Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Behind Closed Doors delivers a refreshingly offbeat gameplay loop that hinges on improvisation and environmental interaction. You guide The Balrog through a series of ingenious puzzles within the cramped confines of an outhouse, using nothing but a stubby pencil and your wits. Each puzzle feels handcrafted, from jury-rigged lock mechanisms to improvised tools drawn directly onto the walls with that forlorn pencil tip.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The controls are intuitive yet precise, allowing you to pick up objects, sketch helpful diagrams, and even carve notches in the wooden planks. As The Balrog scribbles notes from his beloved Goblins’ Gazette, you’ll unlock hints to bypass hidden traps or fashion makeshift keys. It becomes an addictive loop of observation, deduction, and just enough trial-and-error to keep you on your toes without driving you to madness.

What truly elevates the experience is the playful use of limited resources. Your pencil stub is both tool and lifeline, and watching its tip shrink with every scribble heightens the tension in a delightfully quirky way. Even mundane actions—like tightening a rusty bolt or prying open a loose board—become mini-victories. This resourcefulness-centric design makes you feel ingeniously clever rather than simply following a walkthrough.

Graphics

While not pushing the boundaries of photorealism, Behind Closed Doors embraces a stylized, hand-drawn aesthetic that perfectly complements its whimsical tone. Textured wood grains, exaggerated character models, and comical facial expressions give the outhouse setting more personality than many AAA titles muster in vast open worlds. The warm, muted palette evokes that cramped, rustic hideaway vibe while spotlighting interactive elements in brighter tones.

Close-ups of The Balrog’s weathered features—his furrowed brow, bushy eyebrows, and ever-present scowl softened by faint amusement—lend emotional depth to the proceedings. Animations are fluid, whether he’s furiously sketching on planks or cackling in triumph after a clever escape. Even background details, like faint goblin graffiti or dangling cobwebs, hint at past visitors and add to the cozy-yet-creepy ambiance.

Subtle visual cues—such as pencil shavings piling up or chalk outlines revealing hidden compartments—guide players without resorting to intrusive on-screen prompts. This unobtrusive design fosters immersion, encouraging you to scour every nook and cranny. The art style may feel modest compared to big-budget contemporaries, but its charm and consistency more than compensate for any technical limitations.

Story

At its heart, Behind Closed Doors is a darkly comedic tale of an aging rambunctious giant named The Balrog who simply wanted a peaceful morning routine. Instead, he finds himself trapped in the world’s smallest restroom by prankster goblins bent on mischief. The game brilliantly flips a mundane scenario into an absurd battle of wits—and you’re right in the thick of it.

The narrative unfolds through diary entries jotted in the Goblins’ Gazette, which blend tongue-in-cheek advice columns, goblin gossip, and cryptic clues to each puzzle. These snippets of lore are equal parts hilarious and helpful, fleshing out the goblin culture while giving context to your captors’ twisted antics. As The Balrog deciphers these ramblings, you piece together a surprisingly touching backstory about aging, respect, and the value of privacy.

Dialogue and narration are delivered with dry wit and impeccable timing. Each succeed-or-fail moment is punctuated by small narrative flourishes—a grumpy aside, a chuckle at your own clumsiness, or a defiant roar at unseen tormentors. This consistent tone keeps the stakes low enough for comedic relief yet high enough to keep you invested in The Balrog’s quest for freedom (and revenge).

Overall Experience

Behind Closed Doors strikes a delightful balance between challenge and charm, making it accessible to both casual puzzle fans and seasoned adventurers. The average playthrough clocks in around three to five hours, a brisk length that respects your time while delivering memorable moments at every turn. Replay value is boosted by multiple solution paths and hidden Easter eggs tucked behind secret panels.

The sound design deserves praise too: creaky floorboards, distant goblin guffaws, and the scratching of pencil on wood all heighten immersion. A sparse, whimsical soundtrack underscores key moments without overwhelming the game’s intimate atmosphere. It’s an audio tapestry that reinforces the humor and tension of your solitary confinement.

For a modest price point, Behind Closed Doors offers a wildly original premise executed with polish and heart. Its blend of inventive puzzles, charming visuals, and witty storytelling make it a standout indie title. Whether you’re drawn to its comedic premise or its clever mechanics, you’ll find plenty to love in this small-space adventure that proves greatness can flourish even in the tiniest rooms.

Retro Replay Score

null/10