, allowing newcomers to dive deep into endgame content without worrying about subscription costs. In addition, the included 14-day trial for City of Heroes and 14-day trial for Lineage II serve as perfect gateways to adjacent NCsoft worlds, giving players a taste of different mechanics and communities at no extra charge.

Graphics

Even years after its original release, City of Villains retains a charming, stylized aesthetic that still holds up. Character models are bright and expressive, and the environments of Rogue Isles shimmer with neon-lit streets, toxic swamps, and towering clockwork towers. This Collector’s Edition enhances the visual experience through the full-color 144-page manual and The Art of City of Heroes and City of Villains book, which offer behind-the-scenes sketches and concept art.

Textures and visual effects, such as electricity arcs, toxic gas plumes, and fiery explosions, work smoothly on modern hardware. The quick reference guide included in this package even provides handy screenshots of power icons and interface layouts, helping new players navigate keybinding and HUD customization without constantly alt-tabbing for tutorials.

Beyond in-game graphics, the Collector’s Edition comes with a City of Heroes Trading Card Pack featuring 22 individual cards, plus a LIMITED EDITION individually wrapped trading card. These beautifully illustrated cards showcase characters like Statesman with cape and Black Scorpion, bringing the game’s vibrant comic-book style off-screen and into your collection.

Story

City of Villains throws you into the underbelly of Paragon City, where criminal masterminds vie for power amidst chaos and corruption. Unlike many MMOs, the narrative focuses on morally gray missions that challenge your ethics: will you execute a prison break for a sadistic warlord, or negotiate a temporary alliance with your rival to take down a larger threat?

The included Web of Arachnos novel flyer from CDS Books teases further lore, diving into the sinister machinations of the Arachnos syndicate. Paired with the in-game storytelling—complete with NPC dialogue, voiced mission briefings, and dynamic cutscenes—you get an immersive campaign that rivals many single-player RPGs in depth and intrigue.

Collectible HeroClix figures such as Positron, Ghost Widow, and limited edition Captain Mako* also tie into the story’s hallmark characters, giving players tactile reminders of their in-game rivals and allies. Each miniature comes with a small biography that enhances the broader narrative, bridging the gap between virtual villainy and tabletop strategy.

Overall Experience

The Collector’s Edition of City of Villains is a treasure trove for both new players and veteran supervillains. Beyond the core game, you receive a wealth of physical and digital goodies: thirty days free gameplay, quick reference guide, a 144-page manual, art book, and generous trial periods for sister NCsoft titles. This assembly of extras demonstrates the publisher’s commitment to world-building and player immersion.

For collectors, the HeroClix lineup—featuring Lord Recluse*, Manitcore, and Captain Mako*—adds tangible value and replayability. Whether you choose to engage them on the tabletop or simply display them on a shelf, these miniatures reflect the game’s larger-than-life cast. The City of Heroes Trading Card Pack and individual LIMITED EDITION card offer further proof that this edition transcends a mere software purchase.

Overall, City of Villains (Collector’s Edition) offers an engaging gameplay loop, vibrant graphics, compelling story arcs, and an unmatched package of extras that justify its premium price. Whether you’re drawn to the lure of supervillainy, the thrill of MMO combat, or the joy of collecting exclusive merchandise, this edition delivers a comprehensive experience that will appeal to any fan of superhero (or supervillain) gaming.

Retro Replay Score

null/10