Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Project Firestart’s gameplay delivers a tight, atmospheric experience that still influences modern survival horror titles. From the moment you step aboard the derelict Prometheus, every corridor and maintenance hatch feels alive with tension. You’ll navigate claustrophobic environments with limited ammunition and health supplies, forcing you to make strategic decisions about whether to confront or evade the mutated creatures lurking around every corner.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The game emphasizes exploration and information gathering as much as direct combat. Scattered logs, computer terminals, and environmental clues reveal the tragic backstory of Project Firestart’s failed genetic experiments. This scavenger-hunt mechanic keeps you engaged, since uncovering new data not only enriches the narrative but can also provide vital hints for solving puzzles or locating hidden caches of supplies.

Resource management is at the core of Project Firestart’s challenge. You’ll quickly learn to ration your ammo and medical kits, making each encounter with monstrous adversaries a crucial test of your nerves and tactics. The limited inventory space adds another layer of strategic depth—should you carry extra ammo, or pack more health items? Balancing these choices heightens the suspense and rewards careful planning.

Moreover, the game’s multiple endings add significant replay value. Depending on the information you discover and the survivor you rescue (if any), you’ll witness different final sequences. This branching structure encourages you to revisit the Prometheus with fresh strategies and to pursue every hidden data log, ensuring that no two playthroughs feel identical.

Graphics

While Project Firestart was built for the Commodore 64, its graphical presentation remains impressive for its era. The game employs detailed, hand-drawn sprites and pre-rendered background images to create the illusion of depth and realism aboard the starship. Shadows and lighting effects—though limited by hardware—are cleverly used to obscure threats, keeping you on edge as you venture deeper into the ship.

The muted color palette reinforces the sense of dread, with grays, sickly greens, and rusty reds dominating the scene. Creature designs are equally striking: distorted limbs, dripping tendrils, and unnatural movements give each monster an unsettling presence. Even with a low-resolution display, the animations convey a palpable sense of horror, especially when a creature bursts onto the screen unannounced.

Sound design complements the visuals superbly. Sparse ambient noises—hissing steam, distant bangs, and eerie echoes—lend the Prometheus an oppressive, deserted feel. When the music kicks in during key moments, it’s sparse but effective, heightening your awareness without overwhelming the sense of isolation. In a game where every creak of the floor could signal danger, the audio cues play a critical role in building tension.

Given the technical constraints of mid-1980s hardware, Project Firestart’s audiovisual package punches well above its weight. The combination of atmospheric visuals and carefully crafted soundscapes achieves a level of immersion that many contemporary titles still struggle to match, proving that imaginative design can triumph over limited resources.

Story

Set in the year 2066, Project Firestart casts you as a lone agent sent to investigate the silence of the mining ship Prometheus. What begins as a routine reconnaissance mission quickly unravels into a nightmare, as you discover that the genetic enhancements designed to create unbreakable miners have instead spawned lethal, sentient abominations. This premise, ahead of its time, laid the groundwork for countless survival horror narratives that followed.

The narrative unfolds through environmental storytelling and scattered documents rather than extended cutscenes. Terminal entries, personal logs, and audio recordings piece together the motivations and mistakes of the scientists behind Project Firestart. Each fragment you find sheds new light on the ethical and moral dilemmas that drove the experiment—and the horrific consequences of tampering with nature’s design.

Multiple endings provide closure—or further ambiguity—depending on how thoroughly you explore and whom you choose to save. These branching outcomes compel you to delve deeper into the ship’s secrets, whether that means deciphering cryptic lab notes or navigating hidden maintenance shafts to locate a critical survivor. The satisfaction of piecing together the full story across successive playthroughs is a major highlight.

Even by today’s standards, the plot’s pacing is remarkably tight. There’s a constant progression of discovery and escalation, punctuated by sudden, heart-pounding encounters. The dark, claustrophobic setting and minimal dialogue allow your imagination to fill in the gaps, making every unseen noise or distant silhouette feel like a direct threat to your character’s survival.

Overall Experience

Project Firestart stands as a landmark title in the history of survival horror, offering a compact yet deeply engaging experience. Its blend of exploration, limited resources, and environmental storytelling creates a sense of vulnerability that few games of its time—let alone modern ones—can replicate. The intense atmosphere keeps you invested from start to finish, and the multiple endings encourage replayability long after you’ve glimpsed one conclusion.

The game’s pace is deliberately measured, allowing tension to build slowly between each harrowing encounter. This design choice may feel archaic to players accustomed to constant action, but it rewards patience and careful observation. By contrast, the occasional frantic battles for survival feel all the more meaningful, as you grapple with the consequences of every shot fired or path taken.

While the Commodore 64’s controls and interface may feel dated to new audiences, they remain functional and intuitive. The simplicity of the mechanics serves the game’s purpose: to immerse you in the Prometheus’s halls, not to distract with complex button combinations. Modern players with a love for retro titles will appreciate the authenticity of this experience, and newcomers to vintage gaming can still find plenty to admire.

Ultimately, Project Firestart is a must-play for anyone interested in the roots of survival horror. Its pioneering approach to atmosphere, story delivery, and player choice laid the foundation for an entire genre. Whether you’re a retro enthusiast or a horror aficionado seeking to trace the lineage of your favorite modern franchises, Project Firestart offers a tense, satisfying journey into darkness that remains unforgettable.

Retro Replay Score

8/10