Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Sherman M4 places you in the driver’s seat of an iconic M4 Sherman tank, tasking you with commanding up to four of these vehicles alongside two jeeps and periodic artillery support. At any moment, you can hop into one tank for first-person action or switch to the tactical map view to issue movement and engagement orders to your entire squadron. The flexibility of playing “in the tin” or taking on a battlefield overview gives players the freedom to approach objectives in their preferred style.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The game’s three sprawling campaigns—Normandy, Ardennes, and Desert—offer a variety of mission types, from covert convoy ambushes to full-scale town captures. Objectives range from demolishing enemy bridges and bunkers to rescuing stranded jeeps behind enemy lines. Each mission is a test of resource management as well: you’ll need to capture hangars to repair, refuel, and rearm your tanks, making strategic advances all the more vital.

Before you roll out, Sherman M4 allows you to tweak realism settings such as armor penetration physics, vehicle damage constants, and allied versus enemy morale. You can even adjust enemy experience and commander skill levels, tailoring the challenge to suit novices or tank-sim veterans. This level of customization, paired with responsive AI that automatically reacts to threats on the tactical map, ensures each playthrough feels dynamic and rewarding.

Graphics

Sherman M4 leverages a solid 3D engine that faithfully recreates World War II battlefields. From rolling sand dunes in the Desert campaign to the dense forests of Ardennes, environments feel appropriately varied and immersive. Dynamic lighting accentuates the time of day, casting realistic shadows across your tank’s hull as you advance under fire.

The detail on each M4 Sherman is particularly impressive, with weathered paint, rivet-by-rivet armor plating, and puffing exhaust smoke during prolonged sprints. Enemy tanks and bunkers also exhibit distinct textures and damage states—shell impacts leave visible dents, while smoke trails hint at damaged engines or weapon mounts.

Performance remains stable even when multiple vehicles and artillery barrages light up the battlefield. Particle effects for shell explosions, dust clouds, and tracer rounds add a visceral edge to combat without bogging down frame rates. Whether you’re zooming in for precise targeting or pulling back to a strategic overview, the visuals maintain clarity and detail.

Story

Rather than weaving a cinematic narrative, Sherman M4 focuses on authentic mission briefs that ground you in historic WWII operations. Each campaign begins with context-setting dossiers: in Normandy you land amid the fierce hedgerow battles, in Ardennes you face the surprise of a winter counteroffensive, and in the Desert you tackle scorching open-terrain warfare.

Briefings are delivered through period-style maps and text, supplemented by radio chatter that lets you overhear commands from HQ and warnings from your own crew. This stripped-down storytelling keeps the spotlight on tactical decision-making, yet still conveys the high stakes of each operation and the sacrifices made by tank crews on both sides.

While there are no fully voiced characters or branching dialogues, the mission design and battlefield events—reinforcements arriving, flanking maneuvers, and sudden armored counterattacks—build a palpable sense of tension and achievement. Successfully capturing a key town or demolishing an enemy stronghold feels earned, thanks to the game’s no-nonsense approach to WWII combat scenarios.

Overall Experience

Sherman M4 is a robust blend of accessible tank simulation and tactical strategy. Its balance of in-cockpit action and map-based planning appeals to both simulation purists and players seeking a more commanding view of WWII battles. The customizable realism settings extend replayability, letting you dial the challenge up or down according to your preference.

Although it doesn’t feature a deep narrative arc or character development, the game’s authentic mission structure and varied objectives keep each campaign feeling fresh. The ability to manage multiple vehicles, coordinate artillery strikes, and adapt to dynamic battlefield conditions offers hours of strategic depth without overwhelming newcomers.

For WWII enthusiasts and fans of armored warfare, Sherman M4 delivers an engaging, historically grounded experience. Its strong graphics, intuitive controls, and mission variety make it a worthy purchase for anyone looking to relive the armored clashes of WWII from behind the iconic Sherman’s periscope.

Retro Replay Score

7/10