Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Tolkien Collection offers a fascinating triptych of gameplay styles, each reflecting the source material in a unique way. The Hobbit delivers a classic action-adventure experience, challenging players with platforming segments, light puzzle-solving, and melee combat against goblins and spiders. Its tight controls and incremental difficulty curve make it accessible to newcomers while still providing enough challenge for Tolkien veterans.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring shifts gears toward hack-and-slash mechanics, letting you control multiple heroes—Aragorn, Gandalf, Legolas, and Gimli—as you fight through scripted encounters. Each character’s abilities feel distinct: Legolas’ ranged skill contrasts nicely with Gimli’s brute force, and Gandalf’s magic adds an extra layer of tactical depth. This variety helps maintain momentum throughout the nine chapters of the Fellowship’s journey.

Rounding out the package is The Lord of the Rings: War of the Ring, a real-time strategy title that tasks you with commanding armies of elves, dwarves, men, or orcs. Resource management, base building, and unit micro-control are at its core, giving players a broader, more strategic vantage on Middle-earth’s conflicts. The transition from action-adventure to RTS might surprise some, but it underscores the collection’s ambition to cover multiple gameplay genres.

Graphics

Visually, the Tolkien Collection spans the evolution of late ’90s game design. The Hobbit employs colorful sprite-based art and detailed backgrounds that evoke hand-drawn storybook illustrations. While its pixel art feels dated by modern standards, the charm and clarity of character animations still resonate, transporting you into the depths of Mirkwood and the halls of Erebor.

The Fellowship of the Ring takes you into early 3D territory, with polygonal models and pre-rendered environments that aim for cinematic flair. Character faces are simplified, and textures can appear blurry up close, yet the game compensates with dynamic lighting and sweeping camera angles during boss fights and set-piece moments. It’s a nostalgic reminder of the era when 3D worlds were a fresh frontier.

War of the Ring continues this graphical journey with an isometric perspective and richly detailed sprites representing units and buildings. Battlefields come alive with marching columns, clashing swords, and swirling spells. Although the graphical fidelity doesn’t match contemporary RTS blockbusters, the clear visual language keeps you informed of troop movements and battlefield status, which is crucial in strategic gameplay.

Story

All three titles draw heavily on J.R.R. Tolkien’s celebrated works, yet each interprets the source material differently. The Hobbit stays closest to Bilbo’s solitary adventure, weaving in familiar characters like Thorin Oakenshield and Smaug. Small narrative vignettes between levels help set the mood, though some lore enthusiasts may wish for deeper dialogue or more extensive exploration of Tolkien’s rich backstory.

In The Fellowship of the Ring, the game’s nine chapters loosely follow the path of the books, from the Mines of Moria to the breaking of the Fellowship at Amon Hen. While key plot beats are represented, certain scenes are condensed or altered for pacing and gameplay coherence. Still, fans will appreciate the voice work on essential lines and the evocative musical themes that echo Howard Shore’s iconic score.

War of the Ring takes more creative liberties, introducing “what if” scenarios and side campaigns that branch off from the main War of the Ring narrative. This approach offers fresh perspectives on pivotal battles, such as Helm’s Deep and the Pelennor Fields, allowing players to explore alternative outcomes. Although not strictly canonical, these variations add replay value and strategic intrigue.

Overall Experience

The Tolkien Collection stands out as a diverse anthology, showcasing three distinct gaming genres under one thematic umbrella. Its eclectic mix of platforming, action-adventure, hack-and-slash, and real-time strategy means there’s something here for nearly every kind of gamer. The compilation installer streamlines setup on modern PCs, and unified menus let you switch between titles with minimal fuss.

Challenges abound in each game: mastering platform jumps in The Hobbit, coordinating multi-character tactics in Fellowship of the Ring, or balancing economy and army composition in War of the Ring. While the graphic fidelity and control schemes reflect their original release eras, they remain surprisingly playable today—particularly if you’re willing to tweak settings or use community patches for updated resolutions and bug fixes.

For fans of Tolkien’s legendarium, this collection is a nostalgia-fueled pilgrimage through Middle-earth. It’s an opportunity to experience—or re-experience—the stories in interactive form, complete with memorable music cues and familiar locales. Newcomers may find some mechanics dated, but the sheer breadth of content and the enduring allure of Tolkien’s world make the Tolkien Collection a compelling purchase for those seeking both adventure and strategy in a single package.

Retro Replay Score

null/10