Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Lost Cities for Xbox Live Arcade faithfully recreates the elegant card-play of the original Reiner Knizia design, offering accessible yet deeply strategic sessions. Each player begins with eight cards and must decide whether to start new expeditions or build on existing ones in five colored sequences. When you launch an expedition by playing the first numbered card, you incur a 20-point entry cost, instantly raising the stakes and emphasizing risk versus reward in every decision.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The inclusion of Investment cards multiplies both gains and penalties, creating tense moments where a single bold play can dramatically swing the score. After each move—whether you play a card on an expedition or discard to the central row—you draw a new card, ensuring you always have eight options and maintaining a constant flow of choices throughout the match. This simple draw mechanic belies the layers of forward planning and hand management that keep seasoned players coming back.

Lost Cities supports both one-on-one matches against AI or human opponents over Xbox Live, and a two-on-two team mode where partners can pass cards to each other. This cooperative twist introduces new dynamics, as teammates coordinate expeditions and time their investment plays to maximize joint returns. Quick matchmaking and adjustable AI difficulty make it easy to find an evenly matched opponent or to hone your skills before challenging real players online.

Graphics

Despite its roots in a tabletop card game, Lost Cities on XBLA presents a clean, polished visual package that enhances readability and immersion. Each colored expedition track is distinct, with vivid hues that pop against the neutral board background. Card designs are crisp and legible, with large numerals and subtle texture details that echo the worn look of well-used playing cards.

The game’s main board sits atop a stylized archaeological site backdrop—complete with dusty rock formations and distant mountain ranges—which lends thematic weight to your expeditions. Animations are smooth and unobtrusive: cards slide into place with a satisfying snap, and discards glide elegantly to the central display. Even simple effects, like a faint glow when you play an Investment card, reinforce key gameplay moments without overwhelming the interface.

A notable visual bonus comes with Vision Camera support, allowing players’ Xbox avatars to appear beside their expedition tracks during online matches. This small touch of personalization injects personality into what could otherwise be a fairly static interface. Overall, the graphical presentation strikes a fine balance between style and utility—everything you need to play at a glance, wrapped in a tactile archaeological theme.

Story

As a digital adaptation of a minimalist card game, Lost Cities does not thrust you into a sprawling narrative with cutscenes or character arcs. Instead, its “story” is conveyed through the evocative expedition theme and the silent drama of risk-taking at a remote dig site. Each colored track—whether deep green for dense jungle or pale yellow for arid desert—hints at a different environment waiting to be explored.

Your adventures unfold through the cards themselves: playing a high-numbered card suggests a triumphant find of a rare relic, while investing heavily only to falter early can feel like a sudden sandstorm sweeping through your camp. This emergent storytelling, born from gameplay outcomes rather than scripted events, gives each session its own narrative twists and keeps matches feeling fresh and personal.

In lieu of a traditional story mode, the game relies on players’ imaginations and the thematic artwork to craft a sense of journey and discovery. The lack of dialogue or mission briefings may disappoint those seeking a structured storyline, but for fans of abstract strategy, the thematic veneer is precisely enough to spark curiosity and engagement.

Overall Experience

Lost Cities on Xbox Live Arcade offers a captivating blend of simplicity and depth, making it an ideal title for both quick lunchtime matches and longer, tension-filled contests. The core rules are straightforward and well-explained in a concise tutorial, yet the interplay of investment mechanics and sequential builds ensures that no two games ever feel the same. Casual players can enjoy a relaxed match against the AI, while competitive strategists will appreciate learning the subtleties of timing and card counting.

The multiplayer suite is robust, with reliable online play and the charming touch of Vision Camera integration. Team mode adds a fresh cooperative layer, encouraging communication and joint planning in a way few digital card games achieve. Even in local play, the clean UI and fast-paced turns keep the action moving without downtime or fiddly animations.

For fans of cerebral, low-fi gaming experiences, Lost Cities delivers exactly what it promises: an elegantly designed card game adaptation that’s easy to learn, hard to master, and endlessly replayable. It’s a smart addition to any Xbox Live Arcade library, offering tens of hours of strategic intrigue and competitive fun at a budget-friendly price. Whether you’re exploring solo against an AI rival or joining forces with a friend in team mode, this digital expedition is well worth embarking upon.

Retro Replay Score

6.9/10