Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Backyard Wrestling 2: There Goes the Neighborhood delivers a raw, unfiltered approach to combat, blending traditional wrestling mechanics with environmental brawling. Matches take place across backyards, construction sites, busses, and trailer parks, each location packed with improvised weapons—trash cans, barbells, crowbars, you name it. The pick-up-and-throw system lets you hurl opponents into fences or through windows, establishing a visceral, chaotic feel that is the series’ hallmark.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The create-a-wrestler mode is surprisingly robust, offering a wide range of body types, attire, and signature moves. You earn fight points in tournaments and versus matches, unlocking new props, entrance animations, and special attacks. This progression loop keeps the grind engaging: every backyard federation you conquer reveals fresh hazards and rival fighters, ensuring no two bouts feel identical.

Controls are responsive, though the learning curve can be steep for newcomers. Mastering the timing of environmental takedowns and counter-moves is key. While some button combinations feel unintuitive at first, a few hours of play smooth out the rough edges. Multiplayer skirmishes are where Backyard Wrestling 2 truly shines, with up to four players duking it out in local versus mode—perfect for intense, laugh-out-loud sessions with friends.

Graphics

Technically, Backyard Wrestling 2 sits firmly in the early 2000s era, with character models that can appear blocky from certain angles. However, the developers offset these limitations with gritty art direction: peeling paint on trailers, rusted steel beams, and blood spatters rendered in bold, cartoony strokes. The overall aesthetic captures the underground, guerilla-style ethos of backyard brawling.

Each arena boasts interactive set pieces that break apart dynamically under stress. Whether you’re smashing an opponent through a wooden fence or sending them crashing off a rooftop, the physics-driven destruction remains consistently entertaining. Lighting and particle effects—like sparks from metal collisions—add just enough polish to keep the visuals compelling without straying from the game’s rough-and-tumble charm.

Character animations are a mixed bag: signature moves execute with flair, but generic strikes can sometimes look stiff. Facial expressions rarely change mid-match, yet running commentary and over-the-top taunts help infuse personality. Given the budget-conscious production, Backyard Wrestling 2’s graphics serve the gameplay rather than upstage it, and that’s precisely where its strength lies.

Story

There Goes the Neighborhood drops you into an all-out tournament spanning multiple backyard federations, each ruled by its own eccentric champion. There’s no cinematic narrative to speak of—storytelling happens through pre-match banter, locker-room cutscenes, and the escalating stakes of the million-dollar prize. This minimalist approach lets players dive straight into the action without wading through lengthy exposition.

Character backstories come alive via unlockable vignettes, showcasing the personal motivations and grudges fueling the competitors. You’ll learn why ‘Trashcan Tasha’ fights in abandoned lots or how ‘Pavement Pete’ earned his street-fighting moniker. While these snippets aren’t backbone-deep, they provide context for the brutal rivalries you’ll find yourself in, making victories feel earned and losses sting just a bit more.

Although the narrative framework is thin, it’s sufficient to drive you from one federation to the next. There’s a sense of progression that keeps you curious: What will the next backyard look like? Who will you face? The game’s blunt, DIY storytelling matches its gameplay ethos, ensuring that every match feels like a handcrafted, underground spectacle.

Overall Experience

Backyard Wrestling 2: There Goes the Neighborhood is a love letter to fans of hardcore, no-holds-barred brawling. It isn’t for those seeking polished, WWE-style glitz and glamour. Instead, it revels in grit, gore, and improvisation. The combination of environmental hazards, character customization, and multiplayer mayhem makes for an experience that’s both replayable and unpredictable.

Technical hiccups—framerate dips in densely interactive arenas and occasional collision detection quirks—are easy to forgive once you’re in the thick of a three-on-one brawl over a pile of steel rods. Unlockable content, from hidden fighters to outrageous props, provides a solid incentive to keep battling through the federations. Casual players will find plenty of fun in versus mode, while completionists can chase every trophy and secret challenge.

Ultimately, Backyard Wrestling 2 thrives on its unapologetic backyard brutality and creative use of environment as a weapon. If you’re drawn to over-the-top fighting games with a DIY spirit and enjoy fooling around with friends, this title stakes its claim as a wild party-game alternative to mainstream wrestling sims. Prepare for bruises, broken furniture, and unforgettable matches—you’ll either love the chaos or choose to stay in the ring for another round.

Retro Replay Score

5.4/10