Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

HeroQuest + HeroQuest: Return of the Witch Lord brings the classic dungeon-crawl board game to life on PC, preserving the turn-based tactical combat that made the tabletop original so compelling. Players choose from a roster of hero classes—Barbarian, Dwarf, Elf, and Wizard—and navigate their party through labyrinthine dungeons filled with traps, treasure, and monsters. Movement is grid-based, and action points determine your ability to explore, attack, or cast spells. This faithful adaptation ensures that each decision—be it swinging a sword at a Goblin or probing for hidden doors—carries weight.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The user interface is intuitive for its era, with simple point-and-click commands for issuing orders and managing inventory. The game’s pacing is deliberate, encouraging careful planning over button-mashing. As you progress through the base game’s 25 quests, resource management becomes increasingly critical: supplies of food, healing potions, and torches can spell the difference between victory and a hasty retreat. Cooperation between hero abilities—such as the Wizard’s Fire of Wrath spell complementing the Barbarian’s melee prowess—creates satisfying synergies and memorable team moments.

Return of the Witch Lord expands on this foundation with 13 new quests that raise both the stakes and the difficulty. The introduction of new monster types, augmented traps, and timed events compels even veteran adventurers to rethink their strategies. The expansion also adds novel mechanics such as artifact forging and reputation checks, giving your heroes a sense of progression beyond mere loot collection. Overall, the compilation delivers a robust, varied gameplay experience, balancing nostalgia for board-game fans with strategic depth for newcomers.

Graphics

Visually, HeroQuest’s DOS release is a time capsule of early 1990s VGA artistry. The top-down isometric perspective presents dungeons and hallways with crisp, hand-drawn tiles, while animated sprites bring enemies and heroes to life. Though the color palette is limited compared to modern standards, clever shading and well-designed textures evoke the look of carved stones, flickering torchlight, and hidden alcoves. The minimalist interface keeps the view uncluttered, allowing you to focus on the action.

The expansion retains the original engine and art style but introduces new tilesets and character portraits that subtly refresh the visual experience. Return of the Witch Lord’s environments feel darker and more ominous, from crypts littered with skeletal remains to haunted swamps shrouded in mist. New monster sprites—such as Wraiths, Gargoyles, and the titular Witch Lord himself—stand out with distinct silhouettes and animations that heighten the sense of danger. While there are no high-definition upgrades, the art direction remains consistent and charmingly evocative.

Loading screens and menus employ decorative, fantasy-themed borders that reinforce the tabletop heritage of the source material. Sound effects—sword clashes, monster growls, trap springs—are functional rather than cinematic, but they punctuate the atmosphere effectively. Occasional MIDI tracks underscore key moments without overwhelming the quiet tension of exploration. In sum, the graphics and audio marry simplicity with character, preserving the board game’s visual identity in digital form.

Story

The narrative framework of HeroQuest is straightforward: the evil wizard Zargon (or Morcar, depending on regional naming) seeks domination of the realm, and it’s up to your band of heroes to thwart his nefarious plans. The base game’s 25 quests unfold as self-contained adventures—rescue missions, artifact hunts, boss battles—strung together by Zargon’s growing menace. Dialogue is sparse, but evocative scenario introductions provide enough context to fuel player imagination and role-playing flair.

Return of the Witch Lord picks up where the original leaves off, elevating the stakes with a personal vendetta and an expanding cast of allies and enemies. The Witch Lord, once vanquished, seeks resurrection through dark rituals, compelling your heroes to chase down fragments of a shattered relic. This arc introduces recurring NPCs, branching quest paths, and moral choices—such as whether to spare a fallen foe in exchange for hidden knowledge. These elements lend emotional weight to an otherwise straightforward hack-and-slash formula.

While neither title rivals a modern RPG in narrative complexity, the compilation excels in providing a loose framework that encourages player-created stories. Dungeon masters of old will appreciate the digital faithful adaptation, and solo adventurers will find enough variety to keep their imaginations engaged. Each new map and encounter in the expansion feels like a fresh chapter, ensuring that the overall saga feels cohesive and rewarding.

Overall Experience

As a bundled release for DOS, HeroQuest + Return of the Witch Lord stands out as the definitive way to experience this classic franchise on PC. The compilation’s greatest strength lies in its authentic replication of the beloved board game, right down to the suspense of opening a new map tile or drawing a hidden trap card—translated perfectly into a digital format. The expansion pack’s additional content ensures that you’ll spend dozens of hours exploring, looting, and strategizing.

Nostalgia is a powerful draw, but this release goes beyond mere fan service. Its deliberate pacing and strategic depth make it accessible to newcomers who may never have touched the original board game. While the graphics and sound are dated by today’s standards, they possess a quaint charm that modern remakes often miss. If you value gameplay substance over flash, you’ll find much to admire here.

Whether you’re reliving childhood memories or discovering classic dungeon-crawl design for the first time, HeroQuest + Return of the Witch Lord offers a satisfying, campaign-length adventure. Its modular quest structure promotes replayability, and the expansion’s heightened challenges ensure that skilled players will be tested. In an era saturated with action RPGs, this compilation reminds us of the joys of turn-based tactics, cooperative play, and the simple thrill of dungeon exploration.

Retro Replay Score

7.5/10