Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Phantasie II stays true to the formula established by its predecessor, delivering a classic turn-based RPG experience that will feel immediately familiar to fans of the original. Players assemble a party of up to six adventurers from a roster of character classes, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. Exploration unfolds on a high-level overworld map, where you move your party from town to town, stocking up on supplies and accepting side quests before venturing into the depths of sprawling dungeons.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Combat encounters are frequent and demand careful party management. Battles play out on a simple grid, with actions chosen from an easy-to-navigate menu. While there’s no radical innovation here—the attack, magic, item, and flee commands mirror those of Phantasie—the addition of new monster variety keeps fights from becoming monotonous. Strategic positioning and judicious use of healing spells or restorative items are crucial, especially when facing tougher foes or exploring lower dungeon levels.

Progression in Phantasie II is largely driven by dungeon crawling and quest completion. Characters gain experience points from every victorious battle and can be leveled up to learn new spells or increase combat abilities. Equipment upgrades are found in hidden chests or purchased from blacksmiths in town, encouraging players to revisit earlier areas to take on previously insurmountable challenges. The balance between risk and reward keeps progression satisfying, though veterans of the first game may find the pacing nearly identical.

Graphics

Graphically, Phantasie II offers an aesthetic that is identical to the original title. The game uses 8-bit tile-based graphics to represent towns, wilderness areas, and dungeon corridors. While this style may feel dated compared to contemporary RPGs of its era, it retains a certain nostalgic charm, particularly in the colorful townscapes and enemy sprites.

One of the strengths of Phantasie II’s visual presentation is its readability. Dungeon layouts and monster designs are clear and distinct, making it easy to differentiate friend from foe even when the screen becomes crowded. Animations are minimal—attack and spell effects consist of simple flashes and sprite swaps—but this simplicity helps maintain a steady frame rate on older hardware.

While there are no graphical enhancements or sweeping visual improvements over Phantasie, the consistency in style ensures a cohesive look throughout the entire adventure. If you appreciated the pixel art and iconography of the first game, you’ll feel right at home here. Newcomers, however, may view the visuals as simplistic compared to more modern RPG titles.

Story

Phantasie II picks up the narrative threads left by the original game, once again pitting the adventuring party against the malevolent Dark Lord Nikademus. This time, Nikademus has fashioned an evil orb that curses the idyllic island of Ferronrah, plunging its inhabitants into despair. Your mission is straightforward: gather clues, seek out powerful artifacts, and destroy the orb before its corrupting influence spreads further.

The plot unfolds through dialogue with NPCs in town and cryptic inscriptions found in dungeon chambers. While the storytelling is serviceable, it rarely departs from familiar RPG tropes. You’ll find yourself completing fetch quests, slaying minor lieutenants, and eventually storming the Dark Lord’s stronghold. The narrative’s strength lies in its simplicity—it never overcomplicates the overarching goal—but those looking for deep character development or branching storylines may feel underwhelmed.

Despite its predictable beats, Phantasie II injects enough world-building moments to maintain interest. Lore about Ferronrah’s history and hints at Nikademus’s past ambitions provide context for the journey. Engaging side quests—such as rescuing kidnapped villagers or recovering lost relics—add flavor to the main plot and offer welcome diversions from the central questline.

Overall Experience

Phantasie II is a faithful sequel that delivers more of the same addictive dungeon-crawling RPG action from the original. If you enjoyed Phantasie’s straightforward mechanics, clear interface, and classic pixel art, you’ll find plenty to like here. The game offers dozens of hours of content, a healthy challenge level, and a nostalgic atmosphere that captures the spirit of early computer role-playing.

However, Phantasie II does little to advance the series in terms of innovation. The graphics, gameplay systems, and user interface remain virtually unchanged, which means the title will feel extremely familiar to returning players. While this consistency can be comforting, it may disappoint those hoping for new features or a fresh graphical overhaul.

Ultimately, Phantasie II is best suited for RPG purists and fans of the original who crave more adventures in the world of Ferronrah. Newcomers seeking a deep, modern narrative or cutting-edge visuals might prefer more recent releases. But for players who appreciate solid mechanics, challenging dungeons, and the timeless appeal of 8-bit RPGs, Phantasie II offers a rewarding—and nostalgically charming—experience.

Retro Replay Score

7.8/10