Retro-Replay.com Retro gaming reviews, news, emulation, geek stuff and more!
Copyright Strikes Hit Popular Retro Gaming Channel
In a controversial move, Nintendo has begun targeting YouTube channels that demonstrate its games being emulated on third-party hardware. The latest victim of this crackdown is the popular channel Retro Game Corps, which recently received a copyright strike for a video showcasing Wii U games running on emulation devices.
Retro Game Corps, a channel with over 500,000 subscribers, specializes in reviewing modern handheld devices capable of emulating classic games. These reviews often include footage of Nintendo titles running on systems from manufacturers like AYANEO, Anbernic, and Retroid. The channel’s owner, Russ, believes he is being “specifically targeted by Nintendo,” as this latest strike comes after a previous one related to a device for copying Switch game cartridges.
Recently, Nintendo has taken action against Russ, the proprietor of the Retro Game Corps channel, by removing a video that specifically dealt with emulation of their products.
In a YouTube statement, Russ expressed his concern: “It does appear that my worst fears are true, and that I am being specifically targeted by Nintendo. My Wii U video was taken down and I received another copyright strike, even though this showcase video was no different than all of the tech demos and reviews I have made on this channel previously.”
Contemplating his next move, Russ is weighing the option of submitting a counter-claim based on fair use principles. He explains his reasoning: “as the video was for educational use, transformative in nature, and had no [effect] on the market – it was a demonstration of a console no longer for sale.” Nevertheless, he expresses hesitation about pursuing this course of action, stating he is “reluctant to open that can of worms with a multi-billion dollar corporation, as their next step would be to file legal action.”
I hate making posts like this, but I received another copyright strike this morning. I'm going to have to change the way I make videos. More info: https://t.co/ihGy4OLNzx pic.twitter.com/xRHx0PN2pn
— Retro Game Corps (@RetroGameCorps) September 28, 2024
Fair Use and Game Preservation Debate
The incident has raised questions about fair use and game preservation. Russ argues that his content is educational and transformative, demonstrating hardware capabilities rather than promoting piracy. He also points out that the Wii U is no longer in production and its online store has been closed, meaning Nintendo no longer profits from the console.
This aggressive stance by Nintendo has forced Retro Game Corps to alter its content strategy. Future videos will avoid showing Nintendo games, with existing footage being blurred out as a precaution. This change is likely to impact the channel’s ability to provide comprehensive reviews of emulation devices.
The gaming community remains divided on the issue. Some argue that Nintendo is within its rights to protect its intellectual property, especially given the legally dubious nature of many emulation devices. Others contend that such actions harm game preservation efforts and unfairly target content creators who help keep interest in classic Nintendo franchises alive.
As the debate continues, this incident highlights the ongoing tension between copyright protection and the preservation of gaming history. It also raises concerns about the future of game preservation if companies like Nintendo continue to shut down channels that advocate for keeping older games accessible.
What are your thoughts on this issue? Is Nintendo justified in its actions, or should there be more leeway for educational content and game preservation efforts? Share your opinion in the comments below.
