Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

EverQuest: The Buried Sea introduces an array of fresh mechanics that reinvigorate long-time players and newcomers alike. Central to the experience is ship-to-ship combat, which allows guilds to customize vessels and engage in dynamic naval battles. This feature adds a layer of strategic depth, forcing you to balance your ship’s armaments, crew composition, and maneuvering tactics as you defend Katta Castrum from rival factions and sea monsters.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Beyond naval engagements, you’ll find over 60 new missions distributed across various quest hubs. These missions range from single-player reconnaissance runs to large-scale, multi-wave skirmishes that test your coordination and group strategy. With faction vendors offering unique rewards for loyalty, you’re encouraged to align with one of the Combine subgroups, each boasting its own progression track and exclusive gear. This branching quest design gives the expansion tremendous replay value.

The expansion also overhauls armor mechanics, introducing modular upgrades that can be slotted into your gear. Whether you prefer heavy plate, spell-casting robes, or agile leather, you now have greater control over defensive and offensive stats. Combining these new gear options with the existing skill trees empowers veteran players to craft highly specialized builds for both solo play and endgame raiding.

Crucially, guild emblems have been given new significance in The Buried Sea. Players can design and upgrade custom emblems that grant passive bonuses to all guild members—anything from increased ship speed to enhanced underwater breathing. This system fosters a real sense of community investment, rewarding guild leadership and membership with tangible benefits that scale alongside their involvement in the expansion’s content.

Graphics

The visual overhaul for The Buried Sea is immediately apparent the moment you breach the water’s surface. Underwater lighting effects create a luminous, bluish haze that bathes the entire environment, from the coral-encrusted sea walls to the grand spires of Katta Castrum. These atmospheric touches help differentiate the expansion from earlier zones and showcase the game’s ability to render diverse biomes.

Katta Castrum itself is a marvel of ancient architecture meeting aquatic decay. Crumbling statues of Combine champions loom over algae-covered plazas, while bioluminescent flora cast eerie glows along submerged corridors. Textures have been updated to include dynamic shaders that simulate the refractive properties of water, making each dive into the depths feel immersive and visually convincing.

Ship models receive a much-needed polish, with intricate wood grain, rusted hardware, and customizable sails that flutter realistically in tempestuous storms. The attention to detail extends to the combat animations, where cannon fire splinters water into fine droplets, and explosive impacts send shards of wood flying. This level of fidelity elevates ship battles from mere stat checks to cinematic engagements.

On the character front, the new armor upgrade system is complemented by high-resolution gear models. You’ll notice enhanced cloth physics on robes, metallic gleams on plate mail, and dynamic particle effects for enchanted items. Whether you’re a bard strumming on deck or a paladin wading through flooded chambers, the graphical enhancements breathe new life into classic EverQuest visuals.

Story

The narrative heart of The Buried Sea is the sunken Combine city of Katta Castrum, once the grand capital of the aquatic Combine empire. Players learn that Tsaph Katta, a legendary siren-like overseer, lies incapacitated within a central sanctum. The ancient energy field that has kept the crushing pressure of the sea at bay is failing, and if it collapses, the city—and the delicate balance of power across Norrath’s oceans—will be destroyed.

From whispered rumors in harbor taverns to epic raid confrontations, the expansion’s quests progressively unfold the lore. Early missions involve salvaging lost artifacts and deciphering Combine inscriptions, while later story arcs force you to choose allegiances in a tense political intrigue. Each faction—whether traditionalist loyalists or radical reformers—offers a distinct perspective on how to preserve or exploit Katta Castrum’s legacy.

Voice-over work and scripted cutscenes punctuate major quest milestones, giving personality to key NPCs like the zealous Captain Vharoth and the exiled scholar Merelith. Their conflicting motivations drive the plot forward and humanize the stakes beyond mere loot and XP. Strategic reveals about the Combine’s ancient rivalries and the true purpose of Katta Castrum keep the narrative engaging throughout all 60+ missions.

Ultimately, the story culminates in a multi-stage raid that challenges guilds to breach Tsaph Katta’s inner sanctum and decide the fate of the city. With multiple possible endings—ranging from a complete restoration of the energy field to a dramatic scuttling of the entire stronghold—your choices not only shape the conclusion but also impact future expansions and server-wide events.

Overall Experience

EverQuest: The Buried Sea manages to strike a balance between nostalgia and innovation. It honors the classic pillars of the MMORPG—exploration, group synergy, and world-building—while injecting new mechanics that broaden the scope of endgame content. Ship-to-ship combat alone is worth the price of admission for guilds seeking fresh arenas for competition and teamwork.

The rich environmental storytelling and high-quality visuals make each dive into Katta Castrum an adventure in its own right. Whether you’re charting unexplored trenches during solo dives or coordinating raids through flooded throne rooms, the expansion’s diverse settings keep the experience varied and visually captivating. Tutorials and leveling missions ease new players into the systems while offering veteran characters challenging tasks that scale with their gear level.

From a community standpoint, the guild emblem system and faction vendors foster a renewed sense of camaraderie. The competitive edge gained through emblem upgrades encourages guilds to rally around shared goals, while faction loyalty rewards provide a steady stream of unique cosmetics and gear. This social glue enhances the longevity of the expansion, giving reasons for players to log in even after completing the main raid.

In summary, The Buried Sea stands out as a robust addition to the EverQuest lineup. Its blend of naval warfare, intricate storytelling, and polished graphics provides both depth and accessibility. For anyone invested in the world of Norrath or looking for a fresh MMORPG expansion with substantial content, this installment is a compelling journey beneath the waves.

Retro Replay Score

null/10