Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Neverwinter Nights 2: Mysteries of Westgate carries the core mechanics of the base game into a more focused, city-bound adventure. Rather than sprawling wilderness and multiple regions, every moment of gameplay takes place within Westgate’s three main districts and the winding sewers beneath them. This tighter scope gives quests a sense of urgency and encourages thorough exploration of every alleyway, rooftop, and hidden chamber.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Players must navigate the delicate balance between two powerful factions: the ruthless Ebon Claws crime syndicate and the devout Church of Lathander. Your decision to ally with one or the other not only colors your relationships with NPCs, it also alters quest availability and dialogue options. Though no new character classes or spells are introduced, these branching pathways provide meaningful replay value and reward players who enjoy moral choice and political intrigue.

Companion management remains a highlight, with three unique allies joining your cause. Each companion boasts distinct personalities and motivations, and they react dynamically to decisions you make about the mask’s fate and your chosen faction. Combat itself follows the tried-and-true NWN2 formula—tactical pausing, careful party formation, and strategic use of abilities—making familiar fans feel right at home while newcomers quickly learn the ropes.

Graphics

Visually, Mysteries of Westgate sticks to the Neverwinter Nights 2 engine without pushing radical enhancements, but it makes the most of its urban setting. The city’s districts—from the upscale Merchants’ Quarter to the shadowy docks—are rich in detail, with densely packed buildings, flickering lanterns, and bustling street vendors that bring Westgate to life.

A standout addition is the new sewer tile set, which transforms the city’s underbelly into a labyrinth of dripping tunnels, moss-covered walls, and ominous alcoves. The moody lighting and ambient sound effects heighten tension as you navigate these claustrophobic spaces, making encounters with the four new monster types feel genuinely threatening.

Monster designs in this expansion benefit from varied palettes and unique animations. Whether facing off against sewer-dwelling horrors or tracking down gang enforcers in narrow alleyways, the creatures and human adversaries look distinct from those in the base game. While the graphical fidelity remains consistent with NWN2’s 2006-era aesthetic, the careful art direction ensures Westgate has its own visual identity.

Story

Mysteries of Westgate centers on a simple yet compelling premise: your character has come into possession of a cursed mask that inflicts pain and haunting visions. This personal torment drives the narrative, as you follow cryptic clues to Hopdur—the city known as Westgate—seeking a way to remove the curse and uncover the mask’s dark origins.

Once in Westgate, the plot deepens as you choose between serving the underworld Ebon Claws or the pious Church of Lathander. Each faction offers its own quests, secrets, and narrative twists. Aligning with the Ebon Claws leads you into shady backroom deals, daring heists, and stealth-based objectives, while the Church path emphasizes ritual, investigation, and clashes with cultists seeking to exploit the mask’s power.

The campaign unfolds over a dozen or so substantial quests, culminating in a finale that ties together the mask’s backstory and the true forces at play in Westgate. Though the overall storyline can feel linear at times—there are no optional zones beyond the two faction lines—the writing is engaging, the NPCs are well voiced, and the revelation-driven pacing keeps you invested until the final confrontation.

Overall Experience

As an add-on to Neverwinter Nights 2, Mysteries of Westgate delivers a compact, story-driven adventure that feels more focused than the base game’s epic scope. By confining the action to one sprawling metropolis, the expansion maximizes NPC interaction, environmental storytelling, and the sense of a living, breathing city teetering on the edge of chaos.

Although it doesn’t introduce new classes, abilities, or major gameplay systems, the expansion’s strengths lie in its narrative choices, memorable companions, and atmospheric setting. The balance between crime syndicate politics and religious intrigue offers players two distinct playthroughs, enhancing longevity for those who want to see all sides of Westgate’s power struggle.

For fans of NWN2 looking to dive back into a rich D&D experience without committing to a full-blown campaign, Mysteries of Westgate is a rewarding stop. Its blend of urban exploration, character-driven quests, and moral dilemmas make it a worthy addition to any RPG enthusiast’s library—one that proves even familiar mechanics can feel fresh with the right story and setting.

Retro Replay Score

7.1/10