Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Super Bowl delivers an intriguing action/strategy hybrid that faithfully recreates the lopsided triumph of Chicago over New England in Super Bowl XX. As the offensive commander, you pick from a library of long and short passing plays, running schemes, and special teams options. The clarity in play selection ensures even newcomers to sports sims won’t be overwhelmed, while veterans can dive deep into situational analysis and clock management.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The mechanics of kicking and punting add a tactile layer of engagement. Strength and accuracy are determined by timing your fire button press, giving each field goal or punt the tension of a real match. While you cannot steer the ball’s trajectory mid-kick, the risk-reward dynamic of judging wind and distance brings a satisfying authenticity, and punts can only be returned when cleanly caught on the full, just like in the big game.

On offense, the game shifts into precise micro-management once you snap the ball. A flashing cursor floats over potential receivers, and pressing fire locks in the target—you can then assume direct control of any player on the pitch. This freedom to switch focus mid-play replicates the chaos of live action, whether you’re threading a pass to a streaking wideout or plowing through for a quarterback sneak.

Defensive duties are equally nuanced. You start by choosing one of four base formations—ranging from heavy blitz packages to zone-heavy alignments—before assigning individual markers or a shadow to follow the ball carrier. Once the snap occurs, you can seize control of any defender, or hold down fire to cycle between players. This blend of strategic pre-play planning and in-play adaptability gives the defense a real voice, inviting you to react on the fly and thwart big-yardage threats.

Graphics

Visually, Super Bowl on the Commodore 64 and Spectrum sports crisp sprites and a clean playing field that puts the focus squarely on the action. Player avatars are simple yet distinct, and the scrolling gridiron gives ample room for breakaway runs and deep passes. The scoreboard and sideline graphics are kept minimal, but they deliver essential information at a glance without cluttering the main view.

Animation is particularly smooth on the C64 version, where each tackle and catch feels fluid thanks to generous frame rates. The Spectrum release—limited to practice plays for solo gamers—retains the same sprite work but can exhibit a bit more flicker during heavy traffic on the line of scrimmage. Even so, the designers strike an admirable balance between performance and visual fidelity on both platforms.

Special teams sequences shine thanks to the dynamic camera shifts when you launch a punt or kick a field goal. You’ll zoom in slightly to gauge your aim and power meter, then zoom back out to follow the ball’s flight and any potential return. It’s a small touch, but it amplifies the drama of game-deciding moments and underscores the hybrid action/strategy ethos that defines the title.

Story

Super Bowl doesn’t feature a narrative in the traditional sense—it’s a sports sim, after all—but it builds its own drama through faithful recreations of historic matchups. By placing you in the roles that defined Super Bowl XX, the game evokes the thrill of that blowout victory while allowing you to reimagine the contest’s key moments. Will your Patriots hold on better than the originals? The canvas is yours to rewrite.

Even without a scripted storyline, rosters and playbooks feel authentic, drawing on the styles and tendencies of early ’80s NFL squads. The dichotomy between Chicago’s powerhouse ground game and New England’s aerial ambitions surfaces in your strategic choices, making each play call feel like part of a larger tactical puzzle.

The lack of licensed player names might disappoint hardcore fans seeking full immersion, but the generic roster still captures personality through differing speed, strength, and pass-catching attributes. As you progress, the ebb and flow of momentum in each simulated quarter crafts its own narrative arc—underdog rallies, goal-line stands, and special-teams heroics coalesce into an emergent story unique to your skill and decisions.

Overall Experience

Super Bowl strikes a compelling balance between arcade-style immediacy and deep strategic planning. Its core loop—selecting plays, executing timing-based kicks, and jumping into direct control of players—remains engrossing well after dozens of matches. The inclusion of AI opponents on the C64 ensures solo gamers can enjoy full matches, while Spectrum owners at least get to sharpen their play-calling skills in practice mode.

While modern sports titles boast hyper-realistic graphics and massive rosters, Super Bowl’s retro charm lies in its simplicity and focus. There’s no menu bloat or endless stat screens—just you, the gridiron, and a compelling simulation of football’s finest moments. Veteran players will appreciate the subtle depth, and newcomers will find the learning curve inviting rather than punishing.

Whether you’re a fan of classic football sims or simply curious about early sports gaming, Super Bowl offers an engaging experience that stands the test of time. Its blend of strategic play-calling, live-action control, and faithful homage to Super Bowl XX creates a package that remains both nostalgic and surprisingly fresh, making it a worthy addition to any retro gaming collection or sports enthusiast’s library.

Retro Replay Score

7/10