Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Ultima Online: Lord Blackthorn’s Revenge builds upon the classic sandbox MMO foundation with a wealth of new content and refinements. The expansion introduces a variety of fresh creatures and items, each with unique behaviors powered by the improved AI. Whether you’re battling skeletal champions or taming exotic mounts, the heightened challenge keeps combat engaging—and encourages strategic group play for tougher encounters.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The addition of Ilshenar as a distinct continent dramatically expands exploration options. Players can traverse dense forests, perilous swamps, and hidden ruins in both the traditional 2D client and the newer 3D view. This dual-view support caters to purists who prefer pixel-perfect nostalgia and newcomers who appreciate modern camera angles and dynamic lighting.

Central to the expansion is the new Virtue system, which weaves moral choices into everyday gameplay. Decisions to assist or exploit NPCs leave lasting marks on your character’s reputation, influencing future interactions and unlocking special rewards. Combined with flexible skill‐based progression and the game’s free‐form economy, Lord Blackthorn’s Revenge offers deep, replayable experiences that reward both solo adventuring and large-scale player cooperation.

Graphics

Lord Blackthorn’s Revenge features striking new art contributions from Todd McFarlane, breathing fresh life into monster designs and environmental textures. Creature sprites are more detailed than ever, and the ominous fortress of Lord Blackthorn looms with menacing architecture. These enhancements give the expansion a distinct visual identity compared to earlier Ultima Online releases.

In the 3D client, character models and terrain reflect improved shading and richer color palettes, though they still carry a mild “retro” aesthetic. Animations—such as spell effects and creature attacks—appear smoother thanks to AI-driven behavior scripts, making battles feel more immersive. The 2D client remains true to its origins, with crisp, hand-drawn tiles that longtime fans will instantly recognize and appreciate.

While neither client can rival cutting-edge graphics seen in modern MMOs, the charm of Ultima Online lies in its stylized world and player‐customizable housing. Lord Blackthorn’s Revenge strikes a fine balance: it respects the game’s heritage while offering enough visual polish to keep the experience engaging for new players.

Story

The plot of Lord Blackthorn’s Revenge centers on the nefarious schemes of Lord Blackthorn, once a trusted ally of Lord British. When Blackthorn returns from exile with an army of nightmares, players must unravel his dark ambitions and thwart his bid for power. The narrative threads weave through newly accessible regions of Ilshenar, revealing hidden lore and ancient rivalries.

Quest design in this expansion varies from traditional “fetch and deliver” tasks to multi‐stage investigations that encourage exploration and puzzle solving. Dialogue with iconic NPCs—such as Lord British and the ever‐enigmatic Gargoyle tribes—adds personality to each assignment. As your actions influence your standing in the Virtue system, the story branches subtly, granting new dialogue options and secret rewards for virtuous (or villainous) deeds.

Despite its branching potential, the expansion’s core storyline remains linear enough to guide newcomers through the world’s deep history. Side quests and random world events further enrich the tapestry, ensuring that no two journeys feel identical. Whether you pursue Blackthorn’s downfall as a steadfast hero or a cunning opportunist, the narrative delivers memorable moments at every turn.

Overall Experience

Ultima Online: Lord Blackthorn’s Revenge stands out as one of the most ambitious expansions in the series. By blending new lands, refined mechanics, and a robust Virtue system, it revitalizes the classic MMORPG formula without alienating long‐time devotees. The choice between 2D and 3D clients broadens its appeal, and the monthly subscription fee of around $10 offers access to a persistent world brimming with player‐driven stories.

Social interaction remains at the heart of the experience. Guild politics, open‐world PvP, and the player‐run economy foster a dynamic environment where your decisions carry weight. While modern MMOs may boast flashier visuals, few can match Ultima Online’s legacy of community‐led content and the freedom to shape the game world with your actions.

For veterans of the franchise, Lord Blackthorn’s Revenge provides ample new challenges and lore to explore. Newcomers willing to embrace its old‐school charm will find a surprisingly deep and rewarding online adventure. In the end, this expansion underscores why Ultima Online remains a cornerstone of the MMORPG genre—inviting players to write their own legends in a living, breathing world.

Retro Replay Score

6.9/10