Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Name: Train Collection
Item: Train Collection
Author: Retro Replay

Train Collection brings together three distinct rail simulation experiences under one roof, offering a diverse gameplay palette for both newcomers and veteran railroad enthusiasts. Rails Across America leads the pack with its strategic route planning and economic management. Players must carefully allocate resources to expand their network, optimize freight and passenger services, and compete with rival companies. Each scenario presents unique challenges—navigating mountainous terrain, crossing rivers, and connecting emerging cities—making every campaign feel both fresh and historically grounded.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Ultimate Trainz Collection shifts the focus toward open-ended creativity and operational depth. Its sandbox environments and robust scenario editor empower players to design sprawling rail systems from the ground up. Whether laying down hundreds of miles of track, fine-tuning signaling systems, or scheduling complex freight runs, the sense of agency is unparalleled. You can transition seamlessly between overseeing the big picture—mapping entire supply chains—and stepping into the cab of a locomotive for a driver’s-eye view, enhancing immersion and strategic nuance.

Trainz: Paint Shed rounds out the package by allowing players to personalize their fleet with an intuitive livery editor. Here, the gameplay emphasis is on artistic expression rather than route logistics. From creating museum-quality liveries for historic steam engines to crafting bold, modern designs for high-speed trains, the editor is surprisingly deep. Completed designs can be easily shared with the community, adding a social dimension and extending replay value for players who relish customization.

Graphics

Rails Across America may show its age, but it retains a certain nostalgic charm. Terrain textures are straightforward, environments are functional, and train models are recognizable if somewhat blocky by modern standards. Although the engine lacks advanced lighting or shadow effects, it conveys the feel of expanding across the American landscape effectively. Trackside details such as grain silos and small hamlet stations help bring 19th- and early 20th-century settings to life, even if polygon counts stay modest.

Ultimate Trainz Collection steps things up with a more polished 3D engine. Rolling stock and locomotives are modeled with higher fidelity, featuring smoother curves and more detailed undercarriage components. Dynamic lighting and weather effects—rain-soaked rails, sun flares at dusk—enhance realism. Water reflections in rivers and lakes are particularly striking for a series that spans nearly two decades of development, showcasing how the Trainz engine has evolved over time.

Trainz: Paint Shed focuses less on environmental graphics and more on the precision of texture mapping. When you apply a new livery, you can zoom in to see how paint adheres to rivets, windows, and signage. The 2D livery canvas displays real-time updates on a 3D preview model, ensuring that decals and color gradients align perfectly. While the editor doesn’t push terrain or lighting boundaries, it delivers crisp, accurate representations of every brush stroke and decal placement.

Story

As is typical for many rail simulations, Train Collection doesn’t feature a conventional narrative; rather, the “story” emerges through strategic milestones and scenario objectives. Rails Across America offers a loose historical framework, guiding players through the transcontinental railroad era and the industrial boom that followed. Brief historical notes and period-appropriate commentary punctuate key events—such as connecting Omaha to Sacramento—providing context and a sense of progression.

Ultimate Trainz Collection relies on user-generated content to fill out its storytelling potential. In the absence of a set campaign, community-created scenarios often incorporate mini-plots: delivering critical supplies to remote towns before winter arrives, reconstructing rail lines after natural disasters, or participating in celebratory “steam festivals.” These bespoke narratives invite players to become both storyteller and engineer, weaving their own railroad sagas through task-based gameplay.

In Paint Shed, narrative happens at the workshop level. Each custom livery can carry its own backstory—honoring a railway’s centennial, commemorating a famous excursion, or branding a fictional high-speed service. While there’s no traditional plot to follow, sharing liveries and encountering others’ creations fosters an ongoing, communal narrative where each design tells a new chapter in a global rail enthusiast’s journey.

Overall Experience

Train Collection delivers remarkable value by combining three distinct experiences into one package. For strategy-minded players, Rails Across America provides a classic tycoon scenario filled with financial juggling and route optimization. Creative builders will appreciate the limitless possibilities of Ultimate Trainz Collection’s sandbox and editor tools. And for artists, Trainz: Paint Shed offers a dedicated space to design and share custom liveries, enriching every other rail simulation with personal flair.

Although the compilation spans multiple generations of technology—resulting in varying graphic quality and engine features—the unifying Trainz infrastructure ensures a coherent user interface and similar control schemes. Performance is generally smooth on modern PCs, though older segments like Rails Across America may require compatibility tweaks. A healthy online community further extends longevity, with thousands of routes, locomotives, and liveries available for free download.

Ultimately, Train Collection is best suited for railfans who seek depth and diversity rather than pick-up-and-play simplicity. The learning curve can be steep, especially when diving into scenario design or advanced economic modeling. Yet, the sense of accomplishment—from completing a cross-country railroad to unveiling a masterpiece livery—makes the effort worthwhile. If you’re passionate about all facets of railroading, this compilation offers a comprehensive playground brimming with discovery and creative potential.