Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Sherlock Holmes vs. Jack the Ripper delivers a deeply engaging investigative experience, placing players at the heart of Victorian London’s most infamous murder spree. You alternate control between Holmes and Dr. Watson, each offering unique abilities: Holmes excels at forensic deduction and crime‐scene analysis, while Watson’s keen sense of observation and social ease help in extracting key information from witnesses. The ability to switch seamlessly between first‐person and third‐person perspectives adds flexibility, letting you zoom into minute details or enjoy a broader view of crowded backalleys and opulent drawing rooms.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Central to the gameplay are the new deduction boards, which require you to link clues, statements and forensic evidence to arrive at logical conclusions. As you gather fragments of testimony, coroner’s notes and street rumors, you must drag and connect evidence nodes on the board to form a coherent theory of the crime. This system encourages active engagement—rather than passively clicking through dialogue trees, you must critically weigh each piece of information before committing to a conclusion.

Exploration and puzzle‐solving are tightly interwoven. Crime scenes brim with interactive hotspots, from bloodstains and discarded trinkets to hidden compartments in furniture. Players frequently consult the in‐game map to navigate London’s winding alleys and use the dossier menu to review reports and documents. The result is a methodical pace that rewards patience and sharp observation, though some players may find the slower tempo a stretch if they’re used to more action‐driven adventures.

Graphics

The game’s real‐time 3D engine brings 1888 London to life with a moody, rain‐soaked atmosphere. Foggy streets and gaslamp glow cast long shadows that heighten tension, particularly in Whitechapel’s narrow alleys. Buildings are richly detailed, from the soot‐darkened brickwork of tenement houses to the polished wood panels of Scotland Yard. Character models exhibit period‐accurate clothing, though facial animations can sometimes feel a bit stiff during intense dialogue exchanges.

Lighting and particle effects play a key role in setting the tone. Flickering lantern light dances off damp cobblestones, and drifting steam adds an eerie veil to crime scenes. Indoor locations—from the cramped Whitechapel police station to the spacious front room at 221B Baker Street—are well‐staged, using volumetric light to create depth and realism. While some textures appear slightly blurred at close range, overall the visual fidelity contributes strongly to immersion.

Performance is generally stable on modern systems, with minimal frame‐rate dips even in densely populated areas. Load times between locations are reasonable, and the seamless camera transitions between exploration and close‐up investigations help maintain narrative momentum. The user interface is integrated neatly into the world, with unobtrusive menus that feel like Holmes’s personal casefile rather than a distracting HUD overlay.

Story

The narrative opens on the night of August 31, 1888, when a mutilated body of a “lady of the night” is discovered in Whitechapel. The brutality of Jack the Ripper’s methods shocks London, and Holmes—drawn by morbid fascination and professional duty—secures preliminary reports from the notoriously unhelpful Whitechapel police station. From that moment, the storyline unfolds as a dark, step‐by‐step detective drama, with fresh murder scenes raising the stakes and deepening the mystery.

Dialogue and character interactions are well‐crafted, giving life to a cast of suspects and witnesses. Some characters—beleaguered police inspectors, terrified streetwalkers and enigmatic aristocrats—offer fragmented clues, forcing you to sift truth from deception. The relationship between Holmes and Watson shines through: Holmes’s analytical arrogance is tempered by Watson’s empathy and moral compass, creating dynamic conversations that enrich the investigation.

The game does an admirable job of blending historical fact with creative fiction. Period details—newspaper headlines, coroner’s sketches and societal attitudes toward women in poverty—are used not just as window dressing but as integral puzzle elements. As you piece together a timeline of Jack the Ripper’s murders, the narrative steadily builds tension, culminating in a final revelation that ties together subplots and motivations in a satisfying, if occasionally predictable, climax.

Overall Experience

Sherlock Holmes vs. Jack the Ripper stands out as a mature, methodical detective game that will appeal to fans of classic point‐and‐click adventures and crime thrillers alike. Its focus on deductive reasoning and timeline construction offers deeper engagement than many genre peers, rewarding players who relish intellectual challenges over fast‐paced action. The atmospheric setting and period authenticity further enhance the sense of immersion, making each new clue feel weighty.

That said, the deliberate pacing can test patience—some puzzles require extensive backtracking or repeated examination of documents to uncover subtle evidence. A handful of interface quirks, such as occasionally unclear hotspot highlighting, may also interrupt the investigative flow. However, for those willing to immerse themselves fully in Holmes’s analytical world, these minor frustrations pale in comparison to the game’s overall strengths.

In the end, this installment secures Frogwares’ reputation for crafting thoughtful detective experiences. It combines a gripping historical storyline with robust puzzle mechanics and a richly realized Victorian London. Whether you’re a longtime Sherlock Holmes aficionado or a newcomer intrigued by the grim legend of Jack the Ripper, this game offers a compelling journey into the darker corners of 19th-century crime solving.

Retro Replay Score

7.2/10