Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Thief: The Complete Collection shines in its innovative first-person stealth gameplay, setting a benchmark that many modern titles still strive to reach. Each installment—Thief: Gold, Thief II: The Metal Age, and Thief: Deadly Shadows—builds on the core mechanic of using shadows and sound to your advantage. The playstyle rewards patience, careful observation, and creative problem-solving, demanding that you plan your path through guarded estates, moonlit city streets, and sprawling underground complexes.

The AI in each game is tuned to feel both challenging and fair. Guards have distinct patrol patterns, varying levels of awareness, and the ability to call for reinforcements if they spot or hear you. You’ll learn to manipulate light sources, toss coins to divert attention, and use your iconic blackjack to knock foes unconscious. Thief: Deadly Shadows even introduces branching level designs and the freedom to explore Garret’s hideout, giving you a sandbox of options to tackle objectives.

Puzzle design plays a major role, too. Securing key items or bypassing locks requires you to explore every nook and cranny, rewarding meticulous exploration with hidden loot, secret passages, and rich environmental storytelling. Whether you’re cracking open a vault in Thief: Gold or sneaking through a clocktower in The Metal Age, each mission feels carefully crafted to encourage a “think-before-you-act” mentality.

Finally, the pacing across the trilogy is masterful. Early missions introduce you gently to the tools of the trade—rope arrows, water arrows, and lockpicks—while later levels escalate into epic set-pieces that combine stealth, light puzzle elements, and occasional direct confrontations. This gradual curve keeps the experience fresh, making the collection a deeply satisfying marathon for stealth aficionados.

Graphics

Although the original titles date back to the late ’90s and early 2000s, Thief: The Complete Collection holds up surprisingly well thanks to its atmospheric art direction. The stark contrast between light and shadow creates tension in every corridor and rooftop. Textures may feel dated by modern standards, but the moody color palettes and gothic architecture evoke an immersive, almost tangible world of damp stone walls and flickering torchlight.

Thief II: The Metal Age introduces more refined models and richer textures, particularly in industrial environments bristling with metal girders, steam pipes, and mechanical contraptions. Deadly Shadows takes a bold step forward with higher resolution character models and dynamic day-night cycles that shift the ambiance of the City. Watching dawn break over a misty harbor or navigating a moonlit cathedral courtyard demonstrates how far the series evolved in visual sophistication.

The lighting engine remains the star of the show. Dynamic shadows carve out hiding spots, and subtle reflections on polished floors alert you when you’re too close to a guard’s field of vision. Even without modern ray tracing, the layering of lights and darks renders the world alive, making each mission feel like playing through a gothic horror painting.

On today’s hardware, performance is smooth in the remastered versions included in the collection, with support for higher resolutions and widescreen monitors. If you crave the nostalgia of pixelated edges, you can dial down enhancements; for newcomers, the optional graphical boosts breathe new life into these classic worlds.

Story

At the heart of Thief: The Complete Collection is Garrett, the master thief whose cynical wit and moral code elevate what could have been a rote stealth trilogy into a character-driven saga. In Thief: Gold, Garrett is drawn into a web of conspiracies involving corrupt city powers, mystical artifacts, and glimpses of an otherworldly “Weird Age.” The narrative unfolds through overheard conversations, found documents, and cutscenes that place you directly in Garrett’s shoes.

Thief II: The Metal Age shifts focus toward organized religion and the perils of unfettered industrialization. The Vendetta storyline deepens Garrett’s world, presenting both familiar allies and unexpected betrayals. Dialogue is sparse but poignant, relying on environmental cues and brief mission briefings to immerse players in a morally ambiguous society teetering on the brink of revolution.

Finally, Thief: Deadly Shadows delivers a more personal tale. Garrett’s presumed-dead mentor, Artemus, becomes a ghostly presence guiding the thief through inner conflicts and external threats. The city itself feels alive, with neighborhoods that react to your deeds—friendly NPCs offering side missions, guards whispering rumors, and criminal factions staking out turf. This interplay creates a narrative you unravel piece by piece through your own actions.

Together, these three chapters form a cohesive and richly layered story that balances supernatural intrigue with social commentary. You’ll find yourself invested not only in Garrett’s goals but also in the shifting power dynamics of the City and the ambiguous forces manipulating events from the shadows.

Overall Experience

Thief: The Complete Collection is more than a simple compilation—it’s a definitive journey through the evolution of one of the stealth genre’s most influential heroes. From the intimate heists of Thief: Gold to the sprawling cityscape of Deadly Shadows, you witness Garrett’s growth and the series’ technological strides. Each title offers unique missions, fresh mechanics, and a consistent tone that binds them together.

For newcomers, this collection is an unbeatable introduction to classic stealth fundamentals: sound management, light versus dark, and environmental exploration. Seasoned fans will appreciate the quality-of-life improvements and easy access to all three games in one package. Whether you’re replaying favorite levels or discovering hidden collectibles for the first time, the collection’s scope delivers hours upon hours of engaging content.

The community around the Thief series remains passionate, with mods and fan patches available to customize visuals, tweak gameplay, and even add user-created levels. Combined with official remasters, these enhancements ensure that Thief: The Complete Collection feels both authentic and refreshed, bridging the gap between nostalgia and modern expectations.

In the end, if you value stealth gameplay that prizes strategy over spectacle, a moody and memorable setting, and a protagonist who embodies the rogue archetype at its finest, this collection is a must-own. It stands as a testament to the power of atmosphere and design in crafting unforgettable gaming experiences.

Retro Replay Score

null/10