Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Darkness fuses classic first-person shooting mechanics with a suite of supernatural abilities, creating a unique combat loop that keeps players engaged from start to finish. Armed with pistols, shotguns and assault rifles, Jackie Estacado can rain down bullets like any other shooter protagonist. However, the real twist comes when shadows envelop the battlefield—only then can The Darkness’s true powers be unleashed.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Switching between conventional firearms and the dark tentacles is seamless, allowing you to chain combos on the fly. In well-lit corridors, you’ll take careful aim and rely on cover. But step into the gloom, and you’ll find yourself tearing through hordes of enemies with tentacle strikes, summoning ravenous darklings to flank opponents, or crushing foes beneath maw-like appendages. The key to mastering the game is learning when to play it safe and when to surrender to the Darkness’s brutal instincts.

Beyond direct combat, The Darkness introduces puzzle and traversal elements that hinge on illumination. Certain doors or pathways can only be destroyed by a tentacle smash, while hidden alcoves become accessible only when you snuff out nearby lights. This interplay between light and shadow encourages exploration—scouring every nook of the game’s meticulously crafted levels to find health packs, Darkness orbs, and hidden dossiers that flesh out the world’s sinister underbelly.

Enemy variety also keeps encounters fresh. From lowly gunmen to heavily armored brutes and even supernatural foes, each class demands a different approach. The game’s difficulty curve is forgiving at first but steadily ramps up, challenging players to mix conventional firepower and dark powers rather than spamming one tactic. Boss battles, in particular, force you to rethink your strategy on the fly, whether by evading costly tentacle strikes in bright arenas or shutting down light sources to gain the upper hand.

The Darkness’s control scheme is intuitive, with dual analog sticks for movement and aim, and simple button presses to deploy tentacles or fire bullets. A quick-toggle wheel lets you select your active Darkness ability, from summoning a black hole to calling down lightning-like Darkness guns. This streamlined interface means you spend less time fumbling in menus and more time wreaking havoc.

Graphics

The Darkness uses a dark, noir-inspired art style that perfectly complements its story of crime and supernatural horror. New York’s gritty streets, dimly lit nightclubs and shadowy back alleys come to life with realistic textures and moody lighting. Rain-slick pavements and flickering neon signs add atmospheric depth, reinforcing the game’s perpetual tension between light and dark.

In supernaturally charged areas—particularly the Otherworld and Hell—textures take on a surreal, nightmarish quality. Flesh-like walls pulse and writhe, flaming skulls drift in the distance, and the sky turns a toxic crimson. These levels aren’t mere palette swaps; they feel like descent into a living painting of horror, with grotesque environmental details you’ll never forget.

Character models are equally impressive. Jackie’s trench coat moves naturally as he dashes or leaps, and blood spatters realistically on walls and clothing. Enemy models show wear on their gear, bullet holes, and torn clothing, heightening the visceral thrill of each firefight. The Darkness’s tentacles boast an oily sheen, their movement fluid and menacing, while summoned darklings scuttle with uncanny agility.

Lighting and shadow technology is arguably the star of the show. Real-time dynamic shadows mean your Darkness powers don’t just feel powerful—they reshape the entire scene. As you extinguish floodlights or smash lamps, darkness floods the environment, allowing tempting ambushes and stealth takedowns. Performance remains solid on mid-range hardware, though ultra settings truly showcase the game’s rich particle effects and volumetric fog.

Subtle details—like the flash of muzzle fire reflecting off rainy streets, or the glow of arcane symbols when you prepare a black hole—demonstrate a high level of polish. Texture pop-in is rare, and load times between chapters are reasonably short, keeping you immersed in Jackie’s grim world.

Story

The narrative thrust of The Darkness centers on Jackie Estacado, a hardened Mafia hit man whose life is shattered when an ancient curse awakens on his 21st birthday. Raised in the shadow of his great-great-grandfather’s dark legacy, Jackie’s forced initiation into horror is as personal as it is violent. The game wastes no time in thrusting you into a frantic escape from Paulie Franchetti’s henchmen, setting up the feud that drives the plot.

Jackie’s relationship with his girlfriend, Jenny Romano, adds an emotional core to what could’ve been a straightforward bloodfest. Jenny’s kidnapping provides the narrative motivation for Jackie’s rampage through the city’s criminal underworld, and her occasional radio check-ins ground Jackie in his humanity. These moments of vulnerability remind you that underneath the monster is still a man tormented by regret and grief.

The Darkness itself is a constant presence in Jackie’s mind, voiced with sultry menace by veteran voice actors. The entity’s dual role—mentor and tormentor—fuels one of the game’s most compelling conflicts: will Jackie remain in control, or will the Darkness consume him fully? Cutscenes emphasize this tension through reactive animations and split-second camera shifts that place you, the player, in Jackie’s fractured psyche.

Supporting characters, from mobsters to cops to supernatural entities, all receive enough screen time to feel memorable. Some are allies, some betray you, and all contribute to the sense that you’re caught in a conspiracy far bigger than a simple Mafia turf war. Plot twists unfold at a measured pace, culminating in a tense showdown that leaves room for introspection—and potential sequels.

Though grounded in the Top Cow comic source material, the game’s story stands on its own merits. Even if you’re not familiar with Jackie Estacado’s comic adventures, the narrative here is clear, coherent and punctuated by moments of brutal violence, dark humor and genuine pathos.

Overall Experience

The Darkness delivers a refreshingly different first-person shooter experience by weaving supernatural powers into a gritty crime drama. Combat never feels repetitive thanks to the dynamic interplay between light and dark mechanics, and the level design encourages creative problem-solving. Whether you prefer a hail of bullets or a rampage of tentacles, the game accommodates your style.

Visually, the game excels in atmosphere. Its masterful use of lighting, combined with haunting level design in the Otherworld and Hell, cultivates a sense of dread that lingers long after you set down the controller. The audio design—complete with unsettling whispers in Jackie’s ear and the distant clatter of subway trains—intensifies the immersion and underscores the game’s horror roots.

Narratively, The Darkness strikes a compelling balance between gangster tropes and supernatural intrigue. Jackie’s internal struggle against the voice in his head keeps you invested in his fate, while the tension between loyalty to his mob family and love for Jenny provides emotional stakes beyond mere bloodshed. The supporting cast rounds out a world that feels both dangerous and tragically human.

On the downside, lighting-dependent gameplay can sometimes lead to frustration if you find yourself stuck in overlit areas with limited cover. A few boss encounters feel artificially prolonged, and the linear progression may disappoint players seeking open-world exploration. However, these minor quibbles are overshadowed by the game’s overall polish and innovative mechanics.

In sum, The Darkness is a must-play for fans of narrative-driven shooters and supernatural thrillers. Its blend of visceral action, haunting visuals and a tightly woven storyline ensures that Jackie Estacado’s descent into darkness will be an unforgettable journey for any gamer seeking something beyond the ordinary.

Retro Replay Score

7.8/10