Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Extreme Paintbrawl 2 attempts to deliver a fast-paced paintball experience, but the execution leaves much to be desired. You’ll find yourself traversing six new maps that range from industrial warehouses to overgrown forest clearings. While variety in settings is promising on paper, the core loop quickly reveals itself as repetitive: run, shoot, respawn, repeat. The lack of meaningful objectives beyond “eliminate the other team” makes matches feel shallow after just a few rounds.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

One of the most talked-about features of this sequel is its AI opponents—described in promotional material as “slightly brain damaged bots.” In practice, this is an accurate assessment. Enemies will often walk directly into incoming paintballs, freeze mid-crawl, or even moonwalk along walls in a glitchy imitation of parkour. While these quirks can be unintentionally hilarious on occasion, they undermine any sense of genuine competition or immersion.

Weapon handling is equally underwhelming. Each marker (paintball gun) shares nearly identical stats: slow rate of fire, low accuracy, and a narrow hit registration window. Upgrades and special ammo types promised by the developers are either non-existent or so subtle that you won’t notice a difference during play. Ultimately, Extreme Paintbrawl 2 feels like the same unrefined mechanics from the first game, simply replayed in different arenas.

Graphics

Visually, Extreme Paintbrawl 2 is stuck in a time capsule of late ’90s budget titles. Textures are blocky, character models are poorly rigged, and environmental details are minimal. Walls often look like flat color swaths with a single low-resolution paint splatter overlay to denote “battle damage.” The lack of lighting effects and particle systems makes even the most action-packed firefight appear lifeless.

Animations are a mixed bag of odd and broken. You’ll see your own character model perform stiff reload motions that lack any sense of weight or fluidity. Meanwhile, enemy bots frequently clip through geometry or freeze mid-stride—sometimes moonwalking along obstacles as if defying the laws of physics. Rather than adding charm, these glitches mostly draw attention to the game’s technical shortcomings.

That said, there are fleeting moments where the level design shines through. A foggy dockside map lends a faint sense of atmosphere, and neon signage in a derelict warehouse map hints at what could have been a stylish locale if given proper polish. Unfortunately, these instances are rare, and most environments feel barren and under-textured.

Story

Extreme Paintbrawl 2 doesn’t bother with narrative depth. There’s no campaign introduction, no character backstories, and certainly no evolving plot to follow. Instead, you’re dropped into matches with the flimsiest justification: “Paintball event happening here, so go paint some faces.” This barebones approach might work for seasoned multiplayer enthusiasts, but without any context or stakes, motivation quickly fades.

Any attempt at world-building is completely absent. The developers haven’t provided any lore about the six new locales, the teams you face, or the stakes behind each skirmish. You won’t learn whether you’re a rookie recruit or a famed paintball champion—you simply start shooting and hope for the best. Story-driven players will find this void frustrating rather than liberating.

Even the loading screens, which could have been used to pepper in tidbits of flavor text or match briefs, are nothing more than static images with boilerplate instructions. If you’re looking for a narrative hook to keep you invested, prepare to be disappointed—Extreme Paintbrawl 2 treats its setting like an optional bonus rather than a core feature.

Overall Experience

On its own merits, Extreme Paintbrawl 2 offers a handful of moments that might elicit laughter—mostly at the expense of its own broken AI and clunky animations. If you’re in the mood for a comical romp through glitch-ridden arenas, there’s a fleeting charm to be found in watching bots moonwalk along walls or glitch into non-combat poses. However, those moments are sporadic and can’t compensate for the game’s overwhelming lack of polish.

For players seeking serious competitive paintball action, this title falls short. The uninspired AI, repetitive gameplay, and low-budget presentation fail to deliver an engaging experience. While six distinct maps promise variety, the poor level design and sparse objectives mean you’ll likely tire of each locale within a single session. There’s simply not enough depth or refinement to justify extended play.

In the end, Extreme Paintbrawl 2 may only appeal to niche audiences: perhaps modders hoping to salvage something from the code, or collectors intrigued by its reputation as a retro curiosity. As a straightforward pick-up-and-play paintball sim, however, it’s hard to recommend this sequel to anyone looking for a cohesive, fun-filled experience. Excitement may be advertised “at every turn,” but you’ll have to look very closely to find it here.

Retro Replay Score

null/10