Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Watchmen: The End Is Nigh – Parts 1 and 2 deliver a visceral, beat-’em-up style of gameplay that stays true to the gritty atmosphere of the graphic novel. Players alternate between Rorschach and Nite Owl, each boasting unique combat moves, special abilities, and stealth tactics. While Rorschach’s brutal, up-close combat emphasizes relentless combos and improvised weapon use, Nite Owl relies more heavily on gadgets and environmental traps to dispatch foes.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Level design is tightly structured, with most stages unfolding along linear corridors punctuated by enemy-filled rooms and brief stealth sequences. The minimalist progression system rewards exploration with unlockable combat techniques and handfuls of audio logs that flesh out the backstory. Though the episodic runtime spans only five to six hours in total, the pacing remains brisk, and each chapter ends with a dramatic cliffhanger that compels players to press on.

Cooperative play is a standout feature, allowing two friends to team up locally and combine Rorschach’s savage melee prowess with Nite Owl’s strategic gadgetry. The drop-in/drop-out co-op scenario feels natural, with enemy difficulty automatically adjusting to a second player’s arrival. Although online play is not supported, the couch-based partnership captures the comic’s camaraderie and elevates the fun factor.

Graphics

The visual style of Watchmen: The End Is Nigh leans heavily on dark, moody color palettes, mirroring the source material’s noir-inspired aesthetic. Character models are detailed enough to showcase each hero’s distinctive costume textures—from Rorschach’s shifting inkblot mask to Nite Owl’s polished armor. Lighting and shadow effects further reinforce the oppressive atmosphere of crime-ridden streets and abandoned warehouses.

Environments, while somewhat repetitive, feature enough variety to break up the monotony. Players traverse graffiti-covered alleyways, derelict industrial complexes, and dimly lit rooftops that overlook a smog-choked city skyline. Subtle touches—like flickering neon signs and rain-slicked pavement—add realism, though some background textures can appear dated during close inspection.

Cutscenes stitch the episodes together with comic-book–style panel transitions, complete with onomatopoeic captions and dramatic close-ups. Voice acting stays remarkably faithful to the original Watchmen tone, capturing the moral ambiguity and hardened resolve of its protagonists. Occasional screen-tear or slowdown issues are rare but remind players of the game’s XBLA origins.

Story

Set in a prequel timeline to the events of Alan Moore’s seminal graphic novel, The End Is Nigh explores a brief but pivotal period in Rorschach and Nite Owl’s partnership. The narrative opens with the duo investigating a string of brutal murders that hint at a larger conspiracy threatening the tenuous peace of 1980s New York. This setup allows both heroes to shine, playing off Rorschach’s uncompromising justice and Nite Owl’s more methodical approach.

Story beats unfold through in-game dialogue, collectible audio tapes, and the aforementioned comic-style cutscenes. While the overall plot doesn’t reach the philosophical heights of the original text, it fills in gaps that fans of the franchise will appreciate. The writing balances gritty noir monologues with wry humor, lending emotional weight to each revelation without bogging down the action.

Part 2 ramps up the stakes by introducing new adversaries and deeper moral quandaries, culminating in a final showdown that feels suitably epic for the Watchmen universe. Character interactions grow more nuanced, showing how the protagonists’ contrasting worldviews both clash and complement each other. Although some loose ends remain, the duo’s dynamic drive the story forward and leave players eager for more adaptations.

Overall Experience

This retail release bundles both parts of The End Is Nigh in a single package, making it the definitive way to own this episodic adventure. For new players, the convenience of a one–two punch eliminates the hassle of multiple digital downloads. Returning fans benefit from improved load times and the ability to replay key sequences without navigating a storefront menu.

The concise runtime—approximately six hours total—means the experience is best suited for players who crave short, punchy sessions rather than an extended campaign. While repetition in level layouts and enemy types can surface over time, the combination of co-op mechanics, faithful art direction, and character-driven storytelling offsets any monotony. The game shines brightest when played with a friend on the same couch, amplifying its blend of teamwork and comic-book fun.

Ultimately, Watchmen: The End Is Nigh – Parts 1 and 2 offer a stylish, action-packed glimpse into a beloved universe. Though it may not redefine the beat-’em-up genre, its commitment to atmosphere, character, and cooperative thrills makes it a worthwhile purchase for fans and newcomers alike. This package honors the legacy of its source material while delivering a polished, focused gameplay experience that stands on its own merits.

Retro Replay Score

6.8/10