Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Sonic Action 4 Pack offers a sprawling selection of classic Sonic titles, providing a varied gameplay experience that spans 2D platformers, an arcade racer, and a compilation of Sega’s cult favorites. Fans of high-speed side-scrolling will feel right at home with the iconic momentum-based physics of Sonic CD and Sonic & Knuckles Collection. These titles maintain the series’ trademark loop-de-loops and precise platforming challenges, and the collection’s emulation preserves input responsiveness remarkably well.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Beyond the 2D adventures, Sonic R introduces a fresh perspective by placing Sonic and friends in a lightweight racing framework. Though simplistic by modern standards, its controls and time-trial objectives feel charmingly nostalgic. Meanwhile, Sega Smash Pack 2 adds variety with its anthology of non-Sonic Sega classics, offering puzzle, action, and arcade diversions between hedgehog thrills.

One of the strongest points of this compilation is the seamless switching between CD-based titles. The built-in menu streamlines game selection, load times are minimal, and each game boots up with its original menus intact. While some minor slowdown occasionally surfaces in Sonic R’s more populated tracks, overall controls remain tight, and the gameplay loops of each title keep players engaged for hours.

Graphics

Visually, the Sonic Action 4 Pack delivers faithful reproductions of early-to-mid ’90s graphics, complete with pixel art that defined the Sega era. The 2D stages in Sonic CD and Sonic & Knuckles Collection pop with vibrant color palettes and crisp sprite work. On modern displays, these visuals can look slightly stretched if full-screen mode is used, but the option to play at native resolution preserves the original artwork without distortion.

Sonic R’s 3D models stand up surprisingly well, considering their age. Character animations are smooth, and environmental textures—though low-resolution by today’s standards—retain their bright, cartoony charm. Occasional texture shimmering can occur on faster hardware, but it rarely detracts from the experience. The inclusion of original loading screens and CD artwork adds an authentic touch for retro enthusiasts.

The Sega Smash Pack 2 titles vary widely in graphical style, from pixel-driven overhead perspectives to early polygonal demos. This assortment highlights Sega’s experimental edge during the CD era. While the graphics aren’t uniform across every game, the compilation’s presentation menu keeps the experience cohesive, and the box art scans in the simple documentation booklet provide a nostalgic peek at the original packaging designs.

Story

As a compilation, Sonic Action 4 Pack isn’t focused around a singular narrative but rather on showcasing four distinct experiences. Sonic CD offers a time-travel plot with Metal Sonic threatening to alter Angel Island’s timeline. Its animated cutscenes—faithfully preserved in this collection—are charmingly earnest and reinforce the game’s unique identity within the franchise.

Sonic & Knuckles Collection doesn’t advance a grand storyline beyond the classic loop of Dr. Robotnik’s schemes and Sonic’s race to stop him. However, the “lock-on” feature to merge with Sonic 3 injects an extra layer of continuity and narrative payoff as additional characters and zones are unlocked. It’s a satisfying cohesion of design and story, even if lightweight by modern standards.

Sonic R takes a backseat on narrative, instead emphasizing arcade-style racing objectives with minimal plot context. The Sega Smash Pack 2 entries each come with premise blurbs typical of mid-’90s anthologies, ranging from fantastical platformer scenarios to puzzle-driven tasks. While story isn’t the compilation’s main selling point, fans will appreciate the historical significance and period-authentic manuals that accompany each disc.

Overall Experience

From a value standpoint, the Sonic Action 4 Pack is a treasure trove for retro collectors and newcomers alike. By bundling two CD collections—Sonic & Knuckles Collection and Sega Smash Pack 2—with standalone releases Sonic CD and Sonic R, the package offers hours of diverse gameplay without any additional purchases. The price point, often lower than buying individual classics, makes it a cost-effective way to dive into Sega’s early CD era.

The physical presentation is delightfully minimal: four CDs nestled in a simple box, with a straightforward booklet that recalls the aesthetic of original jewel cases. While some may find the documentation sparse, it underscores the collection’s intent as a budget-conscious reissue rather than a premium remaster. For many, the nostalgia factor of slotting the discs into their drives and rediscovering familiar tunes will outweigh the lack of glossy extras.

Emulation quality across all titles is solid, and the compilation menu keeps things intuitive. Occasional slow-loading zones or minor graphical glitches feel like authentic hallmarks of the CD era rather than major flaws. Overall, the Sonic Action 4 Pack succeeds as a love letter to classic Sonic and Sega fans, balancing archival fidelity with accessibility. Whether you’re curating a retro library or simply looking for a comprehensive dose of hedgehog speed, this pack delivers a well-rounded and enjoyable experience.

Retro Replay Score

null/10