Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Scaryfish III casts a wide net when it comes to angling options, offering everything from minnows and turtles to channel catfish and even sharks. The core loop of baiting your hook, casting, and reeling in a catch is satisfying, but the depth comes from the sheer variety of equipment you can choose. Whether you’re fine-tuning your rod, selecting the perfect sinker weight, or experimenting with different bobbers, each trip to the water’s edge feels like a fresh challenge.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The game’s 1/4 time scale—where 15 minutes of real time equals one hour in-game—strikes a nice balance between pacing and realism. You can fish for up to four hours of game time per outing, pushing you to strategize: do you chase size records early on, or play it safe to maximize your haul? The inclusion of record books for both proud achievements and amusing failures (smallest fish, most bait lost) adds an extra layer of replayability, encouraging you to master different playstyles.

For players eager to customize their experience, the Make Your Own World Utility (MOWU) is a standout feature. With MOWU, you’re not limited to the default lakes, rivers, and oceans—create exotic fishing spots, stock custom fish populations, and even craft hidden challenges for friends. This level of creative freedom transforms Scaryfish III from a simple simulator into a sandbox where your fishing stories truly come to life.

Finally, progression in Scaryfish III caters to both newcomers and veteran anglers. You can opt for a modest starting kit and slowly earn money to unlock better gear and travel to new “worlds,” or begin as an “uber-character” with top-tier equipment from the get-go. This flexibility makes the game accessible: casual players can jump in without feeling overwhelmed, while hardcore simulation fans can grind for every trophy fish.

Graphics

While Scaryfish III’s visuals might seem dated by modern standards, they possess a rustic charm that complements the fishing atmosphere. Water surfaces ripple convincingly, and fish models—though blocky—are animated with surprising fluidity. The color palette leans toward earthy blues and greens, creating a tranquil ambiance that draws you into the lakeside setting.

Equipment and UI elements are clearly delineated, making it easy to distinguish between rods, reels, and accessories even in the heat of the moment. Menus are functional rather than flashy, presenting all your gear choices at a glance without unnecessary ornamentation. This straightforward approach ensures that technical layers don’t get in the way of the fishing action.

Though there’s no dynamic weather system or day-night cycle beyond the 1/4 time advancement, the game’s lighting does shift subtly as your session progresses. Morning mists give way to bright midday sun, and gentle dusk hues close out each trip. These small touches help reinforce the passage of time and keep the visual experience engaging over multiple sessions.

Story

Scaryfish III doesn’t follow a traditional narrative, but it weaves a personal story through your progression and choices. Starting from humble beginnings with limited funds, you carve out your reputation as an angler—each catch adds to the tale of your rise (or occasional missteps) on the blinking record boards. The absence of a linear storyline actually opens the door for player-driven narratives.

Your journey is defined by the destinations you unlock. From serene mountain lakes to deep-sea marlin hotspots, each new “world” brings fresh challenges and local legends to chase. You might spend one season pursuing elusive muskies, only to pivot and hunt down rare tropical species in the next. Through it all, the game’s open-ended structure encourages you to write your own fishing saga.

The MOWU also doubles as a storytelling tool. By crafting custom locations and populating them with mythical or prehistoric creatures, you can spin legends of fabled waters that only the bravest anglers dare to enter. Friends can share these bespoke environments, turning your personal fishing mythos into a multiplayer storytelling experience—no cutscenes required.

Overall Experience

Scaryfish III is a love letter to fishing enthusiasts and sandbox simulation fans alike. Its strategic depth—choosing gear, managing time, chasing records—keeps you hooked long after the novelty of casting wears off. While the graphics may feel retro, the gameplay systems are robust and layered, ensuring each outing offers something new.

The game’s pacing and progression model cater to different playstyles: grind through the ranks as a humble angler or hit the water in superstar fashion. The record books inject lighthearted competition, and the MOWU elevates the title from a closed simulation to a community-driven creative platform. If you’ve ever dreamed of designing your own fishing environment or tackling the ultimate trophy catch, Scaryfish III delivers.

In an era of blockbuster budgets and photorealistic visuals, Scaryfish III reminds us that depth of mechanics and player agency can be just as engaging. Whether you’re a casual weekend gamer or a dedicated simulation veteran, this game casts a wide appeal. So grab your rod, bait your hook, and dive into one of the most customizable fishing adventures on the market—Scaryfish III might just be the last fishing sim you’ll ever need.

Retro Replay Score

null/10