Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Commander Keen: Keen Dreams takes the series’ classic side‐scrolling action and wraps it in a fresh structure centered on an overworld map. Instead of a linear sequence of stages, you traverse a top-down map of Tuberia, selecting which level to tackle next. This choice adds a layer of strategy—you can revisit completed areas to grab missed items or experiment with alternate routes to reach Boobus Tuber’s fortress.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The core platforming mechanics remain familiar: precise jumps, timed hazards, deadly pitfalls, and a roster of vegetable-themed enemies. Rather than wielding a raygun or pogo stick, Keen’s only offensive tool is his “Flower Power” bomb. You lob these special devices to turn enemies into harmless blossoms for a short time, then retrieve them if they land unused. This limited ammo system encourages careful engagement, turning every encounter into a tactical decision.

Levels are sprinkled with keys, extra lives, bonus point orbs, and the elusive magic eyeball that grants a hefty ammo boost and three lives. Finding Boobus Bombs is crucial—only these can damage the final boss—and they’re often guarded by tricky platforming segments or hidden in tucked-away alcoves. The balance between exploration on the map and precision challenges in each stage keeps the gameplay loop engaging and varied.

Despite the simpler combat, Keen Dreams still captures the creative spirit of id Software’s early work. Each region of Tuberia introduces new obstacles—shifting platforms, bouncing springs, and animated plant enemies—that require you to adapt on the fly. Lives are limited, and a single misstep can send you back to the map screen, but the risk-reward structure fuels a satisfying drive to master every level.

Graphics

Graphically, Keen Dreams embraces the bright, cartoon-like visuals of early ’90s PC gaming. The EGA palette delivers a surprisingly vibrant world of pastel-colored soils, oversized fungi, and comical vegetable enemies. While the resolution is low by modern standards, the artistry shines through in each sprite’s distinctive silhouette and expressive movement frames.

The level backgrounds showcase imaginative designs—from twisting vine tunnels to floating plant platforms—giving Tuberia a whimsical yet slightly eerie vibe. Animations are smooth for the era: Keen’s jump arc, walking strides, and bomb throws feel responsive and well-tuned, while enemies bob and bounce in a way that telegraphs their attack patterns effectively.

On the map screen, Keen and the landscape are drawn with simple icons that still manage to communicate important information—completed stages, locked areas, and unexplored zones are each clearly delineated. This clean layout not only looks charming but also makes navigation intuitive, even for newcomers to the franchise.

While you won’t find photo-real textures or dynamic lighting here, the game’s consistent art direction and playful color choices give it a timeless charm. The visual clarity ensures you can quickly assess hazards and platforms, which is essential in a precision platformer. Overall, the graphics serve both style and substance, supporting the gameplay without unnecessary complexity.

Story

The narrative premise of Keen Dreams is delightfully offbeat. Eight-year-old genius Billy “Commander Keen” Blaze has done it all—saved galaxies, outsmarted aliens, and explored cosmic frontiers—but tonight he faces a new challenge at home. His mother insists he eat vegetables, and in retaliation, Keen drifts into a dreamscape where veggies reign supreme.

In the land of Tuberia, sentient vegetables are more than mere produce—they’re living, scheming adversaries under the thumb of the tyrant King Boobus Tuber. He uses a sinister Dream Machine to enslave children in endless produce-fueled nightmares. Keen’s mission: collect Boobus Bombs, storm the Dream Machine, and liberate kidnapped kids.

Though the plot is lighthearted and serves mainly as a framing device, it injects the levels with personality. Each new stage feels like a chapter in this veggie saga, whether you’re navigating giant tomato towers or slippery mushroom fields. The humor—smashing walking carrots or turning foes into daisies—keeps the tone playful and avoids the repetitive trap that some platformers fall into.

For those familiar with the Commander Keen timeline, Keen Dreams slots neatly between Keen Must Die! and Secret of the Oracle. It stands out as a surreal detour, a self-contained adventure born from a child’s protest against brussels sprouts. The story may not be epic, but its imaginative concept and whimsical execution make it memorable.

Overall Experience

Commander Keen: Keen Dreams offers a compact yet rich platforming experience that distinguishes itself within the series. Its map-driven progression and limited ammo mechanics introduce fresh strategic layers, while the absence of the trusty raygun keeps you on your toes. Despite the loss of a direct weapon upgrade path, the Flower Power bombs remain satisfying to use and fit perfectly with the dream motif.

Longtime fans will appreciate the nostalgic trip back to id Software’s shareware era, complete with catchy MIDI tunes and crisp EGA visuals. Newcomers to the franchise can enjoy a standalone adventure that doesn’t require deep knowledge of the Keen saga. The challenge is balanced—difficult enough to be rewarding, yet fair enough that perseverance pays off.

The game’s whimsical setting, quirky enemies, and clever level design make Keen Dreams more than just a placeholder between two major titles. It feels like a love letter to classic platforming, showcasing creativity over raw power. While it may not push technical boundaries, it excels at delivering tight controls, imaginative scenarios, and a breezy dose of childhood nostalgia.

For retro enthusiasts and modern players seeking a taste of ’90s PC charm, Commander Keen: Keen Dreams is a delightful detour into a vegetable-ruled dream world. Its unique mechanics, endearing visuals, and playful story ensure that this short but sweet adventure remains a standout in Commander Keen’s storied history.

Retro Replay Score

6.3/10