Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

El-Fish centers on an intuitive catch-and-breed system that invites players to collect tropical fish, experiment with genetic crossovers, and observe real-time mutations. At its core, the game presents a straightforward loop: capture wild specimens, pair them in a virtual “tank lab,” and see what surprising traits emerge. Each new generation can produce unexpected color patterns, fin shapes, or behaviors, giving a constant sense of discovery.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The genetic algorithm underpinning El-Fish is surprisingly deep for its era. You can fine-tune parent selection, adjust mutation rates, and even isolate specific traits you want to emphasize. Over time, you learn to predict outcomes and breed increasingly exotic variants—everything from neon-striped angel fish to sinuous, ribbon-like swimmers. This system feels both scientific and playful, encouraging experimentation without punishing failure.

Beyond breeding, the game allows full creative control over your aquarium environment. You choose plants, gravel, backdrops, and even the layout to craft an immersive underwater world. Placement is drag-and-drop simple, and the game’s interface guides you through options for lighting and camera angles. Building the perfect display can become as engaging as breeding the fish themselves.

Rounding out the gameplay is a built-in music generator that lets you select from eight distinct styles. Whether you prefer calming classical riffs or more experimental electronic textures, background tunes adapt dynamically as you design your tank. It’s a small but delightful touch that reinforces the game’s blend of simulation and creative sandbox.

Graphics

Every single fish, plant, and scenery element in El-Fish is procedurally generated, resulting in visual variety that feels fresh every playthrough. The genetic engine combines shapes, colors, and movement patterns into unique sprites that never look quite the same twice. Even if two players breed the same “ink-blotch” pattern, slight algorithmic differences make each specimen distinct.

Animations are smooth and lifelike, with fish gliding through the water in gentle arcs, schooling when they detect others, or darting away if startled. The simulated physics lend a surprising sense of weight and fluidity—fins flutter convincingly, bubbles drift upward, and plants sway realistically. This level of visual immersion was groundbreaking at the time and still holds up as a soothing screensaver-like display.

Backgrounds and gravel beds follow the same generative principles, so you can craft anything from a sunlit coral reef to a deep-sea grotto. The palette options let you shift moods instantly: dusky purples for a twilight tank, vibrant oranges for a sunset effect, or monochrome charcoal for a minimalist look. These elements blend seamlessly with your fish creations to form a cohesive visual tableau.

Story

El-Fish forgoes a traditional narrative in favor of an open-ended creative journey. There’s no protagonist, no quest markers, and no villain to defeat. Instead, the “story” emerges organically as you catalog your collections and watch your designs evolve. Each fish carries its own backstory of lineage and mutation, inviting you to imagine how it came to be.

You effectively become both scientist and artist, crafting a personalized chronicle of aquatic life. Some players keep detailed logs of breeding experiments, treating each new strain as a chapter in their ongoing saga. Others focus on the aesthetic narrative, designing themed tanks that tell wordless stories—perhaps a sunken temple overtaken by luminescent flora and ghostly fish.

The generative soundtrack further shapes this emergent narrative, adapting to your controls and reinforcing your creative mood. A gentle piano motif may underscore a meditative breeding session, while a pulsing ambient track heightens tension when you’re coaxing out a rare mutation. In El-Fish, the story you experience is entirely up to you.

Overall Experience

El-Fish shines as a tranquil sandbox that rewards curiosity and creativity rather than reflexes or high scores. Its patient pace and boundless customization options make it ideal for players who enjoy world-building, digital pet care, or generative art. If you’ve ever dreamed of running your own virtual aquarium without the constraints of real-world biology, El-Fish delivers in spades.

That said, the lack of structured goals or challenges can feel unfocused to those seeking a clear sense of progression. The interface, while user-friendly, shows its age in spotty tooltips and occasional menu quirks. Modern players may miss more robust tutorials or community sharing features that would streamline the breeding process.

Ultimately, El-Fish is less a game and more an open canvas—a peaceful digital aquarium you curate at your own pace. For hobbyists, artists, and anyone intrigued by procedural systems, it remains a charming, endlessly replayable experience. If you value creative freedom and enjoy watching emergent behavior unfold, El-Fish is well worth springing for.

Retro Replay Score

6.8/10