Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles in Time Re-Shelled stays true to the frantic, side-scrolling brawler action that made the original arcade game a classic. Players step into the shoes of their favorite Turtle, each equipped with a single-button attack that flows into a satisfying combo chain. The simplicity of the control scheme belies the depth of strategic play, as you’ll learn to weave standard strikes, signature weapon slashes, and high-impact special moves into seamless assaults on hordes of Foot Soldiers.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

One of the biggest draws is the four-player co-op, available both locally and online. Whether you’re couch-co-op’ing with friends or coordinating combos with distant allies, the teamwork shines. Watching Leonardo hold foes at bay with precise sword strikes while Michelangelo spins his nunchaku in a whirlwind of orange flair is a delight—especially when you time special moves together for screen-clearing damage.

The level design faithfully recreates the arcade stages, from the neon-lit streets of New York City to the prehistoric dinosaur den. You’ll dash, jump, and slam enemies into walls and railcars as you progress. Though the remake omits the extra SNES-exclusive levels, its core stages have been lovingly polished, offering a consistent difficulty curve that ramps up boss intensity without feeling unfair.

Graphics

Re-Shelled’s most noticeable upgrade is its fully 3D-rendered environments and characters. Gone are the flat sprites of yesteryear, replaced by dynamically lit backdrops, detailed Turtle models, and fluid animations that give each flip kick and shell spin new weight. The arenas pop with neon signs, crumbling brick walls, and historically themed set pieces, all bathed in colorful lighting that highlights the chaos of battle.

Character design captures the personality of each Turtle, from Raphael’s scowl to Donatello’s thoughtful stance. Enemy models—the Foot Soldier ranks, mousers, and the occasional Triceraton—are varied and menacing, with each beat-down feeling more impactful thanks to the new particle effects. When you unleash a special move, the screen floods with vibrant bursts, enhancing the sense of power and spectacle.

While some purists may lament the loss of the original hand-drawn pixel art, Re-Shelled’s modern aesthetic succeeds in honoring the source material. The balance of retro shapes and forward-looking shaders ensures that both longtime fans and newcomers will appreciate the fresh take. Performance is generally stable, though online matches can occasionally suffer minor frame dips when the screen gets crowded.

Story

True to its arcade roots, Turtles in Time Re-Shelled keeps narrative elements to a minimum, focusing instead on non-stop action. The basic premise sees Shredder zap the Turtles back through time, forcing them to battle through eras ranging from medieval castles to the Cretaceous jungles. Each level is bookended by a classic boss fight, be it Rocksteady and Bebop or the elusive Krang.

Although the plot serves mainly as a backdrop, it’s fleshed out by snappy dialogue snippets and brief cutscenes. These moments, voiced in that familiar ’90s cartoon style, bring a smile to fans who remember Saturday morning Turtle marathons. Watching Donatello quip about “mutant dinosaurs” or Michelangelo crave pizza in a medieval dungeon adds just enough charm without derailing the momentum.

For players seeking a deeper narrative experience, the limited story might feel shallow. However, Turtles in Time has never been about complex storytelling—it’s about the thrill of teaming up with your friends and smashing your way through time. In that regard, Re-Shelled ticks every box, delivering a lighthearted adventure brimming with Turtle power and cheesy one-liners.

Overall Experience

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles in Time Re-Shelled is a nostalgic rush for fans and a tight, pick-up-and-play brawler for newcomers. The blend of faithful stage design, modernized visuals, and straightforward controls ensures that each play session feels both accessible and rewarding. Whether you’re grinding through waves of Foot Soldiers alone or with a squad of four, the game maintains a satisfying balance of difficulty and fun.

The online co-op mode expands the arcade’s local focus, making it easier than ever to reconnect with friends or meet new Turtle enthusiasts. Even with occasional netcode hiccups, the joy of coordinated special attacks and shared victories far outweighs any minor technical issues. Locally, you’ll love the chaos of four-player smackdowns as you duke it out with mobs of enemies and classic bosses.

While the omission of the SNES-exclusive levels may disappoint some completionists, Re-Shelled’s core offering is robust enough to justify its place on any shelf. It’s a testament to the enduring appeal of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and stands as one of the better arcade-style beat ’em ups in recent years. If you crave fast-paced, cooperative brawling with a side of pizza-fueled humor, this is the Turtle game you’ve been waiting for.

Retro Replay Score

6/10