Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Sherlock Holmes Trilogy offers a rich tapestry of investigative gameplay, combining classic point-and-click mechanics with intricate puzzle design. In Sherlock Holmes: Secret of the Silver Earring, players meticulously examine crime scenes, collect clues and engage in logical deduction at the iconic 221B Baker Street. The interface is intuitive, allowing newcomers to dive right into the Victorian world while offering seasoned sleuths enough complexity to keep their interest piqued.

Moving on to Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened, Frogwares introduces a darker, more atmospheric gameplay layer. Here, you’re not just solving murders—you’re unravelling a cosmic horror plot that forces Holmes to balance forensic investigation with moments of stealth and careful resource management. The occasional action sequences and quick-time events keep the pace varied, ensuring that the narrative’s mounting dread never becomes monotonous.

In The Mystery of the Mummy, the trilogy rounds off with a thrilling archaeological expedition in Egypt. Players excavate tombs, decipher hieroglyphs and dodge ancient traps, all while interrogating suspects in sun-baked Cairo. The variety across the three games—ranging from urban crime scenes to supernatural horrors to archaeological escapades—ensures that the core deduction mechanics never feel stale. Each title builds on the last, refining the puzzle flow and offering a satisfying progression in both challenge and scope.

Graphics

Graphically, the trilogy spans two different technological eras of Frogwares’ development. Secret of the Silver Earring and The Mystery of the Mummy bear the hallmarks of early 2000s 3D adventure graphics: pre-rendered backgrounds, stylized character models and richly detailed set pieces. While character animations can feel stiff by modern standards, the period authenticity in costume design and location art remains impressive.

The Awakened, being a later release, presents a noticeable jump forward. The lighting effects are more dynamic, with shafts of moonlight cutting through foggy London streets and flickering lanterns casting ominous shadows. Textures are sharper, and the Cthulhu Mythos environments are realized with a haunting beauty that elevates the game’s horror elements. Although not photorealistic, the trilogy’s collective art direction captures the atmosphere of each case beautifully.

Across all three titles, Frogwares’ attention to environmental detail shines through. Crime scenes are littered with period-appropriate clutter: gas lamps, ink pots and leather-bound ledgers. Egyptian sets in The Mystery of the Mummy evoke a sense of dusty grandeur, complete with crumbling sarcophagi and intricate hieroglyphic murals. Despite occasional clipping or low-poly edges, the overall visual presentation remains charming and effective in supporting the narrative mood.

Story

At the heart of the Sherlock Holmes Trilogy lies the intellectual allure of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s most famous creation. Secret of the Silver Earring weaves a classic murder mystery with political intrigue, thrusting Holmes and Watson into a high-society scandal. The well-paced narrative lets you interrogate a colorful cast of suspects, each with their own secrets and motives, culminating in a satisfying finale that rewards careful note-taking.

The Awakened takes a bold detour into supernatural territory, blending Lovecraftian horror with Holmesian deduction. The story unfolds across ominous docks, abandoned asylums and shadowy alleyways, building tension through well-placed scares and sudden revelations. Though purists may balk at the paranormal twist, the script balances skepticism and wonder, allowing Holmes to remain the rational hero even as reality strains at the seams.

The Mystery of the Mummy grounds the trilogy in the golden age of exploration, delivering a narrative brimming with tomb-raiding excitement and scholarly rivalry. Hidden chambers, cryptic riddles and betrayals within the archaeological team keep you guessing until the final tomb door swings open. Each game offers its own thematic flavor while maintaining the core appeal of clever plot twists and deductive reasoning.

Overall Experience

The Sherlock Holmes Trilogy stands as a testament to Frogwares’ ability to craft engaging detective adventures across diverse settings. From the fog-laden streets of London to the ancient sands of Egypt, each title presents a unique challenge while retaining the cohesive charm of Sherlock Holmes’ world. The package value is undeniable: three full-length adventures for the price of one ensures hours of entertainment for mystery enthusiasts.

Players who appreciate slow-burn storytelling and cerebral puzzles will find this collection particularly rewarding. The learning curve is gentle, with in-game notebooks and hint systems that prevent frustration without diluting the satisfaction of solving a tough puzzle. Although some mechanics show their age—especially in the earliest game—fans of classic adventure design will view these as nostalgic rather than limiting.

In summary, the Sherlock Holmes Trilogy is an essential purchase for anyone fascinated by deductive gameplay and period mystery narratives. It offers a well-balanced blend of investigation, atmosphere and narrative depth. Whether you’re a long-time Holmes devotee or a newcomer eager to sharpen your detective skills, this collection provides an immersive journey through three memorable cases that stand the test of time.

Retro Replay Score

null/10