Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Aces: Collection Series delivers an impressive range of flight and naval simulators, each with its own distinct playstyle and mechanics. From the low-altitude strafing runs in A-10 Tank Killer and Silent Thunder: A-10 Tank Killer II to the stealthy depths of Command: Aces of the Deep, the collection covers a broad tactical spectrum. Whether you’re dodging flak over Hanoi or tracking convoys in the Atlantic, each scenario demands attention to instruments, environmental factors, and mission objectives.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The six core games—A-10 Tank Killer, Command: Aces of the Deep, Aces of the Pacific (with its WWII: 1946 Expansion Disk), Aces Over Europe, Red Baron (plus its Mission Builder), and Silent Thunder—offer varied campaign structures. The Pacific and European air war simulators present dynamic, branching campaigns based on historical operations, while Red Baron’s mission builder lets players craft and share their own WWI dogfights. This blend of scripted and user-generated content greatly enhances replayability.

Controls across the collection are richly detailed and realistic, catering to enthusiasts who relish fine-tuning joystick sensitivity, keyboard mapping, and rudder pedals. Beginners may face a steep learning curve—especially in managing A-10’s complex weapon loadouts or executing precise torpedo launches in Command: Aces of the Deep. However, extensive tutorials and mission briefings help smooth the ramp-up, making each simulator approachable with time and practice.

Another highlight is the historical context integrated into gameplay. Briefings often reference real-world tactics and aircraft performance, and many missions replicate famous battles and patrols. This authentic framing deepens immersion and rewards players who invest in mastering each vehicle’s unique flight or navigation characteristics.

Graphics

While dated by modern standards, the graphics in Aces: Collection Series capture the essence of early to mid-1990s simulation visuals. Terrain textures are blocky, yet recognizable, with rolling hills, runways, and island chains rendered clearly enough to plan attack runs and evasive maneuvers. Water effects in Command: Aces of the Deep show simple wave patterns and reflections, lending credibility to submarine periscope views and surface ship silhouettes.

Aces of the Pacific and Aces Over Europe pioneered flat-shaded 3D scenery, complete with dynamic weather systems that impact visibility and flight handling. Cloud layers and haze effects create dramatic skyboxes, while horizon lines and sea states fluctuate realistically. Red Baron’s biplanes are rendered with polygonal wings and undersides, and Silent Thunder improves on lighting and explosion animations, adding depth to ground-attack sorties.

Despite the low polygon counts and minimal texture mapping, the collection’s visual consistency across six disparate titles is commendable. Each game retains its original look and feel, preserving the historic charm of Dynamix’s pioneering engines. Even mission loader screens, cockpit panels, and HUD elements remain faithful to the era, reinforcing the nostalgic appeal for veteran sim pilots.

Players running the collection on modern PCs will find compatibility modes and DOSBox wrappers smooth out any display issues. Upscaling tools can sharpen the visual output, though purists may prefer the authentic resolution to relive the classic aesthetic as it was originally experienced.

Story

As a simulation anthology, Aces: Collection Series doesn’t unfold a single narrative but rather offers a tapestry of historically inspired campaigns. In Aces of the Pacific, you follow the air war from Pearl Harbor to Okinawa, assuming the role of Allied or Japanese pilots in multi-mission arcs. Each sortie ties into broader strategic objectives, providing a loose storyline of advancing air supremacy and island-hopping progress.

Command: Aces of the Deep presents an even grittier tale, casting players as submarine commanders under strict communication silence. The mission briefings and patrol orders evoke a sense of isolation and cat-and-mouse tension, while after-action reports read like debriefs from real U-boat skippers. This narrative approach effectively conveys the psychological and tactical challenges of underwater warfare.

WWI enthusiasts will appreciate Red Baron’s atmospheric scenarios, where trench warfare and early aerial combat techniques shape the drama. The inclusion of the Mission Builder extends storytelling possibilities, allowing you to script personalized dogfights and ground-target missions set against the Western Front. Meanwhile, the supplemental historical booklet—covering aviation milestones from 1903 to 1939—adds context and human interest, weaving pilot biographies and aircraft designs into the overall experience.

Although none of the games emphasize character-driven cutscenes or voice acting, the mission-based storytelling, period-accurate briefings, and documented historical events provide an engrossing backdrop. For players seeking cinematic plots, the appeal may be limited, but for simulation purists, the depth and authenticity of each theater’s narrative are highly rewarding.

Overall Experience

Aces: Collection Series stands out as a time capsule for simulation aficionados, combining six award-winning Dynamix titles on two CDs with a wealth of bonus materials. The package’s value is remarkable: you get a comprehensive survey of aerial and naval combat spanning two world wars and beyond, along with supplemental histories of pioneering aviators and their machines.

Installation is straightforward, thanks to the bundled auto-configuring installers and compatibility tweaks. Whether you’re a long-time fan rekindling past glories or a newcomer curious about the roots of modern flight sims, the collection strikes a balance between accessibility and depth. Multiplayer options—once hosted via IPX networks—can be revived through LAN tunneling tools, offering vintage dogfight sessions with friends.

The learning curve rewards patience, as each simulator requires mastery of its unique systems and instrumentation. Yet the sense of accomplishment after completing a carrier takeoff in A-10 Tank Killer or sinking a battleship in Command: Aces of the Deep is profound. The catalog’s breadth ensures there’s always a new challenge, from high-altitude strafing runs to perilous submarine patrols.

In today’s era of hyper-realistic visuals and motion cockpit rigs, Aces: Collection Series may feel quaint. However, its historic significance, diverse gameplay modes, and enduring mod community ensure it remains a must-have for anyone interested in the evolution of combat simulation. The package’s cohesive presentation—pairing solid gameplay with period visuals and educational context—makes it a rewarding purchase for both collectors and active players alike.

Retro Replay Score

null/10