Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Strangeways places you in a tense, first-person survival horror experience where every corner of the island feels alive with unseen threats. Movement is handled via the keyboard, with smooth strafing and sprinting adjustments that let you evade or face the wraiths head-on. Aiming and firing the telekinetic “white balls” is intuitive with the mouse, allowing quick draws in the heat of combat and dynamic reactions to sudden ambushes.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The core combat loop revolves around the game’s signature telekinetic mechanic. Your white balls can be charged by holding the fire button, releasing a more powerful blast that can stagger or outright destroy wraiths. This risk–reward system forces you to decide between rapid, weak shots or slower, more devastating attacks—especially when multiple wraiths charge simultaneously.

Exploration feels equally rewarding. As you traverse dense forests, crumbling ruins, and open beaches, you’ll locate fragments of Jonathan Castle’s journal and ancient manuscripts describing the island’s dark past. Collecting these pieces not only fills in the lore but can unlock minor upgrades or clues on how to circumvent deadly traps. The sanity mechanic further deepens this loop: touch a wraith and the world distorts, forcing you to fulfill certain conditions—such as finding a nearby monument—to regain clarity.

Graphics

Visually, Strangeways excels at creating an oppressive atmosphere. The island’s dense foliage, shifting weather patterns, and decaying structures are rendered with a moody palette of greens, grays, and rusted browns that evoke an otherworldly gloom. Light shafts cutting through overgrown trees and drifting mist over deserted lagoons contribute to a palpable sense of isolation.

The wraiths themselves are haunting designs—ethereal silhouettes that flicker between solid and intangible forms. Their approach is telegraphed by a chilling distortion effect at the screen’s edges, building tension before they pounce. When you fire charged shots, particles cascade outward in shimmering waves, emphasizing the telekinetic power at your disposal.

The sanity shifts are among the game’s most memorable visual moments. Colors warp into sickly reds and purples, textures blur, and the HUD warps along with Jonathan’s fraying mind. Even after you partially restore your sanity at a monument, lingering glitches in the environment remind you that the mind can never fully heal. These effects are used sparingly enough to remain shocking without becoming overwhelming.

Story

At its heart, Strangeways tells the story of Jonathan Castle, whose New York–bound flight inexplicably crashes on an uncharted island. With no signs of other survivors—human or animal—he is left to unravel the island’s secrets alone. The initial calm of discovering a deserted landing site soon gives way to an unsettling realization: he is not alone.

Voices soon begin to echo in Jonathan’s mind, belonging to a cryptic group known only as The Strangers. Their whispers guide, taunt, and challenge him, blurring the line between ally and apparition. As he scours the island for journal entries and dusty manuscripts, the true history of the land emerges—tales of ancient rituals, sacrifices, and a power-hungry cult that once sought dominion over both body and spirit.

Throughout the journey, you piece together the narrative in nonlinear fragments, culminating in the discovery of a hidden crystal at the end of each level. These crystals appear to be the key to the island’s power—and Jonathan’s potential escape. The story threads remain just ambiguous enough to foster debate among players, yet coherent enough to reward thorough exploration.

Overall Experience

Strangeways offers an immersive survival horror adventure that marries tense combat, atmospheric exploration, and psychological thrills. The careful pacing ensures that moments of frenzied action are balanced by quieter segments of journal-hunting and environmental storytelling. This ebb and flow keeps players on their toes and fosters a strong desire to press on—if only to uncover the next secret.

The inclusion of a robust level editor adds significant replay value. Once you’ve conquered the base game’s challenges, you can craft your own island scenarios, design custom wraith encounters, and share your creations with the community. This DIY component transforms Strangeways from a single-player experience into a platform for endless horror experiments.

While the game occasionally stumbles with minor performance hitches during intense particle effects, these moments are rare and do little to detract from the overall immersion. For fans of survival horror who crave a blend of cerebral storytelling and visceral combat, Strangeways delivers a memorable island nightmare that will linger in your mind long after you’ve powered down the console.

Retro Replay Score

null/10